Review: 1984

By Darcy McBrinn

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Big Brother. Forever War. Thought Police and thoughtcrime. Wrongthink and doublethink. Phrases now abundant in the pop cultural lexicon and annuals of smug Twitter spats, but that once found their source, or acclaim, in George Orwell’s seminal 1949 novel, 1984. Adapted in 2021 by Nick Hern into dramatic form, this theatrical realisation of Orwell’s dystopia follows Winston Smith (Cillian Knowles) in the bowels of the Ministry of Love’s torture chambers, as his political follies are reenacted and deconstructed by Party official O’Brien (Sebastien Bate) and his incarcerated lackeys. Strikingly brought to life by director Pearl D’Souza and the wider First Theatre Company team at the Assembly Rooms Theatre, 1984 is an enrapturing play that well reinvents the structure of Orwell’s narrative whilst remaining grounded in his writing.

As the subject of both the play and O’Brien’s mental ruination, Knowles’ performance is naturally a relentless one, an onslaught from beginning to end that nevertheless shines at every opportunity. His performance exudes physicality and brutality, be it his traumatised jittering or tortured anguish, Knowles thrives in this central and expressive role. 

“Lazarides succeeds as a psychological foil for Knowles’ Winston, a mirrored performance that at once composedly emulates Knowles’ characterisation… whilst also standing on its own”

This skill can be found in Knowles’ counterpart as well, Winston’s co-convict forced to perform the protagonist (Noah Lazarides). Lazarides succeeds as a psychological foil for Knowles’ Winston, a mirrored performance that at once composedly emulates Knowles’ characterisation – lending the audience a greater insight into the degradation our contemporary Winston has suffered – whilst also standing on its own. 

Classically an enigmatic and perplexing figure, the architect of Winston’s Hell, O’Brien, is vital in capturing 1984’s inner psyche, a feat handily matched by Bate. Stoic and severe, leering and loving, psychopathic and paternal, Bate’s domineering performance moulds together it all, and delivers a brilliant performance of abject tyrannical villainy. 

With a play of such physical and philosophical intensity, the subtleties of performances can often get lost, but Lazarides, Maia Tollner, Kalypso Panagiotou, and River Blatch’s portrayals of the performing prisoners are discomfortingly immersive. Similar to Knowles, upon breaking from one of their Ingsoc assigned roles, they sharply descend into a shared concoction of utter neurosis, psychosis, and rigid fear. A neat piece of personation as their rapid shifting between these juxtaposed states well conveys the malleability the Party commands over its citizens, their total depersonalisation, in turn, suggesting the ubiquity of this wretched fate under authoritarianism.

This same sense of precision simmers across the play’s production, with set designer Lelia Dubik placing a podium on stage from which Winston and O’Brien review the episodic reenactments. In tandem with 1984’s doublethink, this platform carries a double meaning for its occupiers: for Winston, it resembles a witness stand, as he is perpetually tried, convicted, and retried by the Party for his simple crimes of life; for O’Brien, it is a pulpit, a lectern from which he can sermonise and proselytise the Party dogma and Big Brother’s sacred cult of personality. Dubik’s stagecraft elegantly carries both meanings, individually and at once, creating a nuanced set reflective of protagonist and antagonist.

“With these choices layered atop one another, it culminates in a production laced with talent and thematic care.”

The theme of doublethink is sprinkled throughout the creative team’s ensemble. Lighting designer Adams Yeung envelopes the stage in harsh chiaroscuros with the incessant spotlight upon Winston and the hostile radiance of projected Party propaganda. This is contrasted by the oppressive darkness of the Ministry of Love dungeons – all accentuated with periodic blackouts between scenes. With these choices layered atop one another, it culminates in a production laced with talent and thematic care.

Whilst the show did suffer some technical mishaps, with loud audio ambience occasionally distracting from dialogue, the timings of some sound effects being slightly delayed, or a scrambled megaphone intermittently cutting out, both the creative and production wing of the play were sharp and satisfying to see executed. From all six actors, performances were consistently gripping and impressive, with D’Souza doing a stellar job at giving life to this brilliant deconstruction of Stalinist totalitarianism – and its fetid effect on the human experience. Regardless of any of the dastardly wrongthink going on in your life, you can rest assured, because I guarantee Big Brother is watching this.

Image Credit: First Theatre Company