We need to better understand what it is to be intersex

By Marcus Cassop-Thompson

Looking back on the Rio Olympics, it is clear that names like Phelps, Ennis-Hill, Bolt and Trott will be burned into our consciousness for years to come, whilst others will slowly fade back into the obscurity they had previously occupied just a month ago. Yet one name may be remembered for slightly more complex reasons; that of the 800m gold medallist Caster Semenya.

While the name may be new to some, to those with a longer term interest in track and field, Semenya’s story is a protracted and complex one, filled with speculation, misconception and a fair amount of controversy. All of which could do with revisiting. Rising to prominence ahead of the 2009 athletics World Championships in Berlin, Semenya established herself as an emerging track star. Clinching the world title she looked set to dominate the sport for years to come. Yet the IAAF (athletics’ governing body) soon asked Semenya and her coaching team to undergo a gender verification test.

All of which could do with revisiting. Rising to prominence ahead of the 2009 athletics World Championships in Berlin, Semenya established herself as an emerging track star. Clinching the world title she looked set to dominate the sport for years to come. Yet the IAAF (athletics’ governing body) soon asked Semenya and her coaching team to undergo a gender verification test.

Leaving the public and media floundering as to exactly what this meant, it precipitated the emergence into the public psyche of the rare and poorly understood world of intersex medical conditions. From Berlin to Rio, Semenya’s story has evolved and raised its head time and time again. But with most people’s interest in track and field contained to major events, a firm grip on the details and a full understanding of the Semenya saga seems- to me at least- missing. Many have taken to writing ‘around’ the issue, engaged in a tense meta-discussion, without dealing with any fundamentals. Yet, I have found it difficult, in my own reading, to come across a piece with a direct attempt at science communication. It’s easy to understand why, intersex medical conditions (and their relation to sport) are no easy thing to summarise, and in writing this, I realised just how limited and myopic an overview would be.

it’s not just that intersex people are in the middle of the sex spectrum, in some ways they can be all over the place

With that in mind the first thing to clear up is a few misconceptions. Although complying with a gender test, the results are, as with any medical information, unknown to the public. Early reports that Semenya had internal testes or testosterone levels three times that of an average woman are still unverified. What does seem clear is that Semenya was placed on an androgen (male sex hormone) suppressing drug, in line with the 2011 IAAF ruling on hyperandrogenic women. Since then the media have took to using the word ‘hyperandrogenism’ to describe Semenya’s condition. But it is important to note that hyperandrogenism is not in and of itself a diagnosis – merely a state of having excessively high androgen levels that can have many causes.

Intersex conditions are hard to speak of in generalised terms. All have different causes, levels of degree and characteristic features; but all share the commonality of  having a body whose anatomical, physiological or endocrinological profile either transverses or seems to occupy simultaneously the categories of male and female.

At the moment of fertilisation, the early embryo possesses a wealth of information within its chromosomes; an instruction manual to make a human. This developing foetus is then diverted down one of two possible paths. The presence of an XY genotype, diverts it down a path developing testes and a penis, and it will therefore be called a ‘boy’. Without the Y however, the XX will take the foetus down a sort of ‘default pathway’ and it will be born with a uterus and called a ‘girl’. These pathways are for the most part discrete and highly ordered, but that isn’t always the case.

Sometimes, despite an XY genotype, the failure of the signal pathway can entail a complete or partial reversion of the default setting. Conversely, and slightly more complex, an XX genotype can be diverted down a path whereby once again there is a partial or complete alteration to the body from what we would normally expect. In her interesting and informative TED talk ‘Is Anatomy Destiny’, Alice Dreger (historian of anatomy and patient advocate) rightly points out that while we often think of biological sex to be clear-cut, it can sometimes be difficult to pin down: ‘it’s not just that intersex people are in the middle of the sex spectrum, in some ways they can be all over the place.’

Dreger describes her patient advocacy as pertaining to ‘people who have body types that challenge social norms.’ Whether that be co-joined twins, people with dwarfism or those with atypical sex. In sport, where divisions along biological sex lines remain important for obvious reasons, intersex conditions really do present a difficult challenge for the athletes themselves, regulating bodies and sports fans. While it is well understood the breadth and depth of physiological difference biological sex entails, the limited and emerging understanding of intersex conditions (and where they lie) present many empirical and conceptual gaps that only time will fill.

Semenya’s story truly is a challenging one for sport.  We should not, however, try to claim that this is a non-issue, or to deflect attention away from the heart of the matter. It is only by seeking clarity and sticking to the evidence on the question ‘if and how intersex conditions affect physical performance?’, that we can make sport fair for all.

Photograph: Jon Connell