An appeal for freedom of speech

By Marcus Cassop-Thompson

Universities in one sense were always a part of my life. Woven into some of my earliest childhood memories were days when I’d follow my dad around at work, visiting his office, or the library. My first experience of a university class was around 4 years old, only able to vaguely grasp that a university was a place of learning and ideas. Yet, this seemed to stick with me as I grew up.

Today there are more universities, more people going to them, and the motivation for going has similarly multiplied and shifted. But are the values that universities traditionally stand for eroding? Observing events such as those seen at Yale, and the Christakis’s, Missouri or Oberlin College has made me wonder about free speech, but it was the controversy surrounding the attempt to stop Germaine Greer that finally fixed my attention on this conversation. With some minor details changed Peter Tatchell, Richard Dawkins, Julie Bindle, Milo Yiannopolos all suffered a similar fate to Greer. To keep up with the news I had to learn a new vocabulary: safe-spaces, trigger warnings, SJW, regressive, micro-aggression. At the same time a similar conversation was and is evolving with people describing a feeling of a split occurring within the left.

The interesting thing to me is that the blame was being levelled at a certain force within the ‘left’ by another faction on the ‘left.’ Is this term even useful anymore? Those who hope to preserve free speech certainly cannot define themselves through this prism of thought.

Of course as a young person, I’m still trying to work out exactly what I think, which is why the principle that must be defended is challenging what we see as bad ideas with good ideas instead of suppressing speech. Despite how uncomfortable some things might feel. Someone else’s right to speak is also my right to hear it. There may be some difficulty in pointing to what exactly binds people who seek – whether explicitly or not – to shut down speech. But the emergence of trigger warnings and safe spaces is something that should make us all think, as well as more frankly odd behaviour such as jazz-hands replacing clapping, air horns being used to drown out speakers, pointing and raising hands being ‘aggressive’ as well as demanding the resignation of academic staff for voicing differing opinions. People asked: are our generation more sensitive and intolerant to opinions we don’t like? Are we coddled? Too emotional?

But finally this developing trend collided with the popular world surrounding Stephen Fry and the BAFTAs and a joke between old friends. After a whirlwind of ridiculous backlash on twitter Fry left the social media site. In the following weeks Fry appeared on Dave Rubin’s ‘Rubin Report’ to discuss free speech and what he saw as elements of a hypersensitive generation, in the context of recent campus controversies. The 11 minute 28 seconds interview soon gained a lot of media attention, with forensic analysis based on words Fry made within the last minute of the show.

Being a fan of the Rubin Report I watched the interview from start to finish before it gained the attention of the media. Without adding to further and unessecary dissection of what Fry actually said, in writing this I have had to re-listen to the interview several times. Admittedly the last few seconds are confusing in isolation and to me represent an obvious and genuine case of miscommunication as Fry himself expressed later. Of course a fairly obvious response could have been to ask Fry for clarification, but instead a whirlwind of denouncement, Chinese-whispers, quote-mining and pseudopsychoanalysis attributing beliefs to Fry that he had not necessarily himself expressed.

In the end however a discussion about free speech, and life on the campus was ultimately lost in favour of an attempt to mind read. Rather than hitting out at victims of abuse, Fry and Rubin tried to explore the fact that some students – often not victims of abuse themselves – cynically attempted to shut down ideas and police the syllabus based on their own belief of protecting others. Attempting to blur the lines between recognised mental health issues (that should be treated with the utmost respect) and the hurt feelings of students intolerant of diverse opinions. In this way it is they who do not truly respect mental health.

While I actually do believe that there is a genuine debate to be had about trigger warnings around some issues, and I think it’s fair for teachers at their own discretion to warn about potential graphic content, formalisation of this process and an expansive domain of just what is ‘triggering’ eventually becomes a problem. I don’t think it’s practical or even desirable to forever avoid the things that make us uncomfortable and it is true to say life doesn’t come with a trigger warning.

The idea that the mere presence of Germaine Greer or Christina Hoff Sommers or Richard Dawkins on a campus is enough to induce severe psychological anguish in students is something I cannot accept. An appeal to hurt feelings for speech we do not like will simply not suffice. Again we must ask ourselves ‘what is a university?’ It must remain a place of challenge.

Photograph: dreamwhile