The Birthday Party Preview: ‘a really chilling drama’

By Alexander Marshall

Hill College Theatre Company’s (HCTC) upcoming production of Harold Pinter’s The Birthday Party is one that seems to have stirred some attention in the Durham theatre scene, and rightly so. It is an undeniably challenging play, particularly for a first time director, Katie O’Toole. I’m sure there has been some scepticism over the potential for success of this production, but having been treated to a sneak preview, and I can honestly say it was a treat, I have every faith that O’Toole and her cast are going to produce something fantastic.

When asked about the difficulties in the production, O’Toole explained that ‘the first hurdle was simply deciding how I wanted the audience to visualize it’. She herself describes the play as ‘an absurdist play in a naturalistic setting’, and despite inspiration from the film directed by Pinter, everybody involved insists it will be unique. Leading man, Luke Titmuss goes as far as to say ‘you will not have seen anything like this’.

The uniqueness of the production is aided by the impressive, yet challenging, venue of Castle’s Senate Suite. With the assorted props and furniture Elle Morgan-Williams, who portrays landlady Meg, insists ‘the Senate Suite has really worked with the boarding house feel’.

A defining factor in the success of the production as a whole will be the performance of Titmuss as the show’s central character, Stanley Webber. He is a thirty-something resident of a boarding house, who O’Toole describes as ‘ a failed musician oppressed by society’. Titmuss himself admitted that the role is ‘the most difficult part in terms of characterisation that I’ve ever had’. Titmuss says of the play as a whole that ‘It’s kind of like Pinter has written a play about a parallel universe where humans just don’t act like humans, but rely on their slightly more animalistic nature’.

The rather intense and disconcerting scene I watched also featured Jake Goldman and George Troop as Goldberg and McCann, respectively, as two strange men who visit Stanley on a day that may or may not be his birthday. As a double act they were a joy to watch, simultaneously amusing and sinister. Goldman told me the hardest aspect of his character was ‘to capture the dichotomy between absurdism and the reality of the naturalistic situation’. Troop was equally delighted with his role and admitted, ‘I’ve been told I have fitting facial expressions for a sadistic psychopath; I’m glad to finally find a part for that’.

Intense interrogation scenes aside, there is a comedic aspect to the play. The cast seemed at a consensus that the play wasn’t itself a comedy, but that there were moments where ‘through intonation and delivery that it comes across as funny’, says Morgan-Williams. Goldman also believes that ‘for a lot of the characters there is a lot of latent comic potential in the writing’. It’s the comedy and wit in the text, juxtaposed with the much darker moments, that ‘make it that bit more uncomfortable. It feels out of place’ says Titmuss.

When asked if they related to their characters personally, it was Talor Hanson and Matthew Chalmers portraying Lulu and Petey who had most to say. Hanson felt the young Lulu ‘poses quite an important lesson in terms of consequences of actions. She obviously learns that what is fun in the moment may not be later’. Morgan-Williams helpfully associated this with waking up after what she described as a ‘Klute disaster’. Chalmers seemed to relate most to his character, the quiet and cautious landlord, and Meg’s husband Petey, explaining that he ‘is a very human character in a way that he will ignore everything going on around him just to maintain his superficial, comfortable existence’. Chalmers went on to elaborate that, ‘People do overlook things so that they don’t have to deal with hardship, and I think that’s quite an important point of human nature that Petey reflects’.

Throughout the preview I was struck by how much each of the cast had to say about their respective roles, and how clear an understanding each seemed to have both of their role and the play overall. When I finally asked what makes the play unique and why you should see it I was bombarded with different responses. ‘Everyone just loves a good old fashioned scare – a really chilling drama’ suggested Hanson. Whilst Chalmers added ‘It’s going to give you a lot of food for thought’. Morgan-Williams insists it’s ‘the kind of play where you’ll come out and just think’. Meanwhile Troop’s summary of reasons to watch were ‘It’s got thrills, it’s got shocks, it’s got laughs, and an Irish accent’. Whether it’s for the individual performances, the comedy, the drama, the lingering aspect of fear, or even just to sit inside the Castle for an evening – The Birthday Party has something for everybody and is certainly one not to be missed.

The Birthday Party will be performed in Durham Castle’s Senate Suite from Saturday, 7th of May until Sunday 8th of May at 19:30. Book your tickets here. 

Photograph: Alexander Marshall