Forbes, Fiascos and Florida: the rift within the SNP

By Cameron Frazer

Socially conservative undertones have run rife in Europe as of late. The President of Madrid declared she wanted to turn the city into the ‘Florida of Europe’. In Scotland, whilst not as warm as Florida or Madrid, the temperature of this debate has increased markedly. Kate Forbes’ admittance that she would not have voted in favour of the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013 or the 2014 Scottish equivalent has incited considerable backlash from liberal groups and medias across the United Kingdom. The political ripples from this have reached such an extent that the story has now been covered by the media of the entire political spectrum. So broad is the discussion now that it barely relates to the original subject matter at all. Accusations of the BBC dropping LGBTQ activist groups which supported Forbes right to freedom of speech has mired the discussion in a way reminiscent of American news culture. This is the fixation in our political discourse with past, settled political debates, which harmfully detracts our attention from the future.

There may not even be the need for Forbes to hit the reset on her campaign. The debate becomes more complex with each new group proclaiming their support or disgust for Forbes. Moving beyond the actual issues Forbes addressed, the discussion has become centred on the role of practicing religious figures in politics. Sympathetic writers in the Telegraph have framed Forbes as being targeted by ‘woke’ cancel culture, intent on removing the openly religious from politics. This exists as evidence of a conflation of religiosity with an inherent social conservatism. 

Moving beyond the actual issues Forbes addressed, the discussion has become centred on the role of practicing religious figures in politics

Mr Yousaf, the second highest polling candidate, is a practicing Muslim and holder of progressive social views. Pro-Forbes media generally ignores this fact. The publicity of these internal debates undermines the reputation of the SNP and indirectly of Scottish independence; cynical Conservative and Labour MPs have weighed in to undermine Sturgeon’s presentation of ‘us against Westminster’. Instead, it is progressives against conservatives, a tribalistic framing that deepens the political chasm. 

Forbes’ social views run counter to the presentation of the SNP that Sturgeon had worked very hard to cultivate: a progressive, left-wing party that has a virulent and young grassroots presence. Within this we can perhaps glean the reasoning for the greater scrutiny that Forbes has faced, in much the same way as the socialist Corbyn faced internal opposition from a centrist Labour party. Alternatively, in the Conservative party there is greater scope for religious traditionalism – Jacob Rees-Mogg is the obvious example. Should Forbes be elected, there may be many SNP voters with liberal persuasion that take this as a rejection of their own ethos, as well as the party ethos of the last ten years. 

Speculation as to whether this debate has scuppered Forbes’ prime ministerial ambitions is difficult to certify; currently she remains the front runner. Perhaps we should consider such a break from the established party line to be part of the image she is trying to present. Sturgeon’s motivation for leaving has been interpreted partly because of the Gender Recognition Bill and the division this caused. 

Perhaps we should consider such a break from the established party line to be part of the image she is trying to present

There is a social ideological rift within the SNP, just as there is within Labour and the Conservatives. What Forbes is attempting to do, instead of reconciling these factions, is dominate one by the other. Precedent for this return to traditional moralism does exist in British politics in the wake of party upheaval. Major attempted the move with ‘Back to Basics’ in 1997. If this precedent is anything to go by, such a move will not necessarily end in triumph. 

The opinion that Forbes holds on the sanctity of marriage lost in 2013 and 2014. In the current, tumultuous political climate of questioning democratic mandates, perhaps we should be grateful that she does not wish to overturn it. What is pressing for the future if she becomes leader is her conservative attitude towards contraceptives, pre-marital sex, and abortions. 

Same sex marriage is entrenched now, reform is underway within the Church of England as we speak. On the contrary, as witnessed in America, abortion is still very much in the firing line. It may be seen as increasingly pertinent to ensure that mired arguments of ‘culture wars’ do little to distract from the serious political choices that are available to us. In the case of Kate Forbes this requires taking her ideology as her politics, not as her faith. At the ballot box, we can only hope that Scottish voters take this into account.

Image: ScottishPolitico via Wikimedia Commons