Harambe, and the meaning of tragedy
By Marcus Cassop-Thompson
The news of the shooting of Harambe, a 17 year old gorilla, at Cincinnati Zoo after a 3 year old boy fell into his enclosure has caused uproar from animal rights activists and sparked a heated debate between animal behaviour experts, zoo keepers and members of the public.
Falling into a moat within the gorilla enclosure, the splashing soon attracted the attention of the large silverback who proceeded to briefly inspect the child, while onlookers – noticing the child – Â watched helplessly in horror. Shouts to alert park rangers began and video footage was gathered by nervous members of the public.
This rapidly evolving situation seemed to demand a quick decision. Opinions both within the moment and after the event vary from the gorilla seeming to be unaggressive until screams from the crowd caused him to panic and pull the child across the moat. Some say the gorilla was attempting to protect the child, others perceived this as an aggressive act. Whether the gorilla was simply interested in the child and what his behaviour seemed to indicate is – in the long run – for experts to decide. Some point to the high intelligence of gorillas while others emphasise their immense strength and how easily they can kill.
But while we can all sit and debate about the ethics and mistakes that may or may not have been made by parents, onlookers and zookeepers, it’s easy to forget the reality of being in a high stakes, rapidly changing situation.
I’m a fierce defender of animal rights and committed vegetarian. For me the needless killing of animals, especially higher primates is a terrible sign of how far from perfection we are; but in the end I agree with the decision the zoo-keepers made. While thought experiments are useful tools to tease out our ethical intuitions here was a real case of an ethical dilemma. For me the gorilla and the child both are worthy of rights and consideration.
But in an online discussion that has been highly polarised, how are we the react emotionally to this tragic story? Because tragedy is the only word that can truly describe what happened.
Philosopher and Classicist, Martha Nussbaum reflected on the meaning of tragedy as its reflection to the ethical life whilst considering the tragedy of Agamemnon. Agamemnon, a king, going into battle in Troy has angered the gods who then demand the sacrifice of his own daughter, otherwise his army will be defeated and his kingdom be lost. He cries out:
“A heavy doom is disobedience, but heavy, too, if I shall rend my own child, the adornment of my house, polluting my father’s hands with streams of slaughtered maidens blood close by the alter. Which of these is without evils?”
And so we have a situation where two values, two commitments have come into conflict. For Nussbaum tragedy only occurs when we care deeply about more than one thing, and circumstances lead to us not being able to fully attend to both. “Tragedy only happens when we are trying to live well.”
Here whatever choice we make seems to suggest something terrible will have happened, and this emotional response indicates not our failure to be ethical and moral but instead reveals our pain in choosing and our true virtue.
Photograph: Redsilverj on Youtube via Creative Commons
