Man and Revolutionary

By Darcy McBrinn

Figureheads and icons are a staple of revolutionary, progressive, and civil rights movements. People whose name and face become a shorthand for resistance. People that depersonalise themselves to become grander personifications for the struggles they represent. Mandel and anti-apartheid, Pankhurst and feminism, Wilberforce and abolition. In America, the journey for black civil liberty is paved with such figures – Malcom X, Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks. These are household names internationally, yet less known outside the US is the figure of Fred Hampton.

Directed by Shaka King in 2021, Judas and the Black Messiah follows the life of Fred Hampton (Daniel Kaluuya), chairman of the Illinois Black Panther Party, in his fight to liberate black people from oppression and resist the system of capitalist exploitation in the late 1960s. His story is seen through the perspective of Bill O’Neal (LaKeith Stanfield), a fellow Black Panther and undercover informant who is ultimately instrumental in Hampton’s assassination by the FBI.

Kaluuya’s performance of energy and eloquence captures the oratory dynamism that Chairman Fred held across his rallies and speeches. Despite being a decade older than Hampton at the time of filming, it is this divide in age that stresses the profound maturity and intelligence of Hampton. But as the fictionalised Hampton asserts, “Words are beautiful, but action is supreme” , and it is in the recounted actions of Hampton that the chairman’s character and ideology are realised. The film’s Hampton is driven and selfless, exemplified in King’s use of sets. Hampton’s home is sparingly shown, and the activist spaces of the BPP headquarters and famed Free Breakfast for School Children halls are where he is primarily placed. The film also takes time to highlight Hampton’s nuanced intersectionality which can so often be overlooked by biopics seeking to make their figures’ ethos more digestible. This is particularly apparent in the depiction of the ‘Rainbow Coalition’ of marginalised Chicago groups, as Hampton and the film treat the racially regressive elements of its white working-class components with constructive maturity and understanding. Yet alongside his borderline heroism there is also a great tenderness to Kaluuya’s portrayal of Hampton, despite his grandiosity there is a genuine and irremovable humanity that lies within Hampton just as it does in any other. This is reflected in King’s recurrent use of close-up shots in the cinematography. While this can give moments throughout the film a claustrophobic feel, adding to the film’s foreboding tone as we march inevitably towards O’Neal’s betrayal, it also produces a distinct intimacy. It allows us to see the facial physicality of Kaluuya, the wrinkles when he smiles, his muscles when he laughs, his eyes when full of love or loss. It allows the audience to begin to understand Hampton as the embodied fight against racism as well as a victim of it – we can see both the icon and the man. This authentic portrayal of Hampton then resists becoming mere hagiography, but something more.

Yet alongside his borderline heroism there is also a great tenderness to Kaluuya’s portrayal of Hampton, despite his grandiosity there is a genuine and irremovable humanity that lies within Hampton just as it does in any other.

Against the humanity of Hampton are the film’s overarching antagonists, O’Neal’s FBI handler Special Agent Roy Mitchell (Jesse Plemons) and the bureau’s contemporary director J. Edgar Hoover (Martin Sheen). While Hoover represents an explicitly reactionary politics that is violently antithetical to Hampton’s, Mitchell seems to represent a more liberal stance. But regardless of his earnest, caring, and compassionate demeanour, Mitchell is nevertheless subservient to Hoover and orchestrates Hampton’s death all the same. In this Mitchell appears to embody MLK’s conception of the ‘white moderate’, whose empathetic but equally targeted oppression makes him often more disarming, confounding, and sinister thanthe plain racism of reactionaries. His façade of progressivism only enables oppression. Mitchell and Hoover act as a foil against O’Neal and Hampton, but also against Hampton’s philosophies more broadly. Unlike the regressive and politically complex Young Patriots in the Rainbow Coalition, the FBI deliberately lack nuance. They, unlike Hampton, are depersonalised, either as soulless and stoic or frothingly vitriolic. For King and Hampton, the FBI as antagonists represent the state monopoly on violence and exploitation of oppressed groups that Hampton was so driven to overturn.

Ultimately, Judas and the Black Messiah follows the internal struggle between the man and the collective, between individual and icon, between Fred Hampton and the black Messiah. The film finds itself within these boundaries and manages to humanise Hampton while maintaining his embodied status. Unlike the FBI, these people are not monoliths, but just people. Fred Hampton is a revolutionary, but we also see him as a friend, lover, and father. This primary motif highlights his martyrdom but not at the expense of Fred Hampton as a real human being, because to treat Hampton purely as an icon is to obscure the tragedy and injustice at the heart of his fight. When Fred Hampton was assassinated by the FBI, he was only twenty-one years old.

Image Credit: PICRYL Nationaal Archief