All in on Orange? The consequences of a second Trump term

By Matthew Brookes

The preeminent position of the United States of America means that the quadrennial election of the president is observed internationally with varying levels of interest and concern, more so than any other election. A second term for former president Donald Trump would significantly shift the way that the US looks at both its allies and its geopolitical opponents, as the values of Trump would direct the world’s most influential geopolitical player.

There would be some states which would be poised to gain a great deal from this change, the principal one of which would be Russia. The war in Ukraine has resulted in American arms being used to combat Russian troops and has been a source of great tension between the two nations. However, both Trump and important members of his campaign have openly suggested that America’s support of Ukraine could be reduced or cut if the former president is re-elected. In a speech to congress, republican vice-presidential nominee JD Vance said that “the American people will not tolerate another endless war and neither will I”, whist he voted against a bill providing $61 billion of military aid to Ukraine. Trump has bragged on several occasions about his relationship with Putin and how he would end the war before he even gets into office in January. 

A second term for former president Donald Trump would significantly shift the way that the US looks at both its allies and its geopolitical opponents

The knock-on effect of this lukewarm acceptance of Russian control and influence in Ukraine has led to fears within NATO and the EU about Trump’s attitude toward Europe. Former president Trump said at a rally in February that he would “encourage” Russia to attack members of NATO who did not spend enough on defence. This, combined with his attempts to remove American soldiers from Germany in his first term, has sparked fears for some European leaders. As a response the EU has begun to look internally for its own defence, France backing a proposal to increase EU-wide military spending through borrowing and considering changing the French use of their nuclear deterrent for the benefit of the whole continent. The reduction of American influence on Europe would be considerable, as both NATO and the EU would no longer look outwards for protection and increasingly act independently of American direction, both during and after a second Trump presidency.

The age of American geopolitical and diplomatic dominance might not survive a second stint of Donald Trump in the Oval office, regardless of his claim to renew America’s greatness

In contrast to his less than supportive position on Ukraine, Trump has repeatedly expressed nothing but his complete support for Israel both during his presidency and during the election campaign. While president, he moved the US embassy to Jerusalem in 2018 and then went on to recognise Israeli sovereignty over the Golam Heights in 2019. More recently, the Republican Party said in a campaign ad that Trump and Vance were the “pro-Israel ticket” and Trump said that he was “Israel’s protecter”. While this position is clearly a positive one for Israel, with military and diplomatic support, for the US it is the diplomatic equivalent to running up a dead-end street as it completely isolates them from any goodwill with any nation that dislikes Israel in the Middle East. It allows Iran to become a regional ‘anti US’ power, and other states such as Lebanon and Syria could be tempted to follow in this vein.

The return of former president Trump to the White House could dramatically change how the world views America, with Trump’s less nuanced views than his predecessor on foreign policy leading to significant concerns and worries for those of the liberal Western world order. The age of American geopolitical and diplomatic dominance might not survive a second stint of Donald Trump in the Oval office, regardless of his claim to renew America’s greatness.

Image: Rosemary Ketchum via Pexels