The Ashers bakery discrimination case is not just open and shut
By Marcus Cassop-Thompson
As students, most of us are familiar with the deceptively simplistic worldview of textbook writers. They imagine that everyone acts rationally and only in their own self-interest or they assume in physiology that everyone is a 70kg man. Of course most of us know that the real world isn’t that black and white. Yet, following the interesting, albeit somewhat comical case surrounding the moral and politico-legal parameters of icing cakes, it really seemed as if a textbook scenario to rival the trolley-problem had come alive and collided head-on with the real world.
Here, LGBT activist Gareth Lee had brought legal action against the MacArthur family- the Christian owners of small family-run business Ashers bakery- for failing to supply a Bert and Ernie cake (for an LGBT function) with the slogan “Support Gay Marriage.” For Lee this was a case of discrimination, while the MacArthur’s maintained they were prepared to bake a cake but simply objected to and were not willing to ice the message stated: believing it to be sinful and in breach of their freedom to practice their religion. The family claimed the issues of Lee’s sexuality, political activism or the event the cake was intended for, were not important and that they would have similarly refused to bake the same message for a heterosexual customer.
But last Monday’s news that Northern Ireland’s court of appeal upheld an earlier court’s ruling in favour of Gareth Lee has polarized opinion, and should raise a lot of questions for anyone who thinks this is a clear cut case. Even Human rights campaigner and LGBT activist Peter Tatchell flip-flopped, initially supporting Lee but coming to back Ashers. Admittedly the technical question of whether Ashers were in breach of the law is a matter for legal experts and the courts to disagree on, and far beyond my capacity to ascertain, but the deeper question of whether the ruling was just from a wider ethical standpoint remains –to me at least- elusive.
What should the law be, is an altogether more difficult question. A majority of people seem to agree that public institutions should not have the right to withhold services, but opinions largely differed on whether (and for what reasons) private businesses should be obliged to fulfil certain requests.
For me, this is what makes this case particularly interesting to discuss; as rather than consider this question in the abstract, many people’s initial leanings were based more on their propensity to sympathize with the particulars of the case: Christianity or LGBT activism. But once you start to play around with parameters (as any good textbook would) things seem more tricky.
Should a same-sex couple have to make a cake saying “don’t support gay marriage”? Should a Muslim baker or printer be forced to produce images of Muhammed? Or should a Jewish owned publisher be forced to print books denying the Holocaust? And while we may think a small cake shop is inconsequential, what would we think if a large cooperation made such decisions? As was the case of Hobby Lobby in the U.S.
In reading about Ashers I have been decidedly on the fence. A libertarian voice in me whispers: let business withhold services and allow customers to decide. While another says: in setting up a business or entering a job sometimes you know what may be asked of you, and if it’s not to your liking don’t go into it. I.e. don’t be a vegan and apply to work in the butchers. Or maybe its just more simple to make a blanket rule: services cannot be withheld on the basis of conscientious objection.
Trying to think all situations through, it seems evident that it’s hard to please all of the people all of the time. While I still remain unresolved, what Ashers highlights to me is the limitation of legislation to satisfy all parties, and the deeper lesson of the naivety of believing any system could be perfect. I suppose what I’m saying is: we can’t have our cake and eat it too.
Photograph by Adrian Scottow via Flickr and Creative Commons
