Memory and the Gothic in Carmen Laforet’s ‘Nada’
By Abi Saddington
What prevents the theme of memory in the university novel from becoming saccharine and uninteresting? In Carmen Laforet’s ‘Nada’, feeding the characters through a gothic lens.
Novels based in universities contend with the narrative task of navigating a protagonist from hopeful determination to a more educated, matured and analytically adept perspective. This is a task made doubly difficult for the protagonist of ‘Nada’, Andrea, who leaves her small town to pursue a literature degree in deprived, post-Civil War Barcelona.
“I arrived in Barcelona on a train different from the one announced, and no one was waiting for me”. Andrea arrives in the city disoriented, alone, and out of place. She steps into an apartment belonging to relatives she does not remember, “the air stagnant and rotting”. Rich and grotesque descriptions of the apartment abound, as Andrea meets the family she has forgotten from when she was a little girl, her educational fate tied up with her ability to reconcile with this past.
Andrea’s family are eccentric, conflict-prone and violent, the gothic mysticism of the novel’s framing enhancing the portrayal of an impoverished family wracked with inescapable Catholic guilt. Aunt Angustias, devout, attempts to control Andrea’s behaviour and save her from sin. Her Uncle Roman is a semi-successful violinist who refuses to take responsibility for his life. Uncle Juan beats his wife Gloria at erratic and frightening intervals. Presiding over all this is Andrea’s frail, wilfully ignorant grandmother. Told from Andrea’s perspective, there seems little hope for development and connection.
Laforet captures the enforcement of an oppressive Catholicised vision of subordinate womanhood, but liberates her protagonist through intellectual exploration
Yet when at the university, Andrea bursts free from the cobwebbed gothic confines of her family’s house, meeting Ena, the daughter of a wealthy family through whom she discovers artistic corners of the city.
The gothic descriptions of the house compared with the delights offered by Ena and the education she is associated with, and symbolise constitute the central tension of the plot, Andrea figuring out how to maintain a friendship with Ena while necessarily keeping ties with her family.
Written in the 1930s under the censorship of Francoist Spain, Laforet captures the enforcement of an oppressive Catholicised vision of subordinate womanhood, but liberates her protagonist through intellectual exploration and friendship: the cornerstones of the university novel. ‘Nada’ manages to surpass the strict media censorship laws of the era through avoiding direct mention of the regime, but its economic and social impact radiates through the imagery of the city, gothic and otherwise.
Political anxieties are funnelled through Andrea, her adolescence burgeoning into adulthood and fraught with environmental uncertainty. Laforet masterfully integrates social commentary into the novel’s growth, symbolised through Andrea’s girlhood.
This novel differs from others about university life in that it uses the gothic not as an aesthetic tool, but to evoke the central unspoken anxiety of those new to education: that progress is failing to take place, and the “stagnant, rotting” air of the past chokes those who attempt to travel past it. Andrea fulfils the trope of the hopeful rural young girl, yearning for culture and social mobility, trapped by the strategic deployment of the gothic into a past she forgot she belonged to.
It uses the gothic not as an aesthetic tool, but to evoke the central unspoken anxiety of those new to education
Laforet weaves together Andrea’s disparate threads of family and education through the complex relationship between Ena and Roman. Seemingly attracted to him because of his musical merit, Ena seduces Roman. Yet it is later revealed that she seduced him to seek revenge for his betrayal of her mother years prior. Andrea is not confined by her family, but enabled through her friendship with Ena to correct the wrongs of gender-based violence committed on previous generations.
Andrea’s future education is even subsidised by Ena’s family, as she is invited to live with them and escape the gothic apartment. Laforet subtly promotes gender equality in education against the gendered oppression of the Francoist regime.
“I was taking nothing from the house on the Calle de Aribau. At least, that’s what I thought then”: memory seems to happen to Andrea accidentally, her fortunes shaped by happenstance and unlikely friendship. The gothic descriptions of this novel, though, ensure that a precious allure suffuses Andrea’s past, her family, and its economic and religious background.
Laforet’s novel argues for the enriching role of education, a crucial period of development and necessary for women to have access to, as well as more importantly its ability to unify threads of past and present through inviting new relationships to form. Andrea’s family, and her future enabled by Ena, form cornerstones of Andrea’s life which explore the role of memory fascinatingly.
Image: Jose María Ligero Loarte via Wikimedia Commons

