Memories maketh man
By Darcy McBrinn
Lifting its title from the 1717 poem ‘Eloisa to Abelard’ by Alexander Pope, itself a proto-Romantic reflection on a medieval love story, 2004’s Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind – a delightful blend of surrealism, science fiction, and romance – is a film foundationally concerned with love, the past, memory, and re-examination. Directed by Michel Gondry and written by Charlie Kaufman, the film follows introverted loner Joel Barish (Jim Carrey) embarking on a new, exciting, and altogether chaotic relationship with Clementine Kruczynski (Kate Winslet). After a sudden breakup, Joel learns that Clementine has had all her memories of their time together erased by neuroscientist Dr. Howard Mierzwiak (Tom Wilkinson) and his company Lacuna, and in a hysteria elicits the same services for himself.
The film is largely placed within Joel’s imploding mindscape during the procedure and thus it is the very fabric of memory that constructs the narrative as the film folds in on itself and the boundary between one scene and the next becomes obscured. The plot’s non-linear structure neatly mirrors natural recollecting and remembering, as details large and small flicker asynchronously, forcing the audience and our contemporary Joel to routinely reflect and reassess him, Clementine, and the state of their relationship with a new, naturally evolved perspective and hindsight. Through these elements Gondry and Kaufman establish at once an intimate character study as well as a rich dissection of relationships, and uniquely allow for greater insight and engagement with the introverted psyche of Joel typically otherwise limited to conventional characterisation.
The plot’s non-linear structure neatly mirrors natural recollecting and remembering, as details large and small flicker asynchronously
However, the bounds of these fluctuating memories push beyond the realm of just Joel’s mind. The very ordering of the film becomes complicated. Editor Valdís Óskarsdóttir imparts an inconsistent and patchwork feel to its editing as the world of reality and memories are all stitched together into one flowing tapestry – lending the real-world scenes the same hazy dreamlike quality that characterises Joel’s mind. This often has a cyclical effect on the narrative, as present reality and past memories loop back into one another. This further is complimented by Gondry’s emphasis on practical effects, memories of Joel’s childhood being standouts that mesh forced perspectives with enlarged sets. In contrast to the computer-generated moments of mental corruption, Joel’s cognitive realm is visually and literally more real. In all, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind actively problematises the distinction between objective reality and our subjective memory of it. As present reality is defined by a culmination of memory, for the individual both become functionally as real as the other.
In this, Kaufman finds not just significance in memories but finds memories as the significance itself. As Howard explains to Joel, memories hold an “emotional core”, they are the load-bearers of our consciousness, and when removed Joel’s world becomes physically sparser, with scenes gradually more bereft of scenery, supporting characters, and cohesion as he reverts into a simple tabula rasa. Howard goes on to liken the erasure’s impact to “a night of heavy drinking”. This grouping of memory erasure and alcohol becomes compounded as the Lacuna team are seen themselves drinking and getting high during Joel’s procedure. As across the film the procedure is purely motivated by loss, be it of affection or life, its connotations of substance abuse recasts it as an allegorical self-destructive coping mechanism, blocking rather than confronting the problem. Regrets, mistakes, traumas, insecurities, and guilt are unfortunate but vital ‘emotional cores’ to be addressed rather than suppressed. Lacuna’s solution to grief is inauthentic and, as ‘lacuna’ linguistically refers to a gap, empty – an approach routinely doomed to fail, as the cyclical framing of the film suggests.
“To forgive”, Pope continues, is “divine”; only by accepting our faults can growth and fulfilment be achievable and no aspect of the human experience embodies this ethos more than love, loss, and relationships
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind uses the relationship between memory and reality as an exploration of the understandable tragedy of how humans attempt to dull what makes them who they are, a response to a scale loss that feels akin to their own psychological death. In keeping with the film’s Popean title, Kaufman posits that “To err is human”, and to expel those complicated memories from the self is to expel the self. “To forgive”, Pope continues, is “divine”; only by accepting our faults can growth and fulfilment be achievable and no aspect of the human experience embodies this ethos more than love, loss, and relationships.
For Kaufman, memories foul and fair hold equal value, both coalesce into our identity and reality, one cannot be expunged without the other, and together – however complicated – memory defines who we are.
Illustration: Ashley Zhou

