A beginner’s guide to Cryptic Crosswords
By Mulholland (Joseph O’Keeffe)
To the uninitiated, cryptic crosswords can seem daunting and pretentious. While the latter is (somewhat) true, the former gripe can easily be resolved with a quick crash course on how exactly the clues of these puzzles function.
The format underlying every cryptic crossword clue is simple – the clues contain two discrete sections, one straight and one cryptic. While these can come in either order, their function remains the same.
The straight section of the clue gives a synonym for the answer, as in a normal crossword, where dog (6) could be canine or poodle.
The cryptic section of the clue, unique to these crosswords, provides a wordplay hint towards the answer. This can come in several forms, and recognising the type of wordplay employed is crucial to getting the hang of such clues.
All the below examples are taken from my recent crosswords in Palatinate, one of which is placed below for you all to practise this newfound knowledge on!
FORMS OF WORDPLAY
1. Anagrams
These clues have a series of letters that are an anagram of the answer. These will be placed next to an anagram indicator, typically a word that is synonymous with “rearranging”, “untidiness”, or “confusion.” These indicators can be straightforward such as the words “moved around” or more abstract such as the word “discombobulated.”
Ex → Barber’s so messy, fluid gets back in! (9)
Ans → REABSORBS, an anagram of “barber’s so” with the anagram indicator “messy.” The straight clue is “fluid gets back in”, which means “reabsorbs”.
2. Concealed Answers
These clues have a series of words that physically hide the letters of the answer. The words will be placed next to a concealment indicator, typically a word that is a synonym for “containing”. Again, the indicators can be straightforward or vaguer.
Ex → Manic unease encapsulates a ward (3)
Ans → ICU, which is hidden in “manIC Unease,” with the container indicator “encapsulates”. The straight clue is “a ward”, which means “ICU”.
3. Homophones
These clues have a definition for a word that verbally sounds like the answer. The word will be placed next to a homophone indicator. Again, this indicator will be, to varying degrees of directness, synonymous with a word for “hearing.”
Ex → Singular sound of the heart (4)
Ans → SOLE, which is defined by “singular” in the straight clue. For the wordplay, “sole” sounds like “SOUL”, which “heart” defines. Usage of a homophone is shown by the indicator “sound of.”
4. Charades
These clues simply have a definition for two or more words, which, when put together in the order they are given, add up to the answer. They do not need an indicator, although can come with one, usually synonymising “make” or “create.”
Ex → Snake’s bone floats on water? (4) Ans → BOAT, meaning “floats on water” in the straight clue. This is cryptically clued by “snake”, being “BOA”, followed by “bone”, being “T”, referring to a “T-Bone” steak. There is no indicator present, as is common with charade clues.
5. Removals
Here, a synonym for a word is given next to an indicator for removal. Typically, this is a synonym for “removing”. Often, this will make clear what letter to remove – any synonym of “headless” indicating a loss of the first letter, and any synonym of “hollow” indicating a loss of the central letter. The resulting word created will be the straight answer to the clue.
Ex → Success initially absent in round (6)
Ans → INNING. This is “winning”, defined in the clue by success”, without its first letter. The removal here has been indicated by “initially absent”. This creates “inning”, the answer, clued by round.
6. Reversers
Here, a word that is the reverse of the answer is clued, next to an indicator for reversal. As usual, this will be given by a synonym to “reversing”.
Ex → Time one is due to return in date? (3)
Ans → ETA. This is defined by “time one is due”. It is found backwards in “date”, as “ETAd”, a reversal indicated by “return”. The fact this is hidden inside of the word date is indicated by “in”, an indicator for concealed answers.
7. Double Definitions
Here, the cryptic part of the clue is secretly a second definition for the answer! Therefore, these clues are simply made up of two different synonyms for the answer.
Ex → Neuter gun (4)
Ans → Nerf. This means both the toy gun, and to neuter.
8. Initial / Final / Alternate Letters
Here, a series of words are given, with the first letter of each individual word in the sequence together spelling out the answer in order. Alongside them is an indicator for this process, typically synonymous with “first.” Final or alternate letter wordplay can be used in a similar fashion, both with their own indicators, the former synonymising “last”, and the latter synonymising “every other.”
Ex → The first person involved is irrational (2)
Ans → PI. This is straightly defined by “irrational”. It is formed from the first letters of “Person Involved”, an initial letter process clued by the indicator “first.”
9. Containers
These clues contain two separate definitions for two discrete words. One of these words is placed around the other to create the answer. They are accompanied by a containment indicator for this process – a synonym for “holding”.
