Fruit and vegetable shortages show we need to back British farming

By Ellie Dyer-Brown

There is an episode in the second season of Clarkson’s Farm where farmers from around Oxfordshire get together to discuss creating a cooperative which would provide local produce for the restaurant Clarkson hopes to build on Diddly Squat. It quickly becomes apparent that this isn’t just about a bit of extra revenue; it’s a lifeline. At one farm, the exorbitant price of grain is making it almost impossible to turn a profit by keeping pigs. At another, sixty cows — more than half the herd — have been lost to TB, and the people who run the farm admit they haven’t been able to take a wage for themselves. These problems are symptomatic of the state of British farming, which has been neglected by the government for years. Now, we are beginning to see the consequences.

If you’ve been to a supermarket recently, you’ve probably noticed a few bare shelves in the fruit and vegetable aisles. Many shops, including Aldi, Morrisons, and Tesco, have been forced to ration produce like lettuce and tomatoes due to bad weather across Europe and northern Africa. According to the British Research Consortium, the UK imports 90% of these items during the winter; soaring energy costs have prevented many UK farmers from growing produce in greenhouses, making us even more reliant on overseas goods. After the government excluded the horticulture sector from its support scheme for energy-intensive industries, it’s hardly surprising British farmers are increasingly anxious about the future.

Exclusively blaming Brexit doesn’t get to the heart of the issue

Back in 2016, the promise to make a bonfire of all the red tape that acts as a chokehold on businesses was a compelling enough reason for many people to vote in favour of Brexit. Fast forward seven years and Clarkson’s Farm has highlighted the extent to which much of that red tape still binds farmers. Exclusively blaming Brexit doesn’t get to the heart of the issue because the problem isn’t necessarily that we left the EU; it’s that the government has missed countless opportunities to make the UK better outside of it. Last year, according to data from the Rural Payments Agency, subsidies were cut by an average of 22%. It should have been a top priority to ensure farmers could thrive without spending years languishing in uncertainty, but the new post-Brexit funding system, which rewards farms for taking steps to protect the environment, has only just been unveiled.

You might have seen recent images of supermarket shelves in the Netherlands and Spain brimming with tomatoes. It’s easy to claim there’s some prejudice at work here, but geography inevitably dictates where shortages will be felt most profoundly since it costs more to get produce across the English Channel. That’s why there are also shortages in Ireland, which is still inside the EU. We cannot continue to rely heavily on imports if we want to achieve food security. As the National Farming Union says, this is just the “tip of the iceberg.”

The British farming industry used to be the envy of the world — and it could be again if only we could move away from the one-sided narrative that farming is inherently unsustainable and therefore holding us back from achieving Net Zero (and, for some people, a meat-free future… how depressing). The new post-Brexit subsidies will help with this by encouraging more environmental practices. But it’s worth remembering that British lamb and beef are already among the most efficient and sustainable in the world. Rather than seeking trade deals with countries like the US, which has lower food standards than the UK, why not invest time and money in British farmers? We’ll always have to import some produce that is out of season, but what we can grow, we should, including livestock.

Providing more support for farmers would boost our economy as a whole and create the kind of food security we desperately need

Love or hate him, Jeremy Clarkson’s television show has proved there is interest in and support for farming by the British people. We want our farmers to succeed. We want to eat produce grown in this country to high standards, and we don’t want our farmers to have to live without a wage to achieve that. Clarkson has done the industry a great service by highlighting to the public the problems it faces, from disappearing subsidies to high fertiliser costs and the “soil police.” (As Charlie points out in episode four, “there is an every sort of police”). Providing more support for farmers would boost our economy as a whole and create the kind of food security we desperately need. The onus is now on the government to act.

Image: LN9267 Wah Fu via Wikimedia Commons