Why university subject rankings are personal

By Ellie Dyer-Brown

It’s a question almost as old as university ranking systems themselves: why, when Durham consistently achieves a spot in the top ten UK universities, does it perform so poorly in international league tables?

This year, despite having 12 subjects in the world top 50 and three in the top ten according to QS World University Rankings, Durham has landed in a less than impressive position of 92nd place. Things are worse when you look at the Times Higher Education (THE) World University Rankings, where it barely makes the top 200.

For prospective students, many of whom use league tables as a guiding factor in decision-making, the discrepancy between different ranking systems presents a conundrum. According to THE, Newcastle University beats Durham by 59 places, coming 139th in the world. Yet, Newcastle doesn’t make it into the top 20 UK universities in The Complete University Guide, The Guardian or University Advice – all of which feature Durham in the top ten. This is just one example, but there are many more. So how to square these vastly different ranking systems?

One answer is to focus on subject rankings, which seem to cut straight to the heart of the issue. When I confirmed my place at Durham in 2018, the one thing that took the sting out of its lack of Oxbridge-ness was that the English department was, at the time, the best in the country based on The Times & Sunday Times Good University Guide.

Unfortunately, these rankings are often subject to rapid change – the department has hurtled down nine places in just five years. But that isn’t the whole story, either. Durham still has the second highest graduate prospects for English with a score of 85.7, just behind Oxford’s 87. This is despite the fact that teaching quality, student experience and research quality are lower than most other universities in the top ten.

League tables provide one possible answer to a complex
question that is, at the end of the day, deeply personal

It’s a similar story when you look at the scores contributing to Durham’s overall ranking in the Good University Guide: 6th. Graduate prospects are consistently one of its highest- scoring areas. This proves something I’ve always suspected: while Durham is sometimes mocked for its bland nightlife and substantial population of signet ring-wearing rahs, it carries a certain prestige that has yet to be sullied even by poor management and falling standards.

Part of this is because Durham emulates the collegiate system of Oxbridge and is one of the oldest universities in the UK. As you walk through the city, past the castle and cathedral and the beautiful buildings on the Bailey, it’s difficult not to be taken in by the sheer sense of history that soaks the cobbled streets. Durham feels like a place where knowledge is meant to be pursued, which has undoubtedly influenced its ongoing reputation in the UK as a leading institution of higher education.

This is all very well for someone like me, who intends to pursue a career outside of academia, probably in this country. But what about students whose careers will take them further afield?

Global ranking systems like QS and THE typically prioritise research output and citations. When Research Professional News applied its Research Excellence Framework, Durham came in 21st behind Sheffield and Cardiff, two universities that it typically outperforms in UK league tables. The quality of Durham’s research is notoriously high (in the 2021 Research Excellence Framework, 90% was rated ‘world-leading’ or ‘internationally excellent’), so perhaps volume is where it falls.

Even though the university has a strong international outlook, it is small compared to many rivals. The area is beautiful, but it simply doesn’t possess the kind of magnetism that London affords universities like KCL and LSE, which have stronger global reputations. Durham is simply too small a city to support a larger student population (much as the university management would like to ignore that inconvenient fact and continue building new colleges).

One of the best analogies I’ve come across for understanding university league tables relates to food. If you took the equivalent criteria used by THE (teaching, research, citations, industry income and international outlook) and applied the same methodology to find the best restaurants in the world, McDonald’s and KFC would come out on top.

In reality, few would list these establishments as the best restaurant they’ve ever visited. Likewise, league tables provide one possible answer to a complex question that is, at the end of the day, deeply personal. World, UK and subject rankings matter; but they are not all that matters.

Image Credit: Beauregard Sarbruis via Flickr