This Tory government is not anti-immigration
By Max Parry
David Cameron is as close as he ever has been to reaching a settlement with EU officials, that will aid his government’s attempts to curb immigration from the European Union. However, you won’t be hearing champagne corks popping in the Tory shires or on the east coast of England (where UKIP were particularly successful in the last general election). This is because the Prime Minister’s initial proposal – to prevent EU migrants from claiming tax credits for four years – has been significantly diluted. Under the European Commission’s revised offer, an “emergency brake” will be imposed on in-work benefits for EU migrants during the first four years that they live in the UK. However, during the first four years a migrant lives here, they will be able to claim increasingly more in-work benefits, which will rise in line with minimum wage increases and will also still be able to send child benefits back to their country of origin. The Prime Minister will continue to negotiate on immigration prior to the EU referendum, but try as he might, the Eurocrats don’t want to listen.
Irrespective of whether or not the Prime Minister gets his immigration wish, the question will be raised about the attitude of this government towards migrants from Europe and beyond. Net-migration from outside the EU is at its lowest since 1998 and policies of a similar ilk to that floated by Theresa May last week, are very much in vogue. ‘Those pesky right-wing, Enoch Powell-type Tories’, they’re anti-immigrant’, you’ll hear the angry mob cry, ‘how dare the Home Secretary prevent non-EU migrants earning less than £35,000 a year after five years from staying in the UK.’ I would agree, despite not being in the angry mob, that such a policy would have very serious consequences. Unfortunately, given our relationship with the European Union, a policy of that kind is an inevitability. As whilst the EU is committed to the freedom of movement (which it always will be), the UK has to discriminate against migrants from the rest of the world. I would therefore strongly contest the claims that this Conservative government is opposed to immigration, rather they want to see it reduced, like the majority of Britons. Crucially however, they also wish for greater diversity of immigrants, from the commonwealth and other regions of the world, rather than swathes of central Europeans.
The free movement of labour within the European Union has the effect of making Britain turn away teachers from Australia or nurses from India. Britain simply cannot afford to leave the door to the world ajar, when the door to Europe has been taken off its hinges. On that understanding, it is not due to the Prime Minister being actively opposed to immigration that he is attempting to curtail the freedom of movement, on the contrary, it’s what the immigrant-cheerleading metropolitan liberal elite should be advocating. In fact, they should want to leave the European Union altogether, because if anything is guaranteed in Cameron’s renegotiation, it’s that the freedom of movement will not face any significant amendments. As a direct consequence, the discrimination against migrants from the anywhere other than the 28 member states will have to continue. The only way to curb illiberal discriminatory immigration policies is to put the door to Europe back on its hinges, so that we can open the door to the rest of the world, that little bit more.
Cameron’s renegotiation will, almost certainly, be insufficient in tackling the problem of immigration from the EU, realistically only by leaving altogether can that be achieved. However, his efforts to reform the EU’s immigration policy is indicative of the Conservatives’ will to tackle the injustices faced by immigrants from outside of the European Union. Sure the Tories want to reduce immigration, but they no longer want to be forced into discrimination either. The government’s attitude is not anti-immigration but rather anti-discrimination.
Photograph: Copyright by World Economic Forum
swiss-image.ch/Photo by Moritz Hager
