Blue/Orange review: ‘hilarious and moving’
By Alexander Marshall
The lead up to Lion Theatre Company’s (LTC) production of Blue/Orange by Joe Penhall will have been something that has caught many people’s eyes, be it online or via the fairly conspicuous blue oranges left lying around Durham. The thoughtful publicity around the show created quite a sense of anticipation for the production. I’m glad to say it did not disappoint. The team should be very proud of what was an undeniably successful production.
Carrie Gaunt, as Emma, the more junior of two psychiatrists, absolutely shone throughout the production. In the role she never failed to perfectly, and believably, capture her character’s emotions and she had no difficulty commanding the stage. On top of this, when spoken to, Gaunt’s facial expressions were genuine and heartfelt, particularly in her interactions with her patient. Beginning the play alongside Gaunt, Wesley Milligan played Christopher, a young mental patient. Milligan’ characterisation was admirable, with everything from his accent to his physicality clearly being well thought out. He was consistently interesting to watch, with his unnerving hand gestures which suggested that his character was always on edge. Overall Milligan gave a very strong and well-rounded performance and did justice to an undeniably challenging role. Last to appear on stage was Ruari Hutchinson who brought a new energy to the scene and he maintained his character vocally and physically throughout. However, whilst well-sustained, his tone at times came across as somewhat monotonous and lacked some variation in longer passages of dialogue. This did not detrimentally affect what was a generally great performance.
The interaction between characters was generally fantastic throughout the performance, although it took a few minutes to warm up with the opening scene initially feeling a little awkward. This however soon subsided and the relationships between characters settled. The comic timing of all three cast members was outstanding and frequently had the audience in fits of laughter. This was well contrasted by very touching moments, and some unsettling interactions. Hutchinson’s performance particularly highlighted this by instantly flitting between wickedly funny moments and the much darker, almost insidious, side of his character. The stark contrast between the patient and the two doctors also created an interesting and constantly changing power dynamic between the actors. There were however a few moments when slip-ups in Hutchinson’s longer sections of speech, meant the energy somewhat dropped, but each time it was quickly recovered by the cast. Occasionally, interrupting lines did not come in quickly enough, which can make dialogue momentarily stilted; this is however a minor point, that could most likely be put down to opening night nerves.
Originally I felt the setting of Caedmon Hall, one of the largest spaces often used for drama, for such an intimate play seemed odd. Initial confusions aside, the decision to have the play and audience set behind the curtains on stage created an intimate atmosphere. I think the close proximity of actors to the audience lends itself to the small cast and setting, although in the enclosed space the choice of music prior to each act felt rather out of place. Tech was generally smooth and well-operated, setting aside a few minor issues such as a blackout mid scene and lights coming up too soon. Qasim Salam’s direction provided a continually engaging and often hilarious performance. Much of the piece was largely sedentary, which emphasised the smaller yet more poignant gestures of the characters that may have otherwise gone under the radar. This also meant that when characters did move, it was with a greater purpose.
Overall, the whole team should be commended for what is a wonderful production. Whether or not Penhall’s brand of dark comedy is to your taste, the performance skilfully handles important messages regarding mental illness from both a doctor’s and patient’s perspective. The unique balance between hilarious and moving moments has created an unmissable production.
Photograph: Hugh Memess
