£122 mill employment boost for mental health support: caring or missing the mark?
By Ellie Dyer-Brown
It is telling that in the Government’s press release regarding its £122 million employment boost for people receiving mental health support, the plan is repeatedly described as a way to “grow the economy”. The benefits of this investment for the people it is aimed at are little more than an afterthought; it will “fuel a thriving labour market” and “increase individual prosperity”. However, we don’t learn that returning to work could help people with mental health issues until the third paragraph and not at all in the summarising bullet points.
It is difficult to read the press release without feeling uncomfortable. Not because the idea itself is bad — it is well-known that working can provide stability, routine and a sense of purpose — but because the language used to justify the investment comes across as exploitative. People being out of work has economic implications, of course, but the Government has turned mental health into a financial problem. The press release essentially says, ‘what’s best for the economy is what’s best for you’, as if unemployed people who suffer from a mental illness are one of the top issues our country faces right now. Our economy is in crisis: from rampant inflation to falling GDP, along with the 6.7 million people on the NHS waiting lists. Suddenly, the drive to get mentally ill people into work seems like a drop in the ocean in the grand scheme of things.
People being out of work has economic implications, of course, but the Government has turned mental health into a financial problem
The Governments desire for growth is understandable; although unemployment is the lowest it has been since 1974, the number of people who are long-term sick and thus out of work is at an all-time high. However, this reflects the Government’s appalling handling of the pandemic. If it hadn’t deliberately sought to frighten people, causing many to develop depression and anxiety, and if the National Health Service hadn’t been in such a precarious position even before Covid-19 hit, then perhaps the issue wouldn’t have been quite so urgent today.
In August, 1.2 million people were waiting for mental health support, and a combination of underfunding and high demand has resulted in the NHS missing several of its major targets. If this were really about mental health, why not invest the money in improving existing services to cut waiting lists? Or better yet, encourage more people to train as mental health professionals and create jobs for them. It’s all very well telling people to get back to work, but there is a fine line between a supportive nudge and a shove, and the Government already overstepped it during the pandemic. This cannot be allowed to happen again at the expense of people’s mental well-being.
Reading through the press release, it struck me that one glaringly obvious caveat had been omitted: the ability of a job to improve mental health is contingent on the conditions, culture and support systems in the workplace. A 2022 poll by Nuffield Health revealed that two-thirds of employees wouldn’t feel comfortable discussing mental health with their employer, showing the culture within an organisation can harm just as easily as it can help, and the impact of this can be tenfold for people with mental health issues.
It’s all very well telling people to get back to work, but there is a fine line between a supportive nudge and a shove, and the Government already overstepped it during the pandemic
The Government’s approach reminds me of when my mum marched me to the doctor, at a loss for what else she could do when I was fourteen and underweight. The upshot of the appointment? You should try to eat a bit more. In theory, this was exactly the right solution; if I ate more food, I would put on weight. But there was something in my mind stopping me from doing so, and until that was fixed, the obvious solution was never going to work. Likewise, encouraging people with mental health issues to return to employment too soon might boost the economy temporarily but it won’t fix the problem in the long term if there is no support available in the workplace.
To achieve its goal in an effective and compassionate way, the Government must ensure two things. First, that it doesn’t place pressure on employment advisers to get a certain number of people into work, and second, that it also encourages more businesses to fulfil their duty of care by supporting mental health in the workplace. This way, advice can be offered on a case-by-case basis, and people can return to employment with confidence. Mental health isn’t something that can be fixed with a single lifestyle change; for many, it is a long and difficult battle, and Government interventions need to reflect this.
Image: Eliza Ventur via Unsplash

