Aguirre, the nature of delusion

By Darcy McBrinn

A disturbed exploration of empire, oppression, delusion, and nature, the 1972 historical epic Aguirre, the Wrath of God stands as director Werner Herzog’s New German Cinema masterpiece. Set in the early months of 1561, following the Spanish destruction of the Inca Empire, the odyssey – inspired loosely by a myriad of Amazonian explorers – tracks voyaging conquistadors along the Amazon River in search of the legendary golden city El Dorado. The expedition quickly mutinies, led by its lieutenant Lope de Aguirre (Klaus Kinski), a psychotic profiteer consumed by ambition, legacy, and conquest, whose foolish obsession with El Dorado drives his men to ruin.

Filmed on location across the Peruvian Amazonia, Herzog directs our gaze from the outset toward the natural splendour of South America. Rippling mountain fauna weaves across the Andes, all amongst mythic mist. An otherworldly imagining of the Amazon flows throughout Aguirre. As the conquistadors become further wound in the jungle’s vines and coils, an almost mystical expanse begins to emerge. This same mist produces a hazy, hallucinatory effect. Like an elongated mirage, the whole film holds a feverish, dreamlike quality, accompanied by Popol Vuh’s quasi-choral score imbued with uncanny ethereality. When this krautrock music is eerily absent, Aguirre’s minimal dialogue allows simple, naturalistic noise to subsume character and audience alike. The rainforest’s sound design is serene yet omnipresent, sensorily enveloping and inescapable, like a drawn-out lull.

Aguirre’s minimal dialogue allows simple, naturalistic noise to subsume character and audience alike

Adding to the Amazon’s surreality is the titular adventurer himself. Kinski’s overtly theatrical – almost pantomimic – performance portrays Aguirre as more like a conquistador stock character rather than the true Spanish explorer of history. The mistiness of the nature is also imbued into Aguirre, as historically disparate conquistadorial figures flicker in and out of his identity, such as the film’s narrator, Gaspar de Carvajal (Del Negro), who in fact never journeyed with Aguirre, or the fantastical imagery of a treetop shipwreck lifted from the account of Álvar Núñez Cabeza de Vaca. Herzog’s Aguirre is colonialism incarnate. As he becomes an amalgam conquistador, his story becomes a fable, the Amazon its fanciful setting.

The classic moral of this fable is revealed in Aguirre’s central dynamic, man versus nature. Throughout, the jungle is a hostile space, seemingly a malignant entity that strategically floods, snares rafts in eddies, and manoeuvres in distorting ways. Considering the rainforest’s vastness, it also holds an ironic claustrophobia; the mass of nature imparts an oppressive tightness with little space for the colonists. Arrows and spears from natives often fly from unseen hands, as if thrown by the very trees themselves. Carvajal explicitly cannot parse the Amazon, “We are drifting in circles”, the monk despairs. But this is impossible, the river’s mainstem flows straight. Narratively, the rainforest is interpreted through this warped perspective of the conquistadors, who merely view it as a foreign land for conquest. It is alien to them, but so are they to it.

As the slain indigenous couple illustrates, this hazy land is not beyond understanding. Yet, the conquistadors refuse to understand it. The rainforest does not conform to imperial sensibilities; it actively rebels against them. Rather than an antagonistic space, the rainforest becomes one of defiant resistance against colonialism. Monkeys infest Aguirre’s decaying expedition like rats. What would typically be symbols of decay have been reimagined in the jungle as icons of reclamation. The Amazon exposes the absurdities of the colonial project and its inherent otherisation as delirium and delusion.

The Amazon exposes the absurdities of the colonial project and its inherent otherisation as delirium and delusion

The object of this delusion, El Dorado, is merely a fictitious Western invention, an imagined colonial paradise for exploitation. For the imperialists, rather than the land itself, it is this delusion that defines South America, El Dorado’s imagined existence itself an act of topological colonialisation – an imposition of European myth as fact upon Peruvian geography.

Herzog’s filming journey with Aguirre in many ways mirrors the conquistadors’ own. Filmed chronologically, Herzog’s crew shot Aguirre along the very same Ucayali rivers as the explorers, experiencing the same weather, terrain, and flooding as they did. This is reflected in the guerrilla-style filmmaking with muddied lenses and handheld camerawork. Which, at times, lends the film a borderline documentary quality, as if Herzog was himself one of Aguirre’s failed crewmen.

However, here Herzog splits from his subject. Rather than exoticising the rainforest, he, alongside cinematographer Thomas Mauch, tenderly and artistically captures its authentic beauty. It is not in the boundless hubris and megalomania of his protagonist that Herzog finds the sublime, but in the surrounding jungle. El Dorado is the Amazon itself. For Herzog, man versus nature is a false dichotomy, a construct engineered by imperialists to villainise indigenous peoples and landscapes. Aguirre’s conquistadors, missing the forest for the trees, are too blinded by glory, avarice, and colonial expansion to see the natural South American wonder that engulfs them.

Illustration: Michael J. Deas (Sawyer Studios) via Wikipedia Creative Commons