Review: birthday candles

By Darcy McBrinn

★★★★★

An ever shifting yet perpetually grounded play – in family, space, baking, and one long life – the Rocket Theatre Company’s production of Noah Haidle’s Birthday Candles cyclically journeys from the aspirational grandeur in youth to the grounded grandeur of old age. With all the myriad struggles and triumphs, feelings of stagnancy and adventure, lost dreams and recaptured ambitions that rest in between. 

Co-directed by Khaliun Mark and Laurence Davidson, the play takes us from the Michiganian Roaring Twenties to our own modern twenties. Its plot follows Ernestine Ashworth (Nat Pryke) across her century of birthdays, each one a tableau of the previous year’s – and at times, decade’s – story, as Ernestine fulfils her yearly tradition of baking her own cake. 

As Birthday Candles’ prime meridian, time and narrative all revolve around Ernestine, and Pryke stays with her audience from beginning to end. It is a resolute performance, easily embodying both the tenderness and heartache needed to compact such a complex life into one brief act, all whilst continuously leaving the audience gripped.

Each actor gives something unique and distinct to their role

However, Pryke doesn’t stand alone, flanked by a small multiroling generational ensemble. Her comically pestering neighbour Kenneth (Oli Butler) is a standout. Butler’s performance is one of unrelenting charm, the audience either in stitches or on tender hooks with each spoken line. He well captures the development between the dorky loser, awkwardly rhyming off unsolicited intended to be romantic monologues about Hindi cosmological divinity, to a content and confident old man, having changed little, but grown plenty. Butler’s echoing performance throughout Kenneth’s later years retroactively imparts a great sense of earnestness to his character’s earlier puerility. 

Whilst suffering from the odd instance of interrupted or overlapping dialogue, and perhaps benefiting a pause after the audience’s laughter to avoid drowned out dialogue (and there are worse problems to have), the cast was all around a joy to watch. Each actor gives something unique and distinct to their role, Rhiannon Morganin the role of Joan (Ernestine’s anxious daughter-in-law) specifically brings a great nervous energy to her role brimming with character, as does Lauren Williams in her congruously poignant performances as both Ernestine’s mother and daughter. 

As continual as Pryke’s presence throughout the play is the stage she occupies, neatly arranged by the set designer Jem Hodgins. The simplicity of the set, while lacking some element of pizazz, well reflects Ernestine’s own everchanging perspective on her life – a static space feeling at once stagnant and homely, both a place of comfortable routine and imprisonment. A play with such a limited setting naturally thrives with such a minimalist approach, which Hodgins well capitalises upon. 

A play with such a limited setting naturally thrives with such a minimalist approach, which Hodgins well capitalises upon

Always at the focal point of the room – despite any drama or whimsy unfolding – Hodgins has placed Ernestine’s countertop where she bakes her annual cake centre stage. Staging wise, this placement allows Ernestine herself to remain focal at all times, ever baking and ever at the centre. It gives Ernestine the agency to defiantly remain at the centre of her story, while also allowing Pryke herself the space to fully realise Ernestine’s character – culminating in a pleasant piece of stagecraft.

Lastly, being a play about temporality and chronology, the plot is structured through the audio motif of a changing year from one birthday to the next. A transitory, momentary sound expressing the swift passing of months, into seasons, into a whole year, all in an instant. Sound designer Andrew Mullins imbues these skips with an almost haunting aura, a reminder of the routine loss of time and life still left, one that steadily fades into the background, but quickly becomes all the more apparent and foreboding as the play, its characters, and Ernestine herself, naturally begin to draw to their close. 

Birthday Candles is a play of dichotomies, and the experience watching it is no different. Both hilarious and tragic, Mark, Davidson, and the wider creative team have done a brilliant job bringing the play to life, fantastically underscored by the cast’s chemistry, comedic timing, and ability to quiet the audience into a contemplative silence. And as I left the theatre and began my own grand lifelong journey back home to Gilesgate, I felt thoroughly impressed by the stellar production of this moving play.

Image credit: Rocket Theatre Company