Review: Slave Play

By Matthew Travis

“My experience of the whole thing was utter confusion” says Jim, played by Kit Harington (Game of Thrones). Indeed, I wonder if that is the whole point of Slave Play (2018): to leave us perplexed yet eager to rationalise what, at times, seems irrational. This is the premise of the ‘Antebellum Sexual Performance Therapy’ (ASPT), a multiday retreat that seeks to explore the inner workings of the relationships of three interracial couples through role-play and discussion. Directed by Robert O’Hara, Slave Play is as equally as uncomfortable as it is comedic, making for a complex but ultimately exquisite piece of theatre. The plethora of backgrounds grounded in the characters’ intersectionality challenges the audiences’ pre-existing conceptions about identity, sexuality, and power dynamics. The excellent acting manages to draw out these conceptions in a thoughtful way.

Act One, the play-within-the-play, is set in the plantations of the Deep South. It is here where we are introduced to the characters through a series of frankly bizarre sexual encounters. This perverted fantasy, dominated by the slave-master power dynamic, unfolds through scenes such as Kaneisha (Olivia Washington, I’m a Virgo) encouraging her partner-turned-slave-driver Jim (Harington) to call her a slur and to use his whip on her. Likewise, the ‘Mistress of the House’, Alana (Maite Jauregui), lures her ‘servant’ Phillip (Troy Alexander) into bed, whilst Gary (Fisayo Akinade, Heartstopper) and Dustin (James Cusati-Moyer, Sistas) engage in a homoerotic tussle in the cotton. However, throughout these harrowing tableaux, there are undoubtedly comedic moments that ground the play in the present. Unsure whether to laugh or look away, one is only drawn deeper into these relationships.

These tableaux provide the context for the real dramatic crescendo in Act Two, as the somewhat annoying therapists Téa (Chalia La Tour) and Patricia (Irene Sofia Lucio) deconstruct the couples’ thoughts on what all this means. Harington was excellent in portraying the duality of his role: on the one hand, laidback body language and confused expressions reflecting the absurdity of Act One; on the other, tender gestures to Washington and strained monologues in an obvious attempt to rebuild their relationship. A particular highlight was James Cusati-Moyer who, declining to identify as any specific race, refuted the idea that he was white. His emotionally dominating physicality was effective as he moved confidently around the stage sharing his struggle and pushing his point with nuance. Similarly, Troy Alexander, playing the macho man who doesn’t see his race but ‘only Philip’, gradually uncovers his conception of Blackness through powerful storytelling. Through the ASPT, the couples gradually connect race and identity with intimacy issues the couples’ face.

Making for a somewhat 360-degree performance, there is no hiding in Slave Play.

A series of mirrors line the upstage forming the back wall. This simple yet effective feature, designed by Clint Ramos, invites the audience to question their perspective: their gaze is on the actors as well as themselves. Making for a somewhat 360-degree performance, there is no hiding in Slave Play. This is something that the two therapists encourage complete with their own personal and relationship flaws. Act Three, focussed exclusively on Harington and Washington, is as equally tender as it is disturbing. Placed inside the bedroom, the fallout of the ASPT brings the play full circle to a similar dynamic found in Act One. The audience cannot help but be shocked.

Slave Play is not without its controversy. During its first of two runs on Broadway in 2019 (and 2021), the play introduced the concept of ‘Black Out performances’, which will be continued in London. The scheme aims to increase the awareness and participation of Black communities in theatre. The concept is that for two running nights only Black people are encouraged to watch the play – in effect making the theatre a space for Black people to enjoy the work of Black playwrights (in this case Jeremey O. Harris). This attracted criticism from the previous Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, who through a spokesman described it as ‘wrong and divisive’. My view? The performing arts have always struggled with accessibility as well as inclusivity. The premise of theatre is to reflect the world around us, allowing the audience to question, analyse, and enjoy the performance. Therefore, making theatre more accessible to traditionally under-represented groups can only be a positive. Are there other ways to achieve wider access? Probably. Is this a good starting point? Definitely.

Without an interval, the two hours of Slave Play is an emotional rollercoaster that must be taken head-on. A far cry from virtue signalling or ‘wokeism’, the play tackles divisive and complex themes such as intersectionality and identity in a thoughtful way. Nor does the play trivialise historical themes of slavery, as some critics have suggested. From its absurd start to its poignant conclusion, Slave Play grips. The superb acting throughout further draws you in as it takes you on a journey that lacks clear logic or definitive answers, whether from the characters’ relationships, sexual encounters, or the wider story. Yet this makes Slave Play feel so real: it does not patronise or lecture. Instead, it questions, laughs at, and reasons with itself. As Chekhov said, “The role of the artist is to ask questions, not to answer them” – precisely what Slave Play does.

Slave Play is in performance at the Noël Coward Theatre, London until 21st September. Tickets are available here.

Image credit: Noël Coward Theatre.