I never thought I’d say it, but Extinction Rebellion has finally made a good decision

By Ellie Dyer-Brown

Imagine you’re on your way to a big job interview – the once-in-a-lifetime kind. You’ve booked your train, spent all week preparing, and planned your day down to the last second. Then, as you pull open your laptop and attempt to connect to LNER’s abysmal wifi, a voice comes over the speaker system: there are protestors on the tracks. You’re not going anywhere; another candidate gets the job. Now imagine an even worse scenario: rather than stopping trains, they’re glued to the road. Traffic is backed up for miles, and you’re stuck in it, unable to be with your father in the hospital during his last moments.

These aren’t just stories; they are the real-life implications of disruptive Extinction Rebellion protests designed to bring about radical and immediate change to climate policy. I can’t speak for everyone, but neither of the scenarios above makes me more sympathetic to XR’s cause. Like most people in this country, I’m already of the opinion that climate change is an important issue. Recent data from the ONS show that 64% of adults worry about climate change, and for teenagers, whose entire lives have been shaped by the narrative that we are all going to burn for abusing the planet, that figure is likely to be even higher.

Protests that punish ordinary people for the government’s supposed inaction are not the way forward. XR admitted as much recently when the group announced plans to “shift away from public disruption” since “very little has changed”. But much has changed over the past two decades, at least in this country. Britain’s Climate Change Act, introduced in 2008, promised to cut emissions by at least 80% by 2050, and it was amended in 2019 to achieve net zero within the same timeframe. In 2030, a ban on the sale of new petrol and diesel cars will come into force, and by 2035 the government’s path to net zero is set to eradicate all fossil fuels, creating a carbon- free electricity supply. These targets speak volumes about this country’s dedication to alleviating climate change.

Protests that punish ordinary people for the government’s supposed inaction are not the way

Of the G20 countries, the UK has seen its emissions fall fastest, with a 20% reduction since 2010. Carbon emissions are also at their lowest since the mid-19th century. Figures like these rarely make it into climate change discourse. Similarly, questions about the extremely harmful extraction of lithium for electric car batteries and the global capacity for recycling them once they have been used up are usually brushed over. XR’s tireless refrain, ‘not enough, not quickly enough,’ is all very well, but the reality is that there is no silver bullet for fixing the climate, and to pretend otherwise is simply to bury one’s head in the sand.

There are big questions to contend with – such as ongoing energy security – to which we don’t have all the answers. In particular, we have no viable alternative to gas when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow. Nuclear power stations take a long time to build and require significant investment; there are only six operational in the UK generating 15% of our energy. Just last year, Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak came to loggerheads over the issue of cost when the former PM proposed a new generation of up to eight nuclear reactors. Likewise, storing electricity is extremely costly, and we don’t at present have the capacity or efficient technology to do that, either.

The standard of living in this country is already in sharp decline

All of the above is concerning. But it’s also worth remembering that technology is evolving rapidly: radical innovations are just around the corner, and Britain is already on one of the best trajectories for eradicating greenhouse gases and moving to a more sustainable way of life, contributing just 2% to global emissions. XR would do well to focus its attention on serious polluters, like China and the US, rather than disrupting the lives of people who are just trying to get by.

The standard of living in this country is already in sharp decline, and pushing harder in the race to go green without the technology or infrastructure to do so comes with a cost that isn’t often acknowledged. That cost is more people pushed into fuel poverty and a higher toll of excess deaths from those who can’t afford to heat their homes. It isn’t just homes that have to be heated – it’s also hospitals, schools, nursing homes, shops. By all means, put pressure on governments to tackle the climate crisis. But leave ordinary people alone.

Image: Julia Hawkins via Wikimedia Commons