‘Superfoods’: Saviour or Sinister?

By Abi Saddington

Content Warning: This article contains mentions of eating disorders. Reader discretion is advised.

The year is 2003. The processed foods invented in the 70s are becoming increasingly popular. The Aitkins diet, advocating carbohydrate restriction for weight loss, is having a major resurgence. The South Beach Diet by Arthur Agatson has just been published, categorising certain carbs and fats as good or bad based on glycemic index. Growing globalisation has led to the importation of produce not grown in the UK.

Out of this rapidly changing diet landscape came the growth of the concept of the ‘superfood’.

Quinoa was a rare acceptable carb amidst the craze for lowering them. Flaxseed, too, was often used as a replacement for flour. It is true that these foods have a lower glycemic index than wheat, which can be helpful for lowering the risk of heart disease and used in conjunction with other foods in order to reverse type 2 diabetes. These foods were two of the few acceptable carb replacements on the South Beach diet.

From quinoa, to flaxseed, to the goji berry: here were the signposts of the new era.

Superfoods were never a magic medicine, only the illusion of a solution

The goji berry became famous for being an antioxidant. Acai berries also have a low glycemic index, and are a source of fiber. These both were adopted into low-carb diets.

Cruciferous vegetables like kale, cauliflower, and swiss chard also grew in popularity. Kale and chard are relatively high in iron and antioxidants, and cauliflower is both high in fibre and rich in vitamin C. On the Aitkins diet especially, low carbohydrate vegetables like these were extremely valuable. They were similarly indispensable on the ‘volume eating’ diet developed by Barbara Rolls in 2000, where high water low calorie foods were meant to be eaten in huge quantities in order to satiate hunger.

In the midst of rising obesity levels and gradual encroaching of ultra processed foods in supermarkets, ‘superfoods’ seem like a breath of fresh air: but nutrition is never so simple. 

While diets like the Aitkins diet and South Beach diet drew attention to these undoubtedly nutritious foods, the glorification of the term ‘superfoods’ often led to overstatement of the benefits. Goji berries in fact have harmful side effects like hypotension when eaten in too large quantities, as well as overconsumption of antioxidants having been linked to increased risk of certain cancers due to oxidative cell damage(although this is in extreme cases). 

A crucial element of sustainable nutrition is moderation, and the framing of these nutritious foods as ‘superfoods’ obscures that. Yes, these foods may contain useful vitamins and minerals, but the term through which they have been framed suggests a heroism which simply is not true. It is important not to approach food with a morality mindset – foods are not good or bad, but have different levels of nutrition to them.

Superfoods were never a magic medicine, only the illusion of a solution.

Should food be treated as ‘good’ or ‘bad’, or simply as food?

A larger issue developed throughout the 2000s of the food morality system. Think of the WeightWatchers ‘points’ based programme developed in 1997 for example, grown rampant in the 2000s. There was a feverish cultural obsession with weight loss in this decade, and this was a big contributor to that.

This mental framework which allows superfoods to be presented as saviours allows other food groups to be demonised. The Aitkins, South Beach, and volume eating diets may be promoting reduced carbohydrates in pursuit of certain health outcomes like weight loss, but ultimately this feeds into a negative misrepresentation of carbohydrates which makes it difficult to accurately assess their nutritional value.

Should food be treated as ‘good’ or ‘bad’, or simply as food?

And on the other end of the spectrum came a spike in eating disorders for young people. Superfoods, co-opted into the food morality system, enabled increased rates of

 eating disorders such as orthorexia (an obsession with eating healthy food which often accompanies other eating disorders, although it is not a diagnosable issue in its own right according to the DSM-5 and the NHS). Over-restricting one food group is still a restriction, which cannot be maintained over time. Superfoods are nutritionally brilliant and deserve better than to have been co-opted into an unfortunate culture of obsessive dieting.

Yes, foods are more nutritionally complete than others. Certainly they deserve to be recognised for this, and using the term ‘superfoods’ seems like a simple enough way to promote to people which foods are helpful and which are not. However, other than being nutrient-dense, there is not a lot these foods have in common with each other. The last thing the nutrition field needed in the 2000s, already rife with contested and ambiguous advice, was more ambiguity.

Some interesting and wonderful foods emerging from this ‘superfood’ trend are still embedded into our culture today, but alas so is the same morality system that the term was founded on. If we are to do these foods justice, we must overhaul this system and consume them sustainably, without glorifying them.

Image Credit: Amarina de Labaume