Brands like Tampax should ditch the ‘meme marketing’ if they can’t read the room

By Ellie Dyer-Brown

Before I started my Masters degree, I spent a year working in marketing, so I know how difficult it can be to make a business sound exciting and relevant on social media (especially when it’s a small company in the automotive industry, as the one I worked for was). Tampax, in theory, should have less of a problem achieving this. It is owned by conglomerate Procter & Gamble and has a global market share of 29%. How, then, could things go so horribly wrong for the undisputed industry leader? It all started with a Tweet. 

Copying the format of a popular meme, the company tweeted on November 21st: “You’re in their DMs. We’re in them. We are not the same.” Minutes later, outraged replies flooded in, with angry users accusing the brand of sexualising women and young girls, while others took issue with the Tweet’s gender-neutral language. It wasn’t long before #BoycottTampax was trending on Twitter. Soon after that, users turned on each other. Arguments broke out about what it was ‘right’ to be outraged about, and the word TERF was thrown around with vitriol.

Was the Tweet in bad taste? Yes. But is it sexualising young girls?

There’s a lot to unpack here. I saw the Tweet before I knew it had sparked any controversy, and I must admit, I didn’t think much of it at the time (other than a faint sense of despair that yet another brand was trying to be ‘funny’ online). Was the Tweet in bad taste? Yes. Should somebody in Tampax’s marketing team have said, ‘hang on a minute, this is actually quite a vulgar thing for a global brand to Tweet, isn’t it?’. Absolutely. But is it sexualising young girls? It obviously wasn’t intended to be about them, and the original meme format isn’t aimed at that demographic, either. It is hardly comparable to Balenciaga’s recent marketing campaign, which featured young children holding teddy bears wearing bondage gear. Those images explicitly promoted the sexualisation of minors. This Tweet, on the other hand, is another example of a brand buying into the cringe-worthy trend of meme marketing. If only they would learn to read the room.

That’s not to say I think the Tweet is acceptable because it’s supposed to be about adults; I don’t. But I could see how, if someone hadn’t spent much time thinking about it, they might not have realised the full extent of what it implies: the idea that being inside a woman is the ultimate aim for men, which is inherently misogynistic. I think – or I did think at first – this might have been a mistake that slipped through the cracks due to one person who had access to the company’s Twitter account and somehow bypassed the usual content review process. Here lies the problem with recycling online memes to create branded content: most of us don’t care whether a company is funny or relatable, and it’s all too easy for the humour to get lost when it’s reframed by a business from which we want nothing but a functional product or service.

You’d think, given this country seems to be falling apart in various ways, people would have ore pressing ways to spend their time than arguing about gender

As well as critiquing the sexualisation of the Tweet, some people were keen to condemn the brand’s use of the gender-neutral pronouns ‘their’ and ‘them’. I’m sure I’m not the only person who finds the constant policing of language online exhausting, and in this instance, the outrage seems particularly laboured since traditionally, ‘their’ is a plural pronoun anyway. The Tweet was intended to be humorous; it was supposed to be a meme. You’d think, given this country seems to be falling apart in various ways, people would have more pressing ways to spend their time than arguing about gender. 

If Tampax had responded promptly with a genuine apology and a commitment not to let the same thing happen again, it may have been possible for the brand to claw back a shred of respect from its customers. Instead, the company retweeted the ‘joke’ a few hours later, saying it “refused to let Twitter shut down before we shared this tweet” (referring to Elon Musk’s Twitter takeover and the platform’s rumoured demise). At this point, any doubt I might have had about how the Tweet made it into the world rapidly dissipated. It wasn’t the work of an errant marketeer with a warped sense of humour; the brand fully endorsed it. Only days later did Tampax think to issue an apology, by which point it was, for millions of people, too little, too late.

Image credits: Karolina Grabowska via Pexels