Lords standoff over Data Bill

By Darcy McBrinn

In a continuation of cross chamber gridlock plaguing the Government’s AI ambitions, the controversial Data (Use and Access) Bill was defeated for the fifth time in the House of Lords on the 4th of June – in a vote of 221 to 116. 

An expansive bill regarding UK data law, the peers’ contention lies specifically in its allowance of artificial intelligence companies to have unrestricted access to copyrighted material for generative AI training, without the need for licensing agreements or permission. Devised by Technology Secretary Peter Kyle, supporters of the Bill, including ex-Deputy Prime Minister and former Meta executive Sir Nick Clegg, argue that proactive regulation would “basically kill” the UK’s ability to serve as a global AI innovator and would gift monopolisation of the field to international competitors like the United States and China.

“The peers’ contention lies specifically in its allowance of artificial intelligence companies to have unrestricted access to copyrighted material for generative AI training, without the need for licensing agreements or permission”

Resistance against the proposed Bill has been led in the upper chamber by Baroness Beeban Kidron, a crossbench peer, advisor to the Oxford University Institute for Ethics in AI, and one time Bridget Jones film director. Baroness Kidron’s proposed amendments, having been repeatedly rejected by MPs, would force AI companies to disclose what material is used for algorithmic training models to bolster protection of artists’ intellectual property, suggesting the Bill’s current form amounts to “state sanctioned theft”. These amendments would also require Mr Kyle to provide a report to the Commons on the Bill’s financial impact on creative industries fifteen months after the Bill’s passing. 

This opposition has come off the back of monthslong campaigning from British artists, including a 50,000 strong petition of leading UK creatives – signed by household names like Sir Stephen Fry, Kate Bush, and Sir Paul McCartney – and the construction of the Creative Rights in AI Coalition to move against this legislation – comprised of groups from the Motion Picture Association to the Daily Mail Group. Sir Elton John has personified the campaign’s case, arguing that the Bill is an “existential issue” to the UK creative industry (which already stands as one of the major sectors in the British economy worth around £124 billion) and would smother the livelihoods of aspiring artists.

With disapproval towards the Bill seemingly entrenched among the upper chamber, and willingness to engage with let alone accept Baroness Kidron’s amendments absent within the lower chamber, the Bill runs a real risk of collapsing. Baroness Maggie Jones, Lords minister for the future digital economy and online safety, had urged peers to accept its current version lest adjacent legislation within the Bill, from NHS patient data reform to the combating of sexually explicit deepfakes, be shelved alongside it. A last-minute rally ultimately unmet. “We have asked privately and repeatedly on the floor of both houses what is the government going to do to stop the work of creatives from being stolen right now?”, Baroness Kidron said of the Government’s proposed concessions, “The answer is nothing”, she defiantly concluded, and this sense of nothingness appears to neatly characterise the Data Bill’s viability.

“Sir Keir Starmer recently announced hundreds of millions of pounds in funding for training younger generations with AI skills through its new ‘Techfirst’ programme”

Although one should not mistake this for a stalling on the Prime Minister’s vision of making Britain an artificial intelligence “superpower” as he claimed in January. Sir Keir Starmer recently announced hundreds of millions of pounds in funding for training younger generations with AI skills through its new ‘TechFirst’ programme and a further billion pounds to expand British computing infrastructure, all in collaboration with tech giants such as Google, Microsoft, Amazon, IBM, and Nvidia. Sir Keir’s technocratic vision for AI as a lightning rod for British economic growth remains steadfast.

But with a recent YouGov poll indicating that 45% of Britons believe AI will be more costly than profitable, and much of these expansive data centres set to be developed across Labour’s traditional red wall, however fruitful the AI industry may be there appears to be a growing disconnect between Sir Keir’s Labour and those it is perceived to represent. “The UK is grappling with a complex AI trust issue”, KPMG’s head of AI advisory Leanne Allen has written, and alongside with ever-present economic anxieties and growing voter apathy for Labour, Sir Keir will need to assure Britons that these spendings serve as international investment into the British economy, rather than a taxpayer investment into Silicon Valley’s.

Image: UK Government via Wikimedia Commons