Ex → Green accepted into Russian party initially to earn back losses (6)
Ans → RECOUP, “ECO”, defined by “green”, inside of RUP. This is defined by “Russian”, which is “RU” and “party initially”, which is “P”. The straight clue is to “earn back losses.”
10. Combinations
These clues are harder, combining any number of the past 9 techniques. The past rules still apply for each aspect of the clue. Here, however they are placed as a whole together in a manner similar to the charade style of clue. Indicators, which here would synonymise “with” or “followed by” are possible but not necessary.
The past container clue for RECOUP is an example of this, as it has both elements of container and initial letter wordplay working in tandem.
OTHER THINGS TO KNOW
- Cryptic crossword writers are called setters, and often operate under a pseudonym.
- The above techniques are by far the most common forms of wordplay found in cryptics, but harder crosswords from more esoteric setters employ an even wider range of techniques. Techniques with goofy names such as spoonerisms, puns, and stuttering are not uncommon. Sometimes, the entire clue is both a cryptic and straight definition for the answer, rather than being split into two sections! However, the aforementioned techniques are enough to help you become well versed in these puzzles.
- Setters, including myself, sometimes like to incorporate a theme into their crosswords, usually involving some unclued words. Don’t fret if, for instance, 1 Across and 7 Down do not have corresponding clues! For these clues, you will have to guess the words using intersecting letters from other given clues in the grid. Their solution will be linked to the overarching theme. In my first crossword, if you solved all the given clues, you were left with squares reading V_LV_ _, D_I_E, and _AN. Filled in, these are all the last words of the titles of David Lynch films (which was the theme).
- Be careful for red herrings! Cryptic crossword setters often mislead you from the true straight definition in their clue. Remember that the phrasing of the clue as a whole is usually irrelevant, and the straight clue at the start or end of the sentence is the only truly important definition to look for.
- Cryptic crosswords frequently use abbreviations! You will know many of these already. Some examples are: street being St, six being VI, elements being their symbol. The NATO phonetic alphabet is used too. A helpful link for these abbreviations is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossword_abbreviations.
PUZZLES TO PRACTISE ON
Some great free beginner online cryptics are linked below, alongside my own work for Palatinate!
https://www.theguardian.com/crosswords/series/quick-cryptic
https://simplydailypuzzles.com/daily-cryptic/
https://www.newyorker.com/puzzles-and-games-dept/articles/a-starter-pack-for-the-cryptic-crossword-curious
The crossword used for most of the example clues is on the page below. Answers are on the following page. Happy solving!
Graduation – Mulholland
The four unclued lights [two pairs of two] are all connected in a manner of relevance to finalists. Also hiding in the grid is something you might be a little worried about…

Across
1 Vocal happiness resulting from you, in the past, accepting one degree (6)
4 Two rights are instrumental to Ethiopian currency (4)
11 Excitement of past ride with a date? (10)
13 Abnormality caused by president who unfortunately ran riot? (10)
14 Messily fail to hit tuna fish, causing chaos (5)
15 Animal gibbeted, without head, upside down (3)
16 Quietly go too far to dress horse (4)
18 State of affairs in Quebec and Ontario (3)
20 Local doctor has an American measure (3)
21 Opened empty section of newspaper (2-2)
23 Loosen and take the edge off one more sassy (5)
25 Portico produced amongst the best oarsmen (4)
26 Manic unease encapsulates a ward (3)
27 Alumni polarised by new essay helper? (2)
28 Dark Middle-Eastern instrument found in bush (10)
29 Blather on about animal (3)
Down
2 One round moon! (2)
3 The first person involved is irrational (2)
4 Snake’s bone floats on water? (4)
5 Round fails to start with success (6)
6 Greens accepted into Russian party initially to earn back losses (6)
7 Barber’s so messy, fluid gets back in! (9)
8 The good of Spain are kinder, in a way (5)
9 Neuter gun (4)
15 Obtained tea to catch someone out (6)
17 Sauce symbolic of health? (2)
18 Protestant, losing toe, made to tremble (5)
19 Internal organisation of computer-related group (4)
22 Time one is due to return in date? (3)
24 Deserve to have some maize in the North (4)
25 Crafty and not half horrid! (3)
ANSWERS
The unclued words are ROBINSON, BENJAMIN, BRADDOCK, and ELAINE. These pair up to make BENJAMIN BRADDOCK and ELAINE ROBINSON, key characters from the thematically relevant classic film The Graduate! The leading diagonal also spells out the hidden message your future, a reference to the tagline of the film.

Image: Joseph O’Keeffe

