Labour on cronyism: time for a crackdown?

By Cameron Frazer

Sir Keir Starmer’s declaration that he wants to “crack down on cronyism” is at once an attack on Conservative Party history, the conduct of the current government and an allusion to the Labour government that looks increasingly likely to control the levers of power. The degree to which it is concrete and meaningful policy rather than alliterative verse is undermined by the absence of structural changes that he has proposed. Confronted with an appalling reputation and state of public services it is perhaps an obvious avenue of attack for him to take. Yet the entrenched modus operandi for MPs and lobby groups, the “fast lanes, kickbacks” that Sir Keir references predominantly escape scrutiny.

Of the £47bn given out during the governments ‘bounce back’ scheme, an estimated £1.7bn were fraudulent. This is the group that Sir Keir directly targets with his proposed punishment for defrauding the government, suggesting up to 10 years imprisonment. Yet, figures from the National Audit Office concluded that fraud overall quadrupled during the Covid-19 period to £21bn. As appealing as it is to harden attitudes towards overtly criminal behaviour, critically as Sir Keir reshapes Labour to appear as the party of law and order, it does not address the monumental financial damages inflicted from within the political system itself. His comments regarding the “murkier picture” on how government contracts are delivered has yet to translate into tangible means of scrutinising them. The structural changes required to this process have not materialised, beyond Sir Keir promising a cultural shift in the way that a Labour government would conduct itself. Many argue that it is this lack of oversight and accountability that enabled the PPE procurement scandal under Matt Hancock, a frequent target of derision by Sir Keir during PMQs.

Increasing jail sentencing to 10 years for those who defraud the government fails to address the root cause of the problem

Increasing jail sentencing to 10 years for those who defraud the government fails to address the root cause of the problem found within the halls of Westminster; The Guardian observed that Johnson had brought himself down with the “corrosive culture of cronyism.” Epitomised by the Greensill scandal, the potential 5 year waiting period on ministers becoming lobbyists has now been scaled back. Perhaps under pressure from his own MPs, words alone remain to dissuade ministers for lobbying on behalf of the companies they once oversaw. This initial proposal was merely a revival of Angela Rayner’s suggestion at a speech to the Institute for Government in 2021. With its current regulatory powers, the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments (ACBA) can only urge ministers to police their own colleagues; in its limited purview, it is unable to provide the scrutiny required to temper some MPs’ impulses. What Sir Keir has not recycled is Angela’s suggestion that this should be altered. Labour is aware of the policies echoed in its own recent history, but Sir Keir has yet to full them to the forefront.

It is notable that this declaration coincides with both international and national promises to shock our existing governmental institutions. At home, Reform UK promises to end council wastage by implementing a blanket 5% reduction in budget. Abroad, Donald Trump suggests politically appointing civil servants to remove “intellectual” backlogs. The time for the mainstream parties to present pragmatic solutions to the problem of government corruption is fast running out. It may be correct to say that Sir Keir does not need to define the changes he will make to the state apparatus to clinch victory at a general election. But the very fact of not doing so dilutes his message of integrity and reform. Whereas once the House of Lords was berated for its cronyism and marked for replacement with an elected body, this has been shelved in anticipation a second term of Labour government. Perhaps we could have withstood the abandonment of this most public of constitutional reforms had the quieter, subtler scrutiny of the ACBA been empowered. Sir Keir has been vocal about the symptoms of cronyism and corruption within the Westminster system, but he is running the risk of being drowned out by the parties which benefit most from anger at the status quo.

There is a considerable level of cynicism and disillusionment surrounding British politics at present, very possibly reflected here. An attack on backroom deals and nepotistic ineptitude is surely a frontal challenge to this. Labour is on a steady course towards a government majority in the polls; Sir Keir fashions himself and Labour as the responsible technocrats of integrity that are ready to overturn the scandalous and shady government that came before it. The same was once said of Rishi Sunak. Where he differed was in his openness to challenge institutional traditions in a way that the Conservatives were not. In a time of record low trust in our democratic process and the people leading it, Sir Keir may yet have to assuage these concerns. Like Mr Sunak, Tony Blair, Harold Macmillan and so many others, he might regret relying on the strength of character of his ministers alone.

Image: Jorge Royan via Wikimedia Commons