Risqué jokes: are they simply harmless fun?
By Marcus Cassop-Thompson
What are we to make of the risqué joke? In writing this piece I have had to ask myself a lot of questions and follow-up questions to try and understand the nature of jokes and some of the relevant factors concerning taboo, offensiveness and meaning attributed to jokes. No easy task.
I never wanted to try to dissect when precisely a joke is too much; a theory of jokes is beyond the remit of this article. But in attempting to analyse what is risqué and how this relates to a wider context, I realised that maybe considering the question we should ask is a lot more pertinent.
So with this implicit risk of over-philosophising noted let’s try and think about the dangerous jokes that we seem to have a love-hate relationship with?
Obviously the first thing we may wonder is: what do we mean by a risqué joke? It is obvious that all jokes exist on a continuum, from Christmas cracker jokes at the innocent end to vacuous slurs which take pleasure in hurting others. To me, risqué implies coming up against some social taboo; it is something one would not normally say to a teacher or a colleague. While it may be provocative, risqué jokes could have a function of social commentary, irony or satire that keeps them from becoming totally void or simply sadistic.
Along this continuum there is the increasing chance that someone will be offended by the joke and think it inappropriate. This is where the disagreements begin. Maybe they think the joke serves no purpose or that the subject matter should not be the target of humour. Others – including myself – may push back and say that humour, even if dark, can fulfil an analytic role – very often a good comedian can make a point of view become clear.
Due to this disagreement, and if we believe in some form of objective truth, we can appreciate that just because someone is offended does not necessarily mean that the joke IS bad in any platonic sense.
So when exactly does a joke cross the line (because they certainly can) and become racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic or prejudiced against the disabled or poor?
I think the difficulty in saying where exactly this line should be drawn is due to the complex nature of jokes. One thing I do believe is that a joke’s bare content – the words on paper – is insufficient to discern its true function and meaning.
Jokes very often employ complex linguistic devices such as sarcasm or satire and very often a jokes provocative and stark content can be used to imply an obvious subtext that stands in opposition to the original joke.
This last point plays on the idea that “we are on the comedian’s wavelength and understand what he really thinks.” This background context of the person telling the joke is important. We can see this if we consider the classic “I can make this joke because I myself am…” Whether this be black, gay, northern, or French. (I am northern just to be clear!) Here we appreciate that a joke is a joke and that there is no ill intent.
To highlight the complexity of a joke and its context I leave you with a thought experiment: Can you think of a situation in which two people independently come up with a joke which contains the same words, in the same order, but have a difference in context, and have different underlying beliefs? Is it possible in the telling of these jokes that one could be offensive and the other not?
Illustration: Olivia Howcroft
