Reflections on the 2024 Edinburgh Fringe
By Matthew Travis
Last month, an article in The Times argued that the Edinburgh Festival Fringe is on the decline, the main causes being an over commercialisation complete with jam-packed venue schedules, an over-reliance on comedy, and pressure to keep down ticket prices squeezing performer profits. Likewise, the comic and presenter Richard Osman points out that, compared to its past glories, the Fringe is now “not a springboard to anything”.
I find this all far too negative. To many, the Fringe is not about polish or professionalism, it is about challenge and expression. It’s ‘edgy’. Consider its origins in 1947, swapping their Lee-Enfields for Chekhov’s gun, eight amateur theatre companies upstaged the Edinburgh International Festival. Going against the high culture parades of opera, orchestra, and ballet, these theatrical pioneers gradually won over their audiences with their comparably alternative performances. The lights flickered and the Fringe took centre stage.
While the Fringe may be over its commercial boom, it is certainly not bust. Last year I visited the Fringe for the first time, mainly visiting a school friend to watch his sketch-comedy group. However, during those few days, we went to shows that I never thought I would ever be interested in, such as a one-man show from the perspective of Harold Shipman (written by a victim’s grandson), an improv musical comedy from America, basically all of the university revues, and, naturally, some crappy stand-up to fill a spare hour.
The key to the Fringe is to grab on and don’t let go – see a bit of everything and find a niche. So that’s what I did…
At Platform 2 of Durham Station, I boarded the 08:22 to Aberdeen. In less than two hours I was marching through Waverley up the Fleshmarket to the Royal Mile. In the Old Town, the centre of the Fringe, I opened the Edfringe app and went from there.
Ascension, Dan Hazelwood – Bedlam Theatre

In this ‘Queer Historical Drama’, Ascension is a poignant dramatisation of the life and diary of Leendert Hasenbosch. The play focuses on the causes of Hasenbosch’s exile, career in the Dutch East India Company (VOC), and life on… Ascension Island. His crime? Sodomy. For fifty minutes, you are whisked from the factories of The Hague to the forts of the East Indies to Cape Town’s Table Mountain at a hurtling pace. As the story progresses, Hasenbosch begins to explore his sexuality more and more.
The play is effectively a one-man show with the writer, Dan Hazelwood, performing as Hasenbosch. The epistolary style of Ascension lent itself well to the dramatisation of a diary: it gradually introduced us to the premise of the play before getting down to brass tacks. In what was essentially a memory play full of reimagined pasts and reflections on family and relationships, the play felt personal.
Nevertheless, I found the play hard to follow at times. Often, this delicate timeline of past and present was blurred, making for a more opaque than clear experience. There were also interjections of street dance (as a fill-in for sex) and a flip chart that contained various exhibits on what ‘thirst’ meant – to me, this felt somewhat unnecessary. Additionally, Hazelwood sometimes seemed uncertain with movement around the stage, lacking conviction. Whilst Ascension was mostly enjoyable to watch, it failed to truly grasp the story. Perhaps this was due to it feeling a touch anachronistic in parts. If I was short on time, Ascension wouldn’t be at the top of my dance card.

Pork in Progress, Dominic McGovern – West Port Oracle

Stand-up comedy has forever been synonymous with the Fringe with the likes of Russel Brand, Steve Coogan, and Noel Fielding coming up through the ranks. Midnight or Midday there is always comedy at the Fringe. This makes stand-up an exceptionally hard market to stand out in. However, watching Dominic McGovern’s Pork in Progress from the airline seating of West Port Oracle’s basement, the middle seat has never felt so comfortable.
Despite there being only five of us in the audience, McGovern was unphased as he worked through his witty and personable set. Pork in Progress seems a bit like a third-life crisis: focus on McGovern’s past, the state of the Gen-Z world, and his relationship. Starting with some crowd work, it was perhaps inevitable as one of five that his eyes would turn to me. After telling him I was a student at Durham, McGovern fully embraced the stereotype asking me “What College are you in?” before in a harrowingly accurate jibe asking, “How are your mates Hugo and Ludo that I met at the Mixed Lacrosse social?”.
However, speaking to McGovern after the show, it turns out that he was at Durham himself ten years ago! “What College were you in?”, I asked. “Cuth’s”, he smiled back. Perhaps life does imitate art.
Through his set, McGovern seemed at ease and quick-witted. Callbacks come easy to him. His well-timed one-liners such as “Rock climbing is like soft play for management consultants” led to hilarious rambles on modern life. Other highlights were “My boyfriend is a doctor… so obviously I’m the breadwinner of the household”. Where McGovern shined was in his reflection on growing up: from his first concert to his love for musical theatre, he was funny and intriguing. Being only 45 minutes, I would have been happy if this flight was delayed and had been the full hour!

The Importance of Being Earnest, Conduit Productions – Paradise in The Vault

Conduit Productions’ take on Oscar Wilde’s classic left little to be desired. Inspired by Parker’s 2002 film, Kate Woodman directed a tantalisingly fun play that embraces the absurd and considers the serious. This is even more impressive considering that most roles were performed by university students. There was never a moment that felt slow – something hard to do over an hour and a half.
Dominic Inglis-Jones was commanding in his performance of Algernon Moncrieff, capturing his natural eccentricities with ease (as well as his love for many a cucumber sandwich). Likewise, Edward Pickersgill, playing Jack Worthing, was excellent in balancing the dichotomy of the stern yet respectable ‘Jack’ with his wild alter-ego ‘Earnest’. The real highlight was the pompous pair’s pursuit of Gwendolen (Francesca Field) and Cecily (Kate Woodman) complete with a riveting and well-executed serenade. With witty exchanges, playful squabbling, and obvious synergy, the Inglis-Jones/Pickersgill pairing was as effective as it was entertaining.
“Three addresses always inspire confidence, even in tradesmen” – The Importance of Being Earnest is never complete without a Lady Bracknell. Up steps to the plate Laurie Morgan who was excellent in playing the stern socialite, captured her forceful tone through excellent projection and rolling ‘Rs’. He also wore the role well with fluid movement and posture. This cross-gender portrayal of the Lady added comedic depth to the performance and provided a compelling contrast to the pairings of Inglis-Jones/Pickersgill and Field/Woodman.
Unlike most revivals of classics, Conduit Productions’ production did not feel like a CTRL-C / CTRL-V. It felt fresh and genuinely unique. From the eccentric costumes to the playful acting, the play truly captured the natural swagger and fun found in Wilde’s writing.

While I only saw three shows, I’m sure it’s possible to see five shows and still make the last train back to Durham. Or stay for a few days and throw in the Castle (and the military tattoo), Holyrood Palace, Arthur’s Seat, Calton Hill, a walk around the Meadows, the National Gallery, or HMY Britannia. It is impossible to be bored in Edinburgh.
After catching up with a friend over a pint in George Square, I strolled back to Waverley whilst reflecting on the day. Ascension, Pork in Progress, and The Importance of Being Earnest are all very different types of performances. None were professional. All were entertaining. Their glow and lure only possible from the limelight that illuminates the amateur during the Fringe.
I am aware this is hardly investigative journalism: there has been no forensic accounting, death threats, or shady whispering in a dimly lit café. Rather this is my innocent experience of the Fringe from the outside. Whilst professional productions may be on the decline at the Fringe (and undoubtedly their commercial viability), the perhaps more authentic amateur performances are still thriving. No matter what the headlines say, the magic of the Fringe is still alive.
Image credit: Matthew Travis.

