Kemi Badenoch’s shadow cabinet: a reach across the divide?

By Barnaby Howell

2005 was the last time that a new Conservative leader had to form a shadow cabinet after losing a general election. For context, that is almost as long as the individual reigns of Tony Blair, Gordon Brown and David Cameron combined.

Kemi Badenoch is at the helm, having decisively won the Conservative Leadership Election, and now takes on the mantle of Leader of the Opposition as well as of her party.

Needless to say, she faces some significant challenges. Namely that there are about 120 ministerial positions, yet she herself only has 121 MPs. Whilst not every position must be shadowed, this will undoubtedly spread His Majesty’s Official Opposition more thinly than they would have desired. Surely, the most crucial appointment in managing those MPs must be Rebecca Harris, who now becomes the Opposition Chief Whip, aiming to keep the members of a notoriously factional party under control.

An interesting discussion revolved around how many of the five defeated leadership contenders would feature in the new setup

An interesting discussion revolved around how many of the five defeated leadership contenders would feature in the new setup, yet as it turns out three of the five feature prominently. Mel Stride, the centrist, as Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer is an experienced figure amongst a largely unfamiliar group, having served as MP for Central Devon from 2010, albeit with a present majority of only 61 votes. An eye-catching return from the backbenches for Priti Patel as the new Shadow Foreign Secretary. Dame Priti is an outspoken Eurosceptic, having also previously served as Home Secretary under Boris Johnson for three years. The defeated runner-up Mr Robert Jenrick becomes the Shadow Justice Secretary, himself advocating for the UK to leave the European Convention on Human Rights. These two crucial appointments suggest a hard line will be adopted regarding relations with the European Union. There is no place for either Tom Tugendhat or James Cleverly at present.

Who are the new faces? The most notable being Chris Philp, who is arguably not a household name outside of the party, yet has been entrusted with the vital position of Shadow Home Secretary. A former Minister for London as well as for Crime, Policing and Fire, he will be looking to transfer his experience in those departments into his new national role. Another keynote appointment comes knocking for James Cartlidge as the new Shadow Defence Secretary, having led the previous government’s defence procurement program shortly before their defeat. Ms Claire Coutinho remains on the Opposition frontbenches to shadow her former department for Energy Security and Net Zero, whilst Victoria Atkins is moved to scrutinise the government’s Environment, Food and Rural Affairs department. Lord Johnson of Lainston and Nigel Huddleston have been appointed as co-chairmen of the Conservative Party, seeking to reform the Conservative Campaign Headquarters, this being a key fixture of Ms Badenoch’s leadership campaign.

Some notable omissions include Jeremy Hunt, the UK’s longest ever serving Health Secretary, who has now retired to the backbenches, as well as the former Deputy Prime Minister Sir Oliver Dowden also stepping back. Lord Cameron himself, having returned spectacularly to front-line politics as Foreign Secretary under Mr Rishi Sunak, has now left politics permanently.

19 years since the last Conservative Shadow Cabinet was formed. Can Badenoch make the unelectable electable once again? Can the Conservative Party rebuild the trust of the British public by the next general election? Similar questions were posed to Cameron in 2005. Indeed, off the back of a routing by Labour, Kemi Badenoch and her new team will be hoping to emulate his success in the years to come.

Image: Conservative Party/Flickr