Review: chicago
By Matthew Travis
Amidst the lights, showbiz, and cabaret of 1920s Chicago, you are either the story or a forgotten starlet. At least that is the case in this transatlantic touring adaptation of a Broadway classic. Written by Fred Ebb and Bob Fosse, there are not many musical theatre lovers who have not seen or at least heard of Chicago. Indeed, with the 1,400 seats of the Bradford Alhambra fit to burst, it seems this is true in the UK’s 2025 City of Culture.
The story of Chicago is relatively simple: it follows the crimes, trials, exploits, and desires of the women inside Cook County Jail. The musical focuses on the media frenzy around two cases in particular – those of the performers Velma Kelly and Roxie Hart, who decided that they could use these trials as a performance to first be acquitted of their murders and then launch a star-studded career. Alongside them is a sleazy yet capable lawyer in Billy Flynn, a powerful mother hen in Matron ‘Mama’ Morton, and plenty of raunchy costumes. Tie it up with some energetic numbers and then you have yourself a musical.
It seemed that, at times, this simplicity prevailed too often compared to the ‘Razzle Dazzle’ of the Roaring Twenties
At least that is supposed to be the idea. It seemed that, at times, this simplicity prevailed too often compared to the ‘Razzle Dazzle’ of the Roaring Twenties. From the set to the costumes, the presiding colour was black. With little accenting to add any character save from a few ostrich feather fans, the production felt drab and flat. There was just something exciting and bold missing that no number of understated sparkles or fishnets could make up for.
The same can be said about the set: there was none. Instead of using the space, there was a sense of filling the space. This translated into a thirty-foot seating terrace to hold the band, taking up 2/3 of the stage. This, I felt, drew attention away from the performance as your gaze is naturally pulled to the densest part of the stage. Apart from a few saving features like a cleverly used trapdoor and a pair of ladders by the wings, nothing in the design caught my eye. Unfortunately, this made the performance feel unfairly lacklustre.
Nevertheless, where Chicago shined was in its casting and quality of performance. Faye Brookes (Coronation Steet), as Roxie Hart, was excellent in capturing her raw charm and questionable idiosyncrasies. Brookes was confident acting and clinical in her dancing. Likewise, Djalenga Scott (Annie, Piccadilly Theatre, 2017), playing Velma Kelly, led a striking rendition of ‘All That Jazz’ and was a natural storyteller throughout the two hours. More a performer than an actor, Kevin Clifton (Strictly Come Dancing) was as entertaining and likeable as Billy Flynn. He wore the role well and matched the much-needed swagger that made the lawyer perhaps the greatest vaudevillian of them all.
From the engaging ‘Cell Block Tango’ to the twist in ‘Me and My Baby’ the ensemble supported the protagonists commendably
Another particular highlight was Brenda Edwards (We Will Rock You, London Coliseum, 2023) playing the powerful Matron ‘Mama’ Morton who acted as the anchor/matriarch of Cook County Jail. From the engaging ‘Cell Block Tango’ to the twist in ‘Me and My Baby’ the ensemble supported the protagonists commendably – despite the interesting staging choice to seat them by the wings throughout.
Although there were sometimes tracts of uninspired choreography and questionable acting choices, the singing could not be faulted. It must also be acknowledged that, as a tour production, this particular adaptation was limited in its size, scale, and budget compared to its Broadway counterpart. However, the inherent waves of blandness and monotone throughout meant that there was always the feeling of something missing.
With the UK tour underway until August 2025, there are plenty of opportunities to catch a performance. If you like Chicago or musical theatre then I would recommend a watch; if not, I would probably give it a miss.
Chicago is in performance at the Theatre Royal, Newcastle (28th October – 2nd November) and the Palace Theatre, Manchester (4th – 9th November). Tickets for the UK Tour are available here.
Image credit: Tim Green via Wikimedia Commons

