Popular fiction vs literary elitism: which is the real trash?

By Abi Saddington 

There are certain books are by default seen as less worthy of being read. They will waste your time, are poorly written, and will slowly rot your brain to dust. These are the books commonly known as “trashy lit”.

I would like to propose that we unlearn some of these biases against “trashy lit”. Not all fiction is obligated to be impeccably written. Disrespecting people based on their choice of book is often based in bigotry. And at the end of the day, there’s nothing more important than finding something to help your brain to calm down, switch off, and rewire.

Reading in any form can be beneficial for your mental health. A study in Liverpool by Billington et al. found “statistically significant improvements in the mental health of depressed patients had occurred during the 12-month period in which they had attended reading groups”. Although this may be correlation, it nevertheless suggests a positive relationship between reading and improved wellbeing.

As students, it can be difficult to switch off from using a critical brain when reading, especially as deadlines begin to loom. There is guilt associated with shutting off from study, and the temptation to replace reading for relaxation entirely with academic study is ever present. But study cannot happen effectively without prioritising your mental health and making time to do things which relax you. ‘Trashy’ books will create a clear distinction between work and play, aiding relaxation (not every activity has to be laser focused on learning).

‘Trashy’ books will create a clear distinction between work and play, aiding relaxation

But is it worth examining what ‘trashy lit’ really means? In Michael Aaron Rockland’s dynamic article “Popular Culture: Why Study Trash?”, we learn that often what is considered trashy is  popular with its contemporaries, and furthermore it is possible for books “once regarded as trash to become ‘classics’ of our literature”. The novel form itself was once derided as in poor taste, for women with nothing better to do, where now it is a respected object of academic investigation. Look at Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Jekyll and Hyde”, lambasted for being sensationalist, now revered for its examination of the duality of the human psyche. Even Shakespeare was only elevated to literary master status after his death. 

Rockland also argues that “new cultural forms usually emerge from below”, referring to marginalised groups. While I am not using this argument to suggest that all trashy fiction should be elevated to literary status (and recognise that it is controversial to refer to marginalised people as “below”) I hope that this highlights that some forms of popular literature are underappreciated for systemic reasons, and objective value is hard to identify. Nevertheless, regardless of how “literary” something is perceived, you should feel free to enjoy it.

Let us take the example of the ‘chick flick’ genre – criticised and ridiculed as a cheap form of entertainment. This attitude extends to literary criticism, where Burcu Baykan notes the genre is often denounced as “trivial fiction” in a 2015 article. And yet the genre illuminates “research about popular literature…as well as women’s writing and reading practices”. 

Put simply, there is a lot of value to be gleaned from things which are popular, as they explore cultural phenomena and illustrate the interests of a population. The recent resurgence of Twilight into the popular cultural sphere of discussion has been fascinating not only for nostalgic purposes, but because of the influx of popular psychoanalytic discourse. People are looking to Twilight to figure out what it means to desire something, and to explore the nature of those desires.

There is a lot of value to be gleaned from things which are popular, as they explore cultural phenomena and illustrate the interests of a population

When reading for pleasure, there is not always a motive to analyse the fiction and examine its relationship to the cultural sphere. Hopefully, though, being aware of the ever-changing opinions of critical reception, as well as the ability to use ‘trashy lit’ as a tool to examine popular attitudes and debates of the time, helps to lessen some of the guilt in the guilty pleasures you read. 

Reading for pleasure is an easy ticket to bettering your wellbeing. Let no critical discourse discourage you from doing whatever helps you to unwind.

Image credit: “Breakfast at Tiffany’s” via Pinterest