Victory for left-wing alliance in Irish presidential election
By Darcy McBrinn
With 63% of the vote against 29%, independent Catherine Connolly soundly defeated Fine Gael candidate Heather Humphreys to become Ireland’s 10th president – a landslide win which was met with jubilation from Ireland’s political left, and dismay from the country’s governing centre-right parties. Connolly also defeated Fianna Fáil’s nominee, Jim Gavin, who had withdrawn from the campaign due to a renting scandal, but remained on the ballot.
With 914,143 first-preference votes, the former Galwegian mayor has achieved a record high in Irish presidential history. Connolly will be taking over from the incumbent Michael D. Higgins in November – the popular poet president, having served his maximum two terms.
With 914,143 first-preference votes, the former Galwegian mayor has achieved a record high in Irish presidential history
Previously a nationally unknown figure before starting her campaign, Connolly rose to receive the backing of all the Dáil’s leftwing parties – Sinn Féin, the Social Democrats, the Greens, People Before Profit, and Labour, the party she split from in 2006 – who have hailed the result as a victory for left-wing unity and cooperation. But while Ireland’s left celebrates, according to critics, its political right is in shambles. Compared to Connolly’s dynamic social media-oriented campaign mobilising younger voters, Humphreys’ campaign was perceived as uninspiring and rooted in the establishment. Gavin’s electoral prospects imploded following the disastrous emergence of a renting scandal; this has been met by calls from within Fianna Fáil to review Taoiseach Micheál Martin’s position as party leader.
More broadly, the result is seen as a decisive rejection of the current coalition government, composed primarily of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael (historically Ireland’s two largest parties), that have governed together since 2020 – as concerns over an ongoing housing crisis and the cost of living continue to go unaddressed. This presents a sharp turn from Ireland’s general election last year, when the country was highlighted as one of the few that bucked the global trend of anti-incumbency results. However, in this election, Ireland has bucked a different trend – the widespread European lurch towards the right.
As another independent candidate, Connolly may represent a continuation of Higgins’ socialist politics. A staunch pacifist and supporter of Irish geopolitical neutrality, Connolly has criticised the EU’s “militarised […] trend towards imperialism” – a notable position when considering the Irish government’s planned 50% increase in defence spending by 2028, amidst the EU and NATO’s drive to raise military spending due to American pressure. The ex-barrister and clinical psychologist is also a stalwart critic of Israel, calling the nation a “genocidal state”, and criticising the current coalition for not taking a stronger stance against Israel. The extent to which Connolly can diplomatically reconcile these views on which she was elected, with the more restrained perspective of the government remains to be seen.
However, although officially classified as Ireland’s head of state, its president in practice holds limited constitutional power, instead occupying a more ceremonial role. While symbolic, the president is Ireland’s only senior official elected directly by voters; thus, presidential elections can serve as a bellwether for the Irish people’s attitudes and values. Moreover, while the presidency has historically taken a nonpartisan position, the office became increasingly politicised throughout Higgins’ second term. Higgins often commented on political issues, such as international social justice, at times at odds with the government – a trend Connolly has signalled she may follow.
Presidential elections can serve as a bellwether for the Irish people’s attitudes and values
The number of spoilt ballots reached unprecedented levels at 12.9% of votes cast – the highest in Ireland’s history, increasing from just over 1% in 2018. Three Dublin constituencies even recorded more spoiled ballots than first preference votes for Humphries. Seemingly an organised conservative protest over their lack of representation in candidates, it is also matched by a historically low turnout of only 46%. A general sense of apathy for Ireland’s political system appears to be growing.
For observers, Connolly appears to be another figure challenging the status quo and offering an alternative to the far-right, within the ongoing political phenomenon of progressive populists and establishment outsiders – such as Zack Polanski and Zohran Mamdani. Having reiterated her campaign promise to “shape a new republic together” in her victory speech, it seems that Connolly will have to address the inertia which voters globally are witnessing at the heart of politics.
Image credit: Office of the President of Ireland via Wikimedia Commons

