Troubled waters: will Labour’s plans for water reform finally clean up Britain’s water system?
By Connie Doxat
Over recent years, sewage pollution and skyrocketing water bills have become unfortunately all too apparent. As disheartening as it is to hear over and over again that our rivers and beaches are awash with sewage while water company executives earn hefty bonuses, a heightened awareness of the issue is undeniably constructive. In fact, the sorry state of Britain’s water system has lathered the public into such anger that the government now has a real chance to earn public trust and respect by tackling it. As Labour’s reputation sours just a few months into power, it could certainly do with a boost. Failing to deliver on water reform, however, also risks catastrophe, casting the government as inept and indifferent towards a topic of utmost domestic concern.
Although the public’s anger over water has accelerated lately, the water system far from collapsed overnight. Instead, decades of neglected infrastructure, flippant regulation, and the pursuit of profits over the environment have inflicted the steady decay of Britain’s water. A critical blow came in 1989 when, under Margaret Thatcher, the water industry was privatised, engendering a profit-driven sector and syphoning-off revenues to executives rather than reinvesting it to improve ageing infrastructure. The situation has since worsened, which saw Lizz Truss, then environment secretary, cut £24 million of environmental funding destined for sewage monitoring. Climate change also adds a burden as higher rainfall overloads the system with flood water, in-turn forcing untreated sewage to flow directly into our waterways. On top of all this is the inadequacy of water infrastructure, with leaky pipes, broken monitors and insufficient capacity, compounded by government oversight and meagre investment.
All of these shortcomings contribute to the desperate present situation: last year saw over 464,000 sewage overflow events recorded in England, totalling some 3.6 million hours of raw sewage flowing into our lakes, rivers and seas. Paradoxically, as water quality levels have plummeted, bills have also risen. On average, the past five years have seen a 16% rise, while some companies, such as Thames Water, have increased charges as much as a staggering 44%.
Last year saw over 464,000 sewage overflow events recorded in England, totalling some 3.6 million hours of raw sewage flowing into our lakes, rivers and seas
Recent proposals by Sir Keir Starmer’s government to repair our broken water system are therefore both welcome and timely. Talk of such reform was key to this summer’s election and the Liberal Democrats in particular drove the issue home – spearheaded by Sir Ed Davey’s water-borne publicity stunts. Acting on these discussions, Labour outlined its first legislative steps in the Water (Special Measures) Bill to Parliament in September. If the bill passes, it will invoke a major crackdown on the water companies, who it deems primarily responsible for the dire situation. The bill promises to increase regulatory powers, so that bodies like the Environment Agency and Ofwat can directly intervene in instances of environmental neglect. Water executives will also face more stringent prosecution, including imprisonment and the slashing of bonuses in the case of regulation-touting. To oversee this change, the government has also set up a new ‘water commission’ which, according to Environment Secretary Mr Steve Reed stated, “will help shape new legislation to reform the water sector so it properly serves the interest of customers and the environment”.
Although last month’s announcements are a good start, many are encouraging the government to go further still. Various campaigners and MPs have also called for the semi-nationalisation of water companies – as is implemented in many European countries. This structure would keep the operations of water in private hands but on a non-profit basis, meaning that any revenue would go directly back into improving the system.
Even if the government shows zeal for change, the real proof will take patience and solid infrastructure. It will also require a comprehensive plan for the future, as rainfall is set to worsen and water demands increase, the government needs far more than a quick-fix gimmick to implement lasting change. It seems, therefore, that only time will tell if Labour is capable of making Britain’s dirty water system something that was once just water under the bridge.
Image credit: RichTea via WikiMedia Commons

