Isobel Oakeshott was right to leak Matt Hancock’s WhatsApp messages

By Ellie Dyer-Brown

The more you learn about the goings on in Westminster during the Covid-19 pandemic, the more it feels like you’ve been invited to read the script of a political sitcom like Yes Minister or The Thick of It. This season, it seems, will be Matt Hancock’s last. The writers want to know: ‘is it believable?’.

Consider the various plot points, from Hancock’s plan to give French patients places in UK hospitals (at a time when the public were told to avoid using them) to allegedly debating whether blackmailing an MP into supporting lockdowns by blocking funding for a learning disability hub might be a good idea. If this really were a TV show, your answer would probably be ‘yes’. One can easily imagine the vicious Malcolm Tucker plotting to “frighten the pants of [sic] people with a new strain” (probably with a few more expletives). Unfortunately, this is real life, making the revelations of The Telegraph’s Lockdown Files that much harder to swallow.

The files — obtained thanks to the political journalist, Isabel Oakeshott, the ghost-writer of Hancock’s memoir — contain more than 100,000 WhatsApp messages sent between ministers and officials throughout the Covid-19 pandemic. Given that Oakeshott broke her non-disclosure agreement to leak the messages, questions have been raised about journalistic conduct — specifically, whether the leak is in the public interest, thereby vindicating it as an act of whistleblowing. If Hancock decides to sue Oakeshott, she will need to prove that the messages reveal some criminality or wrongdoing, which in my opinion, they absolutely do. 

Contrary to cries from ministers that the Lockdown Files are being used to “rewrite history”, they are vital in shedding light on precisely how decisions were made and by whom. Yes, the messages highlighted by The Telegraph have been selected out of thousands to create headlines, but they reportedly haven’t been doctored. If some present a damning view of politicians, ministers, and comms experts, that should be down to the person who hit send on each message. 

The leaked messages show that, time and again, harsh restrictions were pushed through with no cost-benefit analysis

Unlike Sweden’s approach, which placed trust in its people to behave sensibly and proportionately (and came out of the pandemic much better as a result), Hancock felt the need to ratchet up fear at every opportunity. “When do we deploy the new variant?” he allegedly asked at one point. You don’t need to be an English student to understand the implications of the word “deploy”. Even thinking about the “look them in the eyes” government advertising campaign makes me shudder. I can only imagine the damage those posters and that messaging did to people’s mental health through deliberate fear-mongering.

The leaked messages seem to show that, time and again, harsh restrictions were pushed through with no cost-benefit analysis and little acknowledgement that lockdowns and fear campaigns might do more harm than good. Even after Chris Whitty told Hancock that reducing the Covid-19 isolation period would be safe, the Health Secretary decided to discard that advice, not to err on the side of caution, but because it would “imply we’ve been getting it wrong”. A similar situation happened regarding mask-wearing — Johnson introduced masks because his director of communications, Lee Cain, and Whitty agreed it “wasn’t worth an argument” with Scotland. 

We spent years of our lives under draconian restrictions, many of which were introduced or maintained based on political grandstanding and pride — not ‘the science’. Thousands of people have died because the NHS couldn’t see them, and thousands more will suffer the same fate in the coming years; thousands continue to struggle with mental health issues that were either sparked or exacerbated by being locked up at home; thousands of victims of abuse had nowhere to escape; and thousands of children and babies were set back in their development by years, the poorest of whom will never catch up. The question that hangs over these facts is: was it worth it? And without the Lockdown Files, would we ever have got close to the truth?

Nobody knows for certain the answer to either of the above questions, but what we do know is that the official Covid-19 inquiry — costing a cool £85 million to set up — already runs the risk of rumbling on for many years to come. By making Hancock’s WhatsApp messages public, not only has Oakeshott given the public a unique and crucial insight into the decisions that shaped and continue to shape our lives, but she has also sparked additional pressure for the inquiry to be fast-tracked so key evidence cannot be erased. If that isn’t in the public interest, I don’t know what is.

Image: Number 10 via Flickr