Review: treasure island

By Matthew Travis

★★★★★

With treasure, punch-ups, and plenty of rum, Durham Student Theatre’s adaptation of Treasure Island was captivating. Only five weeks into term, the DST freshers’ play has set an admirable benchmark for the year ahead.

Based on the novel by Robert Louis Stevenson, and adapted by Bryony Lavery, Treasure Island is a swashbuckling tale of adventure, cunning, and wit. As effectively a coming-of-age story, the narrative lens is trained on the young adventurer Jim Hawkins (played by Alice Toner) on her journey from a barmaid to a pirate. This journey is sparked by a chance encounter with a lodger, Billy Bones, at the Admiral Benbow Inn – where Jim works. After Billy’s somewhat brutal death at the hands of another pirate, she finds a mysterious treasure map and is persuaded by some of the inn’s punters to join them on an intrepid adventure to locate the treasure.

On the Seven Seas, on their ship called ‘The Hispaniola’, they are joined by the charismatic captain Long John Silver (played by Tristan Betts) – who Jim forms a father-like bond with. Joining him are his crew of pirates that charm their way onboard and try to remain undercover from the expedition’s loveable bankroller (Squire – Max Hildred), mother hen (Dr Livesey – Martha Buttle), and actual captain (Smolett – Cillian Knowles). However, no good pirate story is complete without a mutiny, and what ensues on the island is a story of betrayal, horror, and redemption.

The most captivating part of Treasure Island was the fantastic depth and dexterity of acting

The Assembly Rooms is a challenging space for a student production: it is a deep end-on stage with plenty of potential for technical and dramatic complexity. Something which Treasure Island did well to handle with a multi-levelled set that transformed from a pub to a ship to a forest with a drop of a rope and shunt of some tables. However, this also meant there were some challenges. The terse grumbling of pirate speak in the opening scenes and in the hectic unravelling of the ending meant that, at times, it was difficult to hear with any clarity. Likewise, I felt that Jim’s monologues felt a touch out of place as Toner would jump down stage to deliver a brief update before returning up stage.

The most captivating part of Treasure Island was the fantastic depth and dexterity of acting. The anchor of this was the wholesome but ultimately betrayed relationship between Jim and Long John Silver. Toner was excellent in capturing the youthful sprite and energy needed to sustain the heroism in the plot. Betts, with enough magnetism to rival Jack Sparrow, was a highlight of the show. His pirate drawl was clear, and his subtle gesticulations were powerful. There was something quite impressive and convincing in his dramatic range that allowed him to start off as a helpful out-of-work cook in Bristol before gradually shifting to be a murderous mutineer.

Other standout performances were that of Squire and Dr Livesey. Hildred was witty, playing Squire’s natural oblivion but loveable ignorance with ease – deservedly gaining the most laughter from the audience. Likewise, as the knowledgeable but terse doctor, Buttle was effective in playing the dichotomy between her concern for Jim but love for adventure and bounty. Nevertheless, a few of the minor characters outside of Silver’s mass of mutineers could have benefited from a bit more clarity and deliberateness in their choices.

This is even the more impressive considering that this was the casts’ first experience of university drama – I’d keep an eye out for them

In this way, Treasure Island is a production that plays to the seriousness of the plot yet embraces the liveliness of a pirate’s life. The costumes were exceptional in doing this with, as ‘Dick the Dandy’ (Harriet Miller) kindly noted, an appropriate array of buccaneering tricornes, colourful sashes, and daggers. This touch really helped elevate the fight-scenes as it provided visual contrasts and highlighted intricate movements. It also helped differentiate members of the ensemble: for example, the aptly named and intentionally forgettable Grey (Mariella Locke) was comparatively drab. 

Credit must be given to the director (Archie Elliot) for what was an entertaining production. Alongside the impressive acting from the cast, the technical design and costumes helped to establish a formidable swashbuckling spirit that was sustained throughout. This is even the more impressive considering that this was the casts’ first experience of university drama – I’d keep an eye out for them.

Image credit: Durham Student Theatre