Impeached: For Better or For worse?

By Sam Harrison
As the spotlight turns to Brazil for the Olympic Games this summer, an embittered political backdrop sets the scene: the coalition government is slowly disintegrating, president Dilma Rousseff is threatened with being torn from power by the very people she governs, and the political figures to take her place are just as unsuitable for the job thanks to their irreversible branding with corruption.
Such a call for impeachment, as pressured by a series of nationwide protests over the past 12 months, is a result of Rousseff’s negligence of public funds, her inability to recover the freefalling economy, and her involvement with the Petrobras scandal: the largest corruption scandal in the history of Brazil, in which state officials were charged with ascertaining more than 10 billion Brazilian Reals through money laundering.
The latest step towards Rousseff’s ever-increasing likelihood of impeachment came on the evening of April 17, as officials of the National Assembly came together to vote overwhelmingly in favour of passing the charges of impeachment to the Senate for trial. With 367 votes for the motion and 137 against, it is apparent that her support from both the people and the government is rapidly dissipating.
Estado de Sao Paulo, a newspaper that has been tracking voting intentions, predicts that 46 out of 81 senators will support the vote for an impeachment trial. If the vote goes as expected, vice-president Michel Temer of the Brazilian Democratic Movement Party (PMDB) will be first in line to take Rousseff’s place for up to 180 days. This means that the Olympic games in all likelihood will not be overseen by the incumbent leader. If the vote reaches a two thirds majority, Temer will hold office until Rousseff’s term ends in December 2018.
Temer seriously runs the risk of being impeached himself, rendering his case for presidency unsound. Firstly, the PMDB is primarily responsible for the Petrobras scandal which has been a major cause for rioting in Brazil, and Temer is closely allied with an affiliate of the scandal, Eduardo Cunha. Having a PMDB president closely associated with those accused of corruption would be no more likely to satisfy the people. The lower house and a Supreme Court minister have filed an impeachment charge against the vice-president, which has lead to an investigation by the Supreme Electoral Court into his alleged employment of graft money to fund his 2014 election campaign. If found guilty, he will be ousted from the race before he gets the chance to run for power. Not only does the government want him out, but the polling institute Datafolha found that 58 percent of Brazilians also want the vice-president impeached.
Whoever is to take the presidential reins next will have masses of social and economic mess to clean up: under Rousseff’s tenure, 1.8 million jobs have been lost, the budget deficit reached a staggering 10.8% of GDP, and the Brazilian Real almost halved in value. Rousseff has put the country through the worst economic recession since 1901, which will severely restrict the possibility of spending cuts to curb the budget deficit, and with a Congress made up of 28 parties, Temer may find it virtually impossible to push reforms needed to revive the $2 trillion economy.
David Fleischer, a politics professor at Brasilia University, says “It’s going to be rough on the streets…It is almost mission impossible for Temer to turn the economy around”. Brazil will simply have to embrace its economic dire straits until the its next elections in 2018. Until then, the government’s only hope is to find a suitable leader before it plunges itself into anarchy.
Photograph: Michael Temervia
