Gavin Newsom – Democrat Saviour or online troller? 

By Tom Streatfeild

For the world’s fourth largest economy, as its governor Gavin Newsom exults online, California’s emergence as a staunch  resistor of the impositions of the federal government strengthens  the Congressman as a leading Democrat figurehead. When compared to  grassroots, left-leaning Democrats like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or Bernie Sanders, Gavin  Newsom has emerged as the epitome of the old guard.  

Over the summer, Gavin Newsom has adopted a new strategy of criticising the  current administration: imitation on social media. One of President Trump’s defining  characteristics seems to be his chronically caps-locked and personally targeted  online rants on his own ‘Truth Social’. Like a modern-day town crier, President  Trump’s announcements and decrees are defined by noticeable sound bites and  phrases such as “THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER”, or  churlish name calling: he has recently taken to fondly referring to Governor  Newsom as “Newscum”. This has been achieved by imitating Trump’s extended  and poorly-capitalised digital rants, alliterative name-calling and word play  expected from a ‘Truth Social’ post.  

Mr Newsom has extended these posts to include AI depictions of him dressed  as a king, surrounded by eagles, or being worshipped by Hulk Hogan and Tucker  Carlson. Such depictions lack the tasteful, structured opposition and criticism of  current affairs expected from traditional politics, but in an age dominated by the  Commander in Chief’s impromptu social media posts, relying on name-calling and  satire has seemingly worked for Mr Newsom and has propelled him as a leading  vocal opposer of the administration. For Mr Newsom, his adept and likely  millennial-centred social media team have not only posted a slew of extended  ‘Trumpian’ rants, but a focus on ‘edits’ and carefully cherry-picked highlights from  the governor’s podcast, which has allowed an image of a polished and slick de  facto Democrat opposition leader to be curated. 

The MAGA-based media have not seen the funny, and sadly ironic, side of this  mimicry. Last month, Dana Perino on FOX News berated Mr Newsom for his  efforts, exclaiming that he was “making a fool of [himself]”, with other MAGA  commentators and pundits sharing their frustration at what they perceived a  juvenile attempt at opposition to the President, completely failing to realise the  unsubtle irony behind every post from the Newsom front. 

For Gavin Newsom, the problem now remains, how long can he keep  maintaining a Trumpian persona as a valid form of criticism?

For Mr. Newsom, however, such jibes and imitations illustrate the current  dominating form of Democrat opposition to the current administration. Many  believe that the flailing Democrat elite post-2024 are not doing enough, not only to  expose the absurdity of President Trump’s administration, but the authoritarian  dangers that inherently lurk under such radical policies. Only having casually  announced his ambitions for the Democrat candidacy post 2026 “Yeah, I’d be lying  otherwise”, Mr Newsom is surely realising he has to play the long game of criticising the administration. Claiming that his social media crusade against the  farcical comments made by the GOP administration have propelled him to  Democrat frontman would be incorrect. Mr Newsom’s introduction of ‘Proposition  50’, a staunch reaction to President Trump’s recent gerrymandering attempts, has  gained mass popularity in recent weeks. For Californians, Mr Newsom’s act of  fighting fire with fire by attempting to negate Texan gerrymandered seats with  redrawn Californian congressional districts shows a governor willing to truly stand  up to a growing sense of federal authoritarianism. 

Nevertheless, for Gavin Newsom, the problem now remains, how long can he keep  maintaining a Trumpian persona as a valid form of criticism? For some, especially  supporters of the current administration, this tactic’s lifespan is unsustainable –  and perhaps the truly adult way to critique this executive branch is to convey the  seriousness and danger of a country freely sliding into autocracy. However, for a  starting point, Gavin Newsom has, after many years, exposed the MAGA support  base to the silliness of their leader. To paraphrase Tom Nichols for The Atlantic: “the MAGA faithful are hypersensitive to criticisms of Trump because, in  their hearts, many of them know the detached and offensive nature of his jibes” –  and I think this is the crucial point, why does a Democrat hopeful have to expose a  President’s statements that frequently veer into the realm of hyperbolism and  falsity?  

As discussed previously, the surging popularity among left-leaning Democrats has,  as Evan Barker writes, left the “tired resistance”, of the old guard in last place – it is  nonetheless very impressive for Mr. Newsom to have consolidated his support  base on a national scale through his extensive social media campaign of mimicry.  Through highlighting the absurdity of an administration so hell-bent on posting AI  generated pictures, deepfakes and low quality memes, Mr Newsom has found an  effective online form of exposing and ultimately parodying a digital demagogy. 

Image by UK Government via Wikimedia Commons.