The American Student: Trump’s attacks on universities

By Matthew Brookes

Harvard is one of the finest universities in the world, with 7 presidents, Bill Gates, Natalie Portman, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg being counted among its alumni. The cultural impact of Harvard is deep and reaches from the founding of Facebook and Microsoft to the more light-hearted references in Legally Blonde and Gilmore Girls. Recently, Harvard has come under attack by the Trump administration as the current great American institution that the president is seeking to sacrifice on the altar of his own ego. One of the stated reasons for this disagreement is that the government feels as though Harvard has failed to act on allegations of antisemitism following protests over Israeli actions in the West Bank since October 2023. 

The US Government seeks to leverage the funds it provides to several private universities, including $2.2 billion per year for Harvard, to fundamentally alter aspects of the university that the Government disagrees with. They want the Ivy League school to drop its DEI programs, to allow for a level of government control over hiring practices and deregistering selected student groups. Harvard’s president, Alan Garber, a Jewish man who has spoken out against antisemitism several times, said that Trump’s demands have “nothing to do with antisemitism and instead the Government seek to control whom we hire and what we teach’. Other elite Ivy League schools such as Cornell, Columbia, and Brown have had funding cut, frozen, or threatened if they did not meet similar ‘antisemitism’ measures to Harvard. An increasingly popular trend amongst the American right is a growing distrust of educational institutions; their independence and the concentration of deeply intelligent and socially aware academics tends to lead to moderately liberal or left-wing faculties being more common than not. A study by the Pew Research Centre in 2019 found that 52% of Republican/Republican leaning voters said they had no or very little confidence in American universities and their professors to act in the public interest, with 59% of the group having a negative view of the impact of colleges in the US. Only 16% of Democrats/Democrat leaning voters had no or very little confidence in colleges, and only 18% had a negative view of universities. This trend can also be linked to a wider trend of anti-intellectualism across the American right as the long-standing mutual dislike of the right and educators comes to a head, the beginning of which can be traced to McCarthyism and anti-trade union propaganda in the 1950s. 

An increasingly popular trend amongst the American right is a growing distrust of educational institutions

These new restrictions by Trump are not about combating antisemitism. As Garber himself said, the removal of funding will hurt Harvard programs. Instead, these restrictions are about control. As the second Trump administration continues to lurch to the political right, the government attempts to gain control over as many aspects of society as possible. For American students, Trump’s demands on Harvard will alter ideological views; dismantling DEI and punishing certain protests, in particular anti-Zionist or anti-Israel, are serious concerns for campus free speech. It is reasonable to see this as government overreach that will try to suppress student activism, through targeting progressive voices and by threatening international students in the context of deportations. The decision to freeze federal funding in response to Harvard’s defiance shows that this is attempted coercion by the US Government and a sad and rapid decline from the presidency of Harvard alumnus George W. Bush only 16 years ago. 

For British students, the primary concern is the response that the reactionary British right will have to the decisions made in the USA. Since the re-election of Donald Trump, Reform UK has been following in the wake of the former Apprentice host. Reform has expressed support for American reductions of support for Ukraine and his hardline immigration policies, and Nigel Farage has visited his rallies and his inauguration, neglecting his constituency. If Reform UK again choose to take inspiration from America and attack universities, removing the right of students to protest, then we as students are at risk of losing our voices in a political climate where education and educators are increasingly sidelined.

Image: Shealah Craighead via Get Archive