The Oppressor, the Oppressed, and the Middle Ground
By Darcy McBrinn
Shunned in its day from critics to writers like H.G. Wells, 1927’s silent epic Metropolis, directed by Fritz Lang and written with his then-wife Thea von Harbou, stands today as one of the most acclaimed films of all time. The German science fiction film follows Freder (Gustav Fröhlich), a young member of Metropolis’ industrialist ruling class, whose life of hollow decadence is interrupted by the appearance of Maria (Brigitte Helm), a saintly figure preaching harmony between the city’s wealthy elite and its dispossessed underbelly of labourers who power Metropolis. This inspires Freder’s odyssey across the subterranean Workers’ City to reunite with Maria and fulfil her vision of peace – all while evading the capture of his austere father Joh Fredersen (Alfred Abel), the despotic architect and executive of Metropolis.
Then and now, the film is celebrated for its grand visuals and stunning special effects which still feel sublime almost a century later. The urban realm of Metropolis’ aristocracy is layered with vast matte paintings and intricately constructed miniatures which are paired with interior sets that dwarf their inhabitants, providing an imposing and majestic cityscape of manmade wonders both internal and external to the film. The city of Metropolis is towering and magnificent, its pyramid appearance in the title card presenting it like a sprawling mountain range –
An urban Olympus where its aloof oligarchs frolic in rooftop pleasure gardens of wealth and excess
Literally below the ruling elite are Metropolis’ workers who live beneath the city in its very infrastructure. A proverbial underworld, its juxtaposed placement against the overhead heavenly skyline positions it as an industrial Hell – aligning with the extensive theological allusions throughout the film. The performance of Metropolis’ vast array of labourer extras is jerky and rigid, as the obtuse physicality of the machines forces their bodies to uncomfortably twist and contort to operate them. With these harsh synchronised movements, the workers are cast like clockwork automata. Under the boot of Metropolis’ magnates, the working class are organic extensions of the machines they manage, and like Inferno’s inhabitants of Dis, their unending toil is torturous.
Opposed to the twentieth century visuals of Art Deco and German expressionism that characterise Metropolis, Lang intercuts Gothic aesthetics through the catacombs that encompass the Worker’s City.
Their forced domain is one of death, a workers’ necropolis
Here Metropolis’ central theme of class conflict is manifested, a painful expression of the immense economic divide that typified Germany’s post-war Weimar era. But strangely, Lang chooses to question the hypothetical consequences of these workers’ full autonomy. Freed from Fredersen’s control, the proletariat mesh into a frenzied mob, hungrily jumping between objects and people to direct their violent ire towards. The film’s composer, Gottfried Huppertz, includes in his spellbinding score themes from “La Marseillaise” during these crazed scenes, portraying the mob as a collective personification of revolution. This body of revolution is an explicitly antagonistic force equal to Fredersen, whose formation is spurred by the unstable scientist Rotwang (Rudolf Klein-Rogge) and his demonic Machine-Man invention in the appearance of Maria (who Helm doubles as). In biblical fashion, the Machine-Man is allegorised to be both the False Prophet and the Whore of Babylon from Revelation, and Helm’s physical performance of long serpentine movements and inhuman sultry bends speaks to the android’s devilish nature. The Machine-Man’s call for class revolution takes on a satanically apocalyptic quality. Instead, in Maria’s vision Lang sees harmony between these parallel destructive forces.
“The Mediator Between the Head and the Hands Must Be the Heart”
reads Metropolis’ epigraph – equal mediation between exploited and exploiter. A philosophy that can only be read as earnest naivety in our late-stage capitalist age. In Metropolis’ anxieties surrounding revolution and contemporary Bolshevism, it ultimately does not advocate to end these oppressive class dynamics, but merely this particular image of extreme class polarity. It suggests a mediated, centrist system. One that is improved but does not address the catacombic rot that lies at the city’s foundation, it merely maintains Fredersen’s hierarchy with his workers at its bottom – a faux harmony as romantic as the pleasure gardens Freder once idled away in.
This harmony would not arrive in Lang’s lifetime, only five years later the Nazis would rise to power, empower corporatists, and co-opt his magnum opus into a simple criticism of liberal degeneracy. And in our present lifetime, a modern world of Trumps, Musks, Murdochs, and tech bros increasingly distant and hostile to those below them, this division Lang would have wished mediated is becoming increasingly absolute. Just like in its original 1920s context, Metropolis today finds itself in a time where fascism and inequality are on the rise, a time where Heart alone will struggle to sway the hate of the Head.

