Review: Mean Girls

By Matthew Travis

★★★★★

Twenty years after the cinematic release of Mean Girls (2004), is ‘fetch’ finally going to happen? It just might have had. Whilst a musical adaptation of Mean Girls may sound a touch contrived, the amusing songs and gripping book make for an exhilarating experience that truly adds a sense of depth to the Mean Girls universe. Wrap it up with a glossy set, fluid choreography, and add a pretty pink bow – you have a worthy adaptation of a cult classic that has you in stitches throughout.

Mean Girls is a coming-of-age story that needs no reminding to Millennials or Gen Zs. Indeed, the opening line of the musical is a reminder of what unfolds by the wonderful narrators, Janis and Damian, that “This is a cautionary tale about corruption and betrayal and getting hit by a bus.” Other references throughout the show like the emphasis on 3 October (fan-proclaimed Mean Girls Day), and the brief introduction of characters, assumes that the audience has a preexisting knowledge of the canon.

However, it is this expectation that builds the relationship with the audience: in a sense, we are already part of North Shore High School and know how the system works. The ‘Mathletes’ sit in that corner, the ‘Jocks’ next to them, and the ‘Plastics’ centre-stage towering over us untouchable. This allows the musical to go into depth regarding character development, rewarding the audience with a more nuanced exploration of their favourites through song and staging not found on the silver screen.

The musical opens with a ‘Mandatory Friendship Workshop’ run by the contagiously hilarious duo of Janis (Elena Skye) and Damian (Tom Xander). Skye, with her short hair, baggy clothes, and powerful dead-pan delivery, was excellent as a companion to Xander and as the foil to queen bee Regina (Clíona Flynn). In his role of being “almost too gay to function”, Xander was equally as dominant centre stage or in the wings where he comedically created chaos whilst blending into the ensemble. The pair’s rendition of ‘Revenge Party’ was a potent reminder of their hidden influence over their friend Cady (Lillia Squires) and Regina.

As the ‘Apex Predator’ and the paragon of a teenage prima donna, Flynn was equally as intimidating as she was desirable

However, what was impressive with this performance in paticular was that both Cady and Regina were played by understudies: with Charlie Burn and Georgina Castle being unavailable – a testament to the performance quality. As the ‘Apex Predator’ and the paragon of a teenage prima donna, Flynn was equally as intimidating as she was desirable. She moved with confident fluidity and seemingly gripped the rest of the ensemble – this was evident in her commanding introduction during ‘Meet The Plastics’ and her mischievous revenge in ‘World Burn’. The direction and choreography (Casey Nicholaw) helped to elevate Regina and Cady’s impact and status: just like the social order, whether by lifts or set elements, only Flynn and Squires were ever elevated above the ensemble.

Squires was excellent in portraying Cady’s gradual shift from a clueless new kid to the new Queen of the Plastics – particularly with her unmatched charisma in ‘Stupid with Love’.  Nevertheless, at the start, some frankly jarring writing made her feel a bit cringe; the rushed ending also slightly lost its poignancy, meaning her redemption arc failed to be fully complete nor didactic.

What I loved the most about Mean Girls was the psychological exploration of the Plastics. Scratching below the fragile veneer of Gretchen (Elèna Gyasi) and Karen (Grace Mouat), there is a sense that, just like every highschooler, they only want to be accepted and recognised amidst the chaos of youth. Whilst Gretchen may not be “the most complicated character since Chekhov’s Masha Kulygina”, as writer Tina Fey jokingly described, she is still perhaps the most emotionally charged character in the production. Gyasi pulls this off remarkably. From her birdlike squawking (referring to her position below Regina in the animalistic hierarchy) to the graceful acceptance of Cady’s coup d’état, she was constantly energetic.

Mouat is acutely aware of this duality between recognition and physical beauty, where she defines herself as beautiful but equally wishes to escape that very same conception

Likewise, Mouat with her Barbie-esque mannerisms was adorable, stealing every scene with her lackadaisical oblivion. A particular highlight was her song, ‘Sexy’, where she wishes it was “Halloween every day” before gently shuffling off-stage and altering it to “world peace”. Nevertheless, there is a sense that there is something deeper to Karen: Mouat is acutely aware of this duality between recognition and physical beauty, where she defines herself as beautiful but equally wishes to escape that very same conception – this makes for some interesting insights into teenage femininity. Just as with Regina, Cady, or Gretchen, for Karen it all comes back to acceptance. In this way, Mean Girls is a story of self-definition.

Whilst the musical was wonderful in its portrayal of teenage female empowerment, this did come with the risk of sideling the male characters. For example, Aaron Samuels (Daniel Bravo), the prize responsible for charging Cady and Regina’s conflict, was more a MacGuffin than an established character. Likewise, everyone’s favourite Mathlete, Kevin (Lucca Chadwick-Patel) was fittingly cringe but, again, underutilised. It is a shame that the minor characters felt flat and wedged in. Similarly, the once delightful Ms Norbury (Zoë Rainey) and Mr Duvall (Ako Mitchell) were unremarkable: many of their jokes did not land, and they just felt irrelevant. This made scenes in North Shore feel a bit unstructured and melodramatic, blurring the space between what was the high school and what was outside.

The set, thanks to Scott Pask, was equally as stunning as it was versatile – with an array of OLED panelling across the back of the stage – making for some dynamic staging. From a collage of Burn Book entries to the Masai Mara to the Plastic Palace (Regina George’s house), the visuals were striking and transitions fluid. The lack of a substantive set also freed up the stage for rolling on wheel-mounted props like school desks, beds, bathrooms, and even Damian’s Jazzy Powerchair.

“The theatrical version is far grander, fun, and complete”

Just like Cady’s story, the theatrical history of Mean Girls is full of ups and downs: taking Broadway by storm in 2018, the planned West End debut in 2021 was delayed by the COVID-19 pandemic. However, as Regina put it, “You took me down, but you didn’t finish me off” and Mean Girls opened in June this year. It is worth noting that the musical adaptation is remarkably different and far better than the Mean Girls (2024) that hit cinemas in January to mixed reviews. The theatrical version is far grander, fun, and complete – partly because the cinematic version cut over fourteen songs to adjust to a shorter runtime, but mainly because it is simply more engaging and playful.

Mean Girls is an entertaining musical that balances an established script (Tina Fey) with a new set of delightful music and lyrics (Jeff Richmond and Nell Benjamin). Whilst there is nothing revolutionary about this musical adaptation, it is certainly enjoyable and rightly deserves an extended run in the West End. The stronger focus on female empowerment and femininity, and the use of social media motifs helped to adapt this cult classic into a fun musical theatre experience that will blow away your expectations. It is worth a watch – just remember that “on Wednesdays we wear pink”.

Mean Girls is currently in performance at the Savoy Theatre, London. Rush rate tickets at £25 are available for every Mean Girls performance, in clear view locations. The rush rate is available through the TodayTix app. Tickets are available here.

Image Credit: Brinkhoff/Mögenburg