The Ghosts of Christmas- has the meaning been lost?
By Marcus Cassop-Thompson
With the 25th fast approaching and another year drawing to a close, the discourse on the true meaning of the season will inevitably make a return, seeming somewhat obligatory, and packed with all of your favourite festive clichés. In fact writing on this subject seems to platitudinous it seems to mandate a warning: beware unoriginality ahead.
In reality any ‘truth’ that can be taken from Christmas is- ultimately- of our own definition. Yet beneath my several layers of cynicism maybe this age old question is still a good one to keep examining.
Among the most prevalent observations of its modern celebration is the somewhat nostalgic view that, a once hallowed Christian festival has been corrupted by the forces of selfish materialism and that Christmas has become merely a vehicle of a hyper-consumeristic society. But with so many able to articulate such a view and engage in such a reflexive critique, it would seem we all have thought there is something particularly special about Christmas. Rather than being a dystopian automata programmed to buy presents, our presence of mind may mean we still remain fundamentally human.
To consider what Christmas was, is and will become and invoke the ghosts of past, present and future touches more widely on the evolution of our culture and society, and perhaps reveals at its most striking the contradictions within it. For just more than a month every year, we suspend whatever modern reservations we may have regarding the value of tradition, national customs and whether your Dawkins or Derrida, enjoy the great anachronism that is Christmas.
How many atheists will sing that ‘Christ the saviour is born’? How many Corbynistas will re-watch Downton’s Christmas specials? And what are we to make of such inconsistencies? One answer may well be that below the hectic dash to buy presents, there is a subtle awareness that December brings us something that is missing from the majority of ordinary contemporary life; to come together and join in something timeless, providing an opportunity to circumvent the increasingly atomised nature of our time.
Whether it be values we can all believe in- such as goodwill to all- rituals that link us not only to each other but also with history or even the fact we privilege a special time where our attention is focused on the things that really matter, in the season of good will, we find a relic of what has been largely lost in an increasingly secular and so called post-modern European society.
Perhaps the aspect of Christmas we find so difficult to reconcile is its foundational religiosity. With the decline of Christianity in Britain, recent generations are almost unique in history to have lives where the concept of something ‘more’ than this world is absent.
In ‘The Varieties of Religious Experience’, William James’s exploration of the more mystical and numinous aspects of peoples lives seems to leave modern life looking starkly more grey by comparison. It seems in a world in which many people no longer believe in God such an experience closes. A society may not be able to notice such a slow gradual loss of religion, but it is often interesting to hear of individual cases in which people have lost their faith in God. Very often these people feel a sense of grief, that something has been taken from them, like the loss of a loved one.
Maybe they are on to something. While the non-religious may see such a change of opinion as a good thing, it may well be time to appreciate that the death of God has left a void in peoples lives that it is incumbent upon us to address. While we may not wish to return to beliefs we view as supernatural or that run counter to a secular rationalist outlook, it may well be that a desire to experience being truly part of something greater than ourselves is something that is at our very core.
It’s ironic that, at the heart of the consumeristic machine, the John Lewis Christmas advert seeks to tap into and commercialise a more profound human desire.The desire to be moved. Each year an exorbitant amount of money is spent attempting to manufacture a quasi-religious reaction to a 3 minute T.V. commercial, however incomplete and haphazard it may seem.
Yet the realisation of what we truly are finding in Christmas may just mean we start to address the gaps left in a secular world, and maybe promise we find magic all year round.
Photograph by Petr Kratochvil via Creative Commons
