The Great American Playwright of the 1950s

By Matthew Travis

The 1950s was a period of global social and political transition: the Second World War was over, European empires were gradually falling, and the world was moving towards modernity. It was also in the 1950s that those born in the ‘Silent Generation’, the generation bearing the brunt of The Great Depression, became adults with the world at their feet. For me, the 1950s is one of the great peaks of American theatre – mainly because of how real and gritty it felt. The stories were not pretentious, they spoke in clear language about real situations often placed in the context of historical events or family interactions. In other words, the theatre felt relatable. Commercially Broadway was also in bloom with the debut of the likes of Guys and Dolls, West Side Story, and The King and I.

Of course, just like the classic debate over the ‘Great American Novel’, there is also a debate over who was the ‘Great American Playwright’. My nomination goes to Tennessee Williams and Arthur Miller. Both playwrights are exceptional story tellers: they wrote about what they knew, drew from personal and cultural experiences, and produced plays that feel fundamentally American. 

For me, the 1950s is one of the great peaks of American theatre

Williams’ plays are stylistically poetic and emotional. In his writing there is a hidden depth to his characters and plot lines tend to revolve around their relationships to each other – there is always a secret. Coming from Mississippi, the majority of Williams’ plays are based in the American South, including the wonderful accents and Southern charms. His personal relationships are also fundamental to understanding his plays: his parents had a strained marriage, his father was an alcoholic and often absent, and his sister struggled with schizophrenia – he was also gay.

The Glass Menagerie, set in his home town of St Louis, sees an ambitious but lost Tom Wingfield battling it out with his controlling mother, Amanda, and mentally unstable sister. The fragility of Tom’s dreams, to escape a world where “People go to the movies instead of moving”, conflicts with his obligations to his family. Similarly, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof is effectively about the breakdown of a dysfunctional family. Set in the backdrop of the wealthiest plantation in Mississippi, there is a story of greed, lies, and personal repression. Add in a dying father, an alcoholic son, and a strong female character in ‘Maggie the cat’ that could even rival Hedda Gabbler, and you have a gripping deep dive into the complexities of human relationships.

In contrast to this more poetic and somewhat personal style in Williams’ writing, Miller’s writing is far more political, moralistic, and grounded in the feeling of modern drama. Born in 1915 to a Jewish family, Miller grew up in New York during The Great Depression. He is well known for his second marriage to Marilyn Monroe. As a suspected Communist, and member of the well-known communist group called the ‘League of American Writers’, Miller faced constant media and political scrutiny – famously culminating in his appearance before the House Un-American Activities Committee created by Congress to investigate the far left and right.

The Crucible is perhaps Miller’s magnum opus. In a dramatic retelling of the Salem Witch Trials, Miller uses the hysteria and chaos from the boundless acquisitions of sorcery as an allegory for McCarthyism (a ‘red scare’ and political repression led by Joseph McCarthy during the ‘40s and ‘50s). The play is one about responsibility, blame, and personal morality guided by the internal conflict of the protagonist, John Proctor – who had an affair with the very girl who triggers the witch-hunt.

Coming from Mississippi, the majority of Williams’ plays are based in the American South

Death of a Salesmen touches on the conceptualisation of the American Dream and its devastating consequences when it becomes unattainable, critiquing its false promise, the myth of meritocracy, and the human cost to chasing what is essentiality an illusion. Along with his other classics like All My Sons and A View from the Bridge, his plays focus on inherently American issues like the Military-Industrial Complex, pursuit of the American dream, justice, as well as more common theatrical tropes like honour, loyalty, and love.

Although not as grand or popular as their musical counterparts, these early 20th century American plays are no stranger to the West End, or indeed Durham. It is extremely rare for there to be a period in the West End where there is at least not one of a Williams or a Miller in performance or in production. In 2022, Amy Adams starred as Amanda in The Glass Menagerie at the Duke of York. In 2023, the National Theatre’s production of The Crucible transferred to the Gielgud. Cat on a Hot Tin Roof is currently enjoying a sold-out run at the Almeida, and likewise in February A Streetcar Named Desire will run at the Noël Coward Theatre with Paul Mescal in the starring role. Indeed, my debut review for Palatinate was Miller’s A View from the Bridge at the Theatre Royal Market.

The 1950s was a golden age for American theatre: a time when two of its greatest playwrights were at their peak. It was also a time of growing economic boom leading to a greater middle class who were engaging more with Broadway and theatre more generally. However, amidst the changing post war context, the questioning of American ideas created dramatic opportunities that still pack a punch seventy years later. For Miller, his plays were social commentaries grounded in historical and political events; for Williams, they were a study of relationships and character in the context of a rich cultural landscape – both considered the personal character and placed them alongside broader social critique. Together, they defined an era of theatre.

Image credit: Bill Gold and Warner Bros. via Wikimedia Commons