Professor Sir John Curtice: From Truro boy to Britain’s premier pollster

By Dan Bavister

As I arrived at Trevelyan College, rain trilled over the cobblestones. It was one of those late October evenings where the rain falls with no end, soft and relentless. Umbrella in hand, I made my way to the porters’ lodge. Today, I’d be sitting down with Professor Sir John Curtice, renowned for his polling expertise and public opinion insights. Known for his methodical approach and profound insights, Sir John is often cited as the UK’s most reliable barometer of political sentiment. Meeting him here, in the heart of Durham at such a pivotal moment in British politics, felt both surreal and apt.

“You must be Dan,” said Sir John, already waiting, framed in the lodge’s warm light, his raincoat still glistening, a copy of the latest Palatinate tucked under his arm. We shook hands. “How was the journey up?” I asked, more out of habit than curiosity. He gave a wry smile. “Up?” he replied, with a hint of amusement, reminding me that Sir John, a proud (if adopted) Glaswegian, holds a professorship in politics at the University of Strathclyde.

Only 58% of people who turned out to vote in the last election cast their ballots for either the Conservative or Labour parties

I followed him through Trevelyan, where he was staying as a guest, and soon we arrived at his flat. He mentioned he had been to Durham twice before, having addressed the Durham Union—his reason for returning tonight. Inside, we settled onto opposite sofas, warm light creating an inviting space. “I’ll pop the kettle on,” he said, and he started pottering about in the flat’s small kitchen, before emerging with a tray of biscuits. We started our conversation.

Sir John shared that his journey into political science was as much a product of familial influence as it was of historical events. “My first political memory is the death of Hugh Gaitskell [the former Leader of the Labour Party] in 1963 and the subsequent election that Harold Wilson won to become Labour leader.” This event would prove historic for UK politics, with Wilson’s first term as Prime Minister ushering in the end of capital punishment, the decriminalisation of homosexuality, the introduction of the Race Relations Act, and the establishment of the Open University, among much else besides. This turn in the British political tide also marked the beginning of Sir John’s lifelong engagement with the forces that shape public opinion.

His childhood, spent in a small Cornish village, was steeped in a political atmosphere nurtured by a politically engaged mother. “I went to a relatively small primary school in the village, and this was in the days before the national curriculum. The school was run by three teachers, with the head teacher being a very dominant figure. Friday afternoons were reserved for practical activities like rug making or cane work, but they also became her excuse to discuss current events. I still remember her talking about that particular political contest,” he recalled, nostalgia tinging his voice. “My mother was politically interested, though her views sometimes clashed with those of my father and one of my brothers. The other brother wasn’t particularly interested in politics at all. Yet, she eventually became a local councillor, as did the brother she disagreed with. It’s curious, really.” He paused, a thoughtful look crossing his face. “My grandfather, by reputation, was one of the individuals who persuaded A. R. Rouse to stand for the Labour Party in Truro back in 1935. That was significant, considering this isn’t the most Labour-leaning part of the world,” he said with a laugh. Sir John reflected on how this backdrop shaped his understanding: “There wasn’t much active political life, but it lingered in the air. I remember in 1964 when the polls used to close at nine, not at 10, so I was allowed to watch the first hour of the BBC election programme before bedtime,” he added, his eyes sparkling with the memory. “I’ll pour the tea,” said Sir John.

You have to be able to dissemble in politics

He returns, reclaiming his seat by the window, his leonine figure framed by the lamplight. Throughout his career, Sir John has closely examined pivotal moments in British political history, notably the Scottish independence referendum of 2014 and the Brexit referendum of 2016. “Both politics in Scotland, in particular, and across the UK as a whole are still heavily shaped by those two events,” he asserted, underscoring their enduring influence on contemporary political discourse.

He spoke to the seismic shifts within the UK’s political landscape, notably the decline of the traditional two-party system. “Only 58% of people who turned out to vote in the last election cast their ballots for either the Conservative or Labour parties,” he observes, marking a stark departure from historical norms. This fragmentation reflects broader societal changes, especially post-Brexit. Addressing the future of the Labour Party, Sir John posits that the key to retaining power lies in a dual commitment to restoring public services and stimulating economic growth. “The answer is not difficult,” he stresses, “but the challenging part is how they manage to do it.”

As our conversation shifted towards the topics of Brexit and Scottish independence, Sir John’s tone grew contemplative, reflecting the complexity of these pivotal issues. “So where do you think Scotland would be better off: inside the UK but outside the EU or inside the EU but outside the UK?” he posed, laying out a dichotomy that encapsulates the heart of the debate. “The point is that it’s a very different question from 2014 because it involves weighing the interests in the relatively small single market of the UK—which is highly integrated and has long engaged in fiscal transfers—against being part of a much larger but less integrated single market, like the EU, which has recently begun to explore fiscal transfers due to COVID.”

Sir John articulated his belief that this debate remains unresolved, noting, “We’ve not really had that discussion,” as he emphasised the necessity for a clearer understanding of the marginal impacts of trade in either scenario. He pointed out the importance of framing issues properly: “If you simply ask people about [Scottish] independence, you tend to get more who think it would be economically disadvantageous. But if you reframe the question about where Scotland would be better off, they often choose the latter,” referring to EU membership over UK integration. His analysis reveals a significant concern about the Scottish National Party’s (SNP) need to solidify public support for independence: “They don’t need to get support for independence running at 48 or 49 percent; they need it to be at 50 or 60 percent so that a referendum simply confirms what you already know.”

The discussion shifted to Brexit, where Sir John highlighted the campaign’s missteps. “Negative campaigning alone is not enough,” he noted. “The Yes side lost the vote but won the 2014 campaign.” Sir John explains that the Leave campaign failed to make a compelling economic case for leaving the EU. “When you ask people about whether the UK will be better or worse off economically if we leave the EU, they said we would be worse off on balance,” he explained, noting that the Leave campaign focused too heavily on fear rather than outlining the benefits of leaving.

 His insights extend to the media’s role in shaping public opinion. “It’s a mixed bag,” he said, addressing the challenge of reflecting public sentiment. “The broadcasters, for the most part, are trying to tell it as it is,” he explained, while acknowledging that the traditional media still has its biases. “Does The Daily Mail, The Daily Express, or The Guardian represent public opinion? No. They’re coming at it from a partisan standpoint.”

In discussing his passion for political science, Sir John reflected on what he would have pursued had he not dedicated his life to polling. “You’re the first person to have asked me that question,” he said with a hint of surprise. “I suspect I probably would have ended up in teaching, but whether I would have survived the experience is another matter! I know I wouldn’t have gone into politics. I find it difficult to dissemble, and you have to be able to dissemble in politics.” His commitment to impartiality shines through as he concludes, “I’ve long wanted to be an academic.”

The evening culminated in Sir John’s address to the Durham Union that was met with wide applause. Sir John’s passion for political dynamics was clear throughout our conversation – it was not only enjoyable but also enriching.

Image credit: Professor Sir John Curtice.