Review: Durham university palatinate orchestra at Durham cathedral
By Darcy McBrinn
A transcendent passage through time and canon, a melodic pilgrimage in the city’s primeval heart, and a dramatic odyssey into the spectacle of music. Boasting a grand 85-piece ensemble, Durham University Palatinate Orchestra’s annual cathedral concert outperforms itself considering its vast technical scope. Nested comfortably within the nave and conducted with finesse by Barney Howard, the programme showcased the repertoire of Henry Purcell, Richard Wagner, Frederick Delius, Arturo Márquez, and their virtuosic centrepiece of Sergei Rachmaninoff and his Piano Concerto No. 3.
Ironically beginning with a piece to encapsulate the end, the concert opened with Purcell’s royally resonant 1695 Music for the Funeral of Queen Mary. Sombre and mighty, there was a great overall sense of tenderness and care in the playing – the percussive bursts elevating the performance’s acoustic weight. Located behind the audience in the cathedral Font, its unexpected placement initially baffled and gave an omnipresent feel to the music – both spatially and experientially placing it apart from the rest of the programme. Generating an immersive surround sound, this theatricality elevated what could have been a merely adequate performance with slight instances of split notes and slips in intonation, resting as a memorable and worthwhile opening to the evening.
Rebounding back to the central orchestra in the cathedral crossing, Purcell was shaded by the night’s headliner, Rachmaninoff’s Third Piano Concerto of 1909. An infamously challenging piece, its execution is defined by the skill of its soloist and their ability to communicate with the orchestra. In every respect soloist Henry Hiscock delivered. Hiscock’s interpretation of the intricate material was poised, delicate, and purposeful – his performance of recurring climatic moments throughout the second movement particularly accomplished with grace – yet still conveyed the patriotic passion and anxiety that embroiled the composer’s psyche. Hiscock’s encore, the second movement of J.S. Bach’s Partita No. 3 in E major (fittingly arranged for piano by Rachmaninoff himself), was equally resplendent and accentuated his clear talent in isolation. Just as Rachmaninoff himself once mentored Mahler on his conducting of the concerto, one could imagine the Russian having in turn sprinkled some of this residual guidance over Hiscock’s playing.
Hiscock’s interpretation of the intricate material was poised, delicate, and purposeful
Ever in tandem with the soloist must be the conductor, and here Howard would shine just as brightly. Balletic in style, Howard’s direction and vivacious spirit was almost infectious, himself becoming just as much of a performer as those he conducts. Rhythmically strong, the orchestral moments of the concerto are clearly personalised with a clear and distinct character, as orchestra becomes his instrument. His interpretation is kaleidoscopic in the range and contrast of colour, in the blends of dark and light musicality, culminating in an overall brilliant display, with this same brilliance sustained throughout the concert.
Thematically, the grouping of Purcell and Rachmaninoff in the first half is poignant. Long considered a laboured nationalistic longing for a bygone Russia – lost to stagnant tsarist squalor – the preceding placement of Purcell’s funeral march recasts the mournful piece as a structural overture to the Russian concerto that follows. A public eulogy into a personal elegy. This weaving of incongruent repertoire highlights an element of clear narrative thought in the programme’s construction, heightening the emotional resonance of Rachmaninoff whilst honouring this historical legacy within Purcell.
Beyond the interval, the night resumed with Joshua Evett taking first chair and the overture to Wagner’s 1845 opera Tannhäuser, and it is here that the melancholic mood of music began to notably elate. Infused with fantasy, heroism, and medievalist adventure, uniquely for Wagner it stands as an understated imagining, making for a more measured and reasoned performance particularly compared to the prevailing throes of the first half. With a satisfying balancing and blending of orchestral sound, Howard’s reservation with explicit theatricality allows the change between sections to flow naturally rather than starkly. Consequently, the iconic descending sequential string motif rests gently and tenderly into the fabric of the music, and grandiose brass elements are softly, rather than bombastically, realised. Ironically for the typical spectacle Wagner, it is this restraint with theatricality that enables the performance to work divorced from its opera, the overall subtlety of playing contributing to a rewardingly executed climax. Structurally placed in dialogue with Purcell – having both opened their respective halves – Wagner thematically stands against the Baroque composer in form. A funeral march against an overture, thus an end versus a beginning. This reframes the spirit of the night going forward, heralding a tonal rebirth of optimism and hope, a sense of acceptance into growth.
Infused with fantasy, heroism, and medievalist adventure, uniquely for Wagner it stands as an understated imagining
Perhaps a weaker aspect of performance was found in Delius’ 3 Small Tone Poems. Published in 1890, the piece is split into three movements, each embodying a season alongside a progressive time of day, moving through each with a sense of content tranquillity. Whilst suffering from issues in balancing – the brass section overpowering the strings on occasion with periodic clashes in intonation – the soul and intention of the music was nonetheless distinct. Each transportive, “Summer Evening” expressed a soothed stroll through the natural, “Winter Night” exuded grace and festivity, and “Spring Morning” felt confident and restorative, all making for an experience emblematic of enlivened renewal.
Finally, the night concluded with a voyage to the New World with Márquez’s Danzón No. 2 of 1994, a contemporary classical piece prolific across Mexico. Although initially somewhat nervous and uncertain with the rhythmic material, once acclimatised the orchestra excelled and filled the cathedral with an infectious thrill. Successfully highlighting the distinct beauty in Mexican classical fusion, the professionalism handling material rarely seen in a classical context was astounding. Both quality and spirit were given space to flourish. Joyous and energetic with a pronounced cultural identity and sense of Latin life, the performance made for a dynamic finale with an appropriate dazzle of dramatic flair.
Successfully highlighting the distinct beauty in Mexican classical fusion, the professionalism handling material rarely seen in a classical context was astounding
At an initial glance you would struggle to understand what unifies this repertoire. Geography, form, genre, period, and style, all are disparate. But what quickly began to typify the concert is its prevailing sense of theatricality. If not found as strongly in Wagner’s piece itself, the composer’s idealised ‘Gesamtkunstwerk’ rippled throughout the night. Every artistic form, from music – embodied in the notorious technicality of the Third Piano Concerto as well as the direct Wagnerian presence – to the dramatic staging and visuals – with the orchestra spotlit by cinematic lightning and punctuated by soaring beams of deep palatinate purple – to even the encompassing architecture – its Romanesque splendour and monumental columns bleeding into the majesty of the music. Even the eclectic range itself reflects the vast artistic synthesis of Gesamtkunstwerk, as their narrativised journey from a pensive decay into a reawakened excitement, culminating in the defiant ecstasy of Márquez, displays a notable literary dimension – resulting in a thematically harmonious experience.
A night defined by theatrical grandeur and an unabashed celebration of optimistic triumph, with excellence from orchestra, conductor, and soloist alike. Durham University Palatinate Orchestra overall thrived in what anyone would have been forgiven for expecting a challenged performance, and whilst the orchestra may certainly have been dwarfed by the colossal columns flanking them, it is undoubtable that their spirit was not.
Image credit: Matthew Prior

