Review: Dear Evan Hansen
By Matthew Travis
Content warning: this article mentions suicide, which may be distressing for some readers
Dear Evan Hansen is a spellbinding tale of tragedy, deceit, and perseverance. In many ways, it feels like an odd concept for a musical. Unlike its upbeat and stylised counterparts, it is an inherently dark journey through an array of catastrophes that leads to no happy conclusion. By engaging with themes around mental health, it is this brave reimagining of the conceptualisation of musical theatre that makes the production so impressive. Perhaps entertaining is not the right word to describe Dear Evan Hansen, but with a sensitive cast and remarkable vocals, it was nonetheless engaging.
Dear Evan Hansen traces the aftermath of the tragic suicide of Connor Murphey. The narrative is focused on Evan Hansen, a senior at high school who suffers from social anxiety and isolation. Although never Connor’s friend, he soon finds himself at the centre of a web of lies surrounding their relationship that he cannot escape. The reason? A letter titled “Dear Evan Hansen”, that Evan was asked to write by his therapist, was found on Connor when he died. Throughout the musical, Evan becomes closer to the grieving Murphey family and gradually starts a relationship with their daughter and long-time crush Zoe. However, as the murky details around their ‘friendship’ come to light, Evan’s relationship with his mother, Zoe, and the Murpheys fractures, leaving him just as isolated as before.
“Dear Evan Hansen is a story of complexity and moral dilemma, blurred through Evan’s difficulties and isolation”
This musical is not for the faint of heart and requires a certain sensitivity to stage appropriately. Under Adam Penford’s direction, this adaptation felt personal and real: from the isolating scenes in the high school to the overwhelming bursts of TikTok from LED panels, the musical was emotionally dynamic. Scenes in the Murphey’s home had all the sorrow of a bereaved family but also the longing urge to hold on to Connor’s memory as a sort of comfort – something that Evan misguidedly provided. Dear Evan Hansen is a story of complexity and moral dilemma, blurred through Evan’s difficulties and isolation. The reinvention of Connor’s memory becomes a way for both the Murpheys and Evan to find comfort in their lives. Nevertheless, the beautifully crafted songs provide a rare moment for Evan to externalise his inner emotions.

In the eponymous role, Ryan Kopel was excellent as Evan – particularly in capturing his mannerisms. Kopel is a natural performer, forever captivating. Utilising shy gesticulations and wavering vocal tones in speech, he came across as naturally anxious and ill at ease. However, where Kopel shined was in his singing: the show’s biggest hit, ‘Waving Through a Window’, guided us through an intimate exposé of his character’s psyche. Likewise, with his interactions with Connor (Killian Thomas Lefevre) beyond the grave like a sort of Banquo, he was fluid and complimented Lefevre’s idiosyncrasies perfectly. Numbers like ‘If I Could Tell Her’ or ‘Only Us’ were other powerful moments of personal broadcast that contrasted nicely with Kopel’s fittingly anxious approach to delivering dialogue.
“Considering Dear Evan Hansen as a tragedy of two broken families, the Hansens and the Murpheys, these complicated and shifting family dynamics were brought to life by the incredible acting and vocal skills”
Zoe, played by Lauren Conroy, balanced frustration with grief effectively as Connor’s sister which is explored in the emotional exposé during ‘Requiem’. There was a compelling journey to her characterisation from being sceptical of Evan initially to gradually accepting him – even in the poignant epilogue where they meet a year later at Connor’s Apple Orchard. Conroy brought emotional maturity to the role and was not afraid to embrace its complexities. Likewise, Connor’s parents Cynthia (Helen Anker) and Larry (Richard Hurst) were exceptional as they gradually united in their grief. There was a clever moment of staging in Act Two when Evan’s mother (Alice Fearn), Heidi, went for supper at the Murphey’s house: when Cynthia and Larry kindly tried to offer Connor’s college fund to Evan, Anker, Hurst, and Conroy were positioned at the end of the table stage-right hovering over him whilst Fearn sat alone isolated stage-left. The isolation and humiliation that Heidi felt were mirrored by the spatial proximity between her and her son. Considering Dear Evan Hansen as a tragedy of two broken families, the Hansens and the Murpheys, these complicated and shifting family dynamics were brought to life by the incredible acting and vocal skills.

The UK Tour prides itself on being the first production of Dear Evan Hansen to include an ensemble. However, I am not sure that their inclusion really added anything to the production: none of the ensemble were named, none spoke, and none had any influence on the plot. Apart from running around the set and providing some backing vocals from time to time, they were superfluous. In a way, this spoiled the intimacy between the small cast and reduced the emotional capital built up through scenes.
Whilst the set, for a touring production, was effective with adaptable features from kitchen countertops in the home to an array of red locks in the school, I felt that the LED panelling was used erratically. Some moments like the ending used it as a beautiful backdrop for Connor’s Apple Orchard (a motif throughout the plot), but other times it was simply bland. The same can be said for the frames which were dropped to overwhelmingly plaster Evan’s speech about Connor on TikTok – a gradual inclusion of them in other aspects like phone calls could have elevated the staging.
The UK Tour of Dear Evan Hansen is entertaining and exceptionally performed whilst staying respectful to the subject matter. Although it is heavy-hitting, that is where the production really shines: it does not shy away, whether it be through staging or the fabulous performance of the songs, from embracing the complexities and tragedy in a thoughtful manner. It is refreshing and important to see musical theatre that is raw and inherently personal not just glitz and glam or fairytale. With the Sunderland Empire being only half an hour from Durham, and easily accessible by train, Dear Evan Hansen is worth seeing.
Dear Evan Hansen is in performance at the Sunderland Empire Theatre from 19 – 23 November. The UK Tour will continue to May 2025. Tickets are available here.
Image Credit: Marc Brenner

