Comparing Bolsonaro and Trump: a flawed analysis?

By Cameron Frazer

It is easy to draw comparisons between Jair Bolsonaro and Donald Trump. They are both socially-conservative, populist leaders who are widely perceived by those on ‘the left’ as threats to fundamental democracy. But to make this connection is to ignore the framing of their respective ‘election rejections’. Bolsonaro is a more ‘nuanced rightist’ than Trump when it comes to his relationship with his nation’s democratic institutions. Taking him as a case study in tandem with others, we can learn much about the state of disillusionment that is widespread in our democratic politics. What is more prudent however, is that we take Bolsonaro and his motives to be the product of Brazil’s deeply complex political backdrop. 

Differing framings of the electoral results are crucial to understanding the differing implications between Brazilian and Western politics. Trump’s dismissal of the Presidential election was grounded in a belief in a wider conspiracy against him personally, even up to the level of his Vice President Mike Pence. Bolsonaro instead took issue with the technology used in the process, claiming that it was vulnerable to fraud.

 The difference in agency here is crucial. Trump’s conspiracy is a personal attack against him, whereas Bolsonaro began to build the narrative that it was Brazil being undermined by this alleged fraud. Whilst on the surface they are both rejections of elections, it is reductive to leave it at this. Bolsonaro’s attempt to overturn the election was seemingly half-hearted, leading to him being fined by the Supreme Court due to ‘bad faith litigation’. Trump was decisively defeated in the Electoral College before the Capitol riot on the 6th January 2021.

Bolsonaro’s attempt to overturn the election was seemingly half-hearted, leading to him being fined by the Supreme Court due to ‘bad faith litigation’. Trump was decisively defeated in the Electoral College before the Capitol riot on the 6th January 2021.

 Bolsonaro’s election rejection hardly had the zealous, concerted ‘anti-establishment’ mentality that Trump’s did. Bolsonaro won 49% of the vote in the elections run-off. This has echoes of the Brexit debate in this country, where at the time of the referendum the country was effectively split down the middle. This underlines the entirety of Bolsonaro’s narrative; his aim was to have enough votes discounted to secure 51% of the vote share. Conversely, Trump outright rejected American democracy as a holistic entity, rotten to the core. Both reject the result of the election, but the anti-institutional venom is not present in Bolsonaro’s case.

Electoral dissent in Brazil is symptomatic of the widening divisions within politics. Bolsonaro is defined as much by what he is against, as by what he is for. Opposed to social-liberalism and secularisation, the aforementioned vote share indicates that a significant portion of the population aligns with/tolerates his views. After his defeat, Bolsonaro called for his supporters to stop blocking roads in protest of his loss, calling the method ‘unproductive’. Yet, the blockades were maintained, suggesting to us that they were motivated by genuine opposition to Lula, rather than by loyalty to Bolsonaro. 

Whilst Trump’s electoral rejection was grounded in a defence of ‘Making America Great Again’, Bolsonaro’s supporters virulently opposed the left-wing government’s association with corruption. Likewise, Trump has frequently levelled allegations of corruption against the Democrats, particularly towards Biden. These have never gained widespread traction. On the other hand, Lula’s successor and former Chief of Staff, Dilma Rousseff, was impeached on corruption charges during Brazil’s worst economic crisis in modern times. The crisis was widely believed to have begun due to misguided government macroeconomic policies, contributing to some Brazilians’ negative perception of Lula’s ‘establishment’. 

There have always been politicians who thrive off controversy and are seen as anti-establishment disruptors. Trump is a billionaire; Bolsonaro is an army captain. These are not grassroots anti-establishment figures. Part of this persona is crafted through the espousal of conservative views. I have chosen Trump as a comparison to Bolsonaro because he has grown to dominate the discourse on ‘rightist populism’. His character looms so largely over Western politics that we have imprinted his motivations and actions onto foreign leaders. Marine Le Pen, Nigel Farage and Bolsonaro have all enjoyed this mirroring. It is incredibly tempting to make this comparison, but there is a risk of overshadowing the genuine grievances of people driven to vote for someone that ‘we’ brand as ‘unelectable’. 

Image: Zumapress via The Advocate