Lucy Powell, Labour Party’s New Deputy Leader
By Darcy McBrinn
Following her recent election as the Labour Party’s new deputy leader, Lucy Powell has been quick to critique the government, saying of chancellor Rachel Reeves’ suspected increase of income tax, National Insurance, or VAT – against manifesto commitments – that the party should “stand by the promises that [they] were elected on”. Ms Powell has extended this challenge to the long controversial two-child benefit cap, calling for the policy to be lifted “in full”.
With a 54% share of the vote, Ms Powell defeated education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, late last month in a two-horse race perceived as a referendum on Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership. Having been sacked as ‘Leader of the Commons’ by the Prime Minister only seven weeks beforehand in a cabinet reshuffle, Ms Powell was swiftly positioned as the anti-establishment candidate against Sir Keir’s frontbencher.
Seeking to represent neglected backbencher voices, maligned in what she calls Downing Street’s “command and control” governance, Ms Powell has advocated for “progressive, mainstream politics” and opposed to Labour reforming into Reform. In her victory speech Ms Powell reiterated that “[Labour] must give a stronger sense […] of our Labour values and beliefs”, claiming that rigorous internal debate is the party’s “greatest strength”.
With a 54% share of the vote, Ms Powell defeated education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, late last month in a two-horse race perceived as a referendum on Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership
Ms Powell stands as the first party deputy leader to have not been given a cabinet position since 1970, with David Lammy having been appointed to the position following Angela Rayner’s earlier resignation. The new deputy leader then has little institutional power, however she is not held by the same convention of collective responsibility that binds her ministerial colleagues.
Most striking for the Prime Minister will be Ms Powell’s Corbyn era messaging, often alluding to the previous leader’s ‘for the many not the few’ slogan – later echoed again in her criticisms of Ms Reeves’ budget. With warm congratulations from Corbynites, John McDonnell and previous deputy leaderAngela Rayner, Labour members may hope that Ms Powell’s elevation will signal to disaffected voters drawn to Jeremy Corbyn’s fledgling Your Party. Ms Powell’s victory seems to reinforce Sir Keir’s ever-growing lesson that Labour’s traditional left cannot be taken for granted.
Celebration among the party’s hard-left has been mirrored by a planned revival of the soft-left Tribune group by party figures vital in organising Ms Powell’s campaign, as well as the July welfare rebellion. Largely stagnant since 2017, the caucus is to be led by former cabinet minister Louise Haigh and former whip Vicky Foxcroft. With the immediate goal to challenge the two-child benefit cap and manifesto U-turns, Tribune seems hopeful to combat the long running right-wing consolidation from Reform UK and the ongoing left-wing flanking by the Green Party.
Most striking for the Prime Minister will be Ms Powell’s Corbyn era messaging, often alluding to the previous leader’s ‘for the many not the few’ slogan – later echoed again in her criticisms of Ms Reeves’ budget.
Expecting to attract more than 100 MPs, Tribune’s reestablishment will offer a softer alternative to the PLP’s traditional leftist Socialist Campaign Group and, centrally, Mainstream. Backed by Sir Keir’s most prolific aspiring challenger Andy Burnham, Mainstream’s “aggressive communications” style has privately been off-putting to some LabourMPs, The Guardian has reported. With its projected membership and National Executive Committee platform through Ms Powell, Tribune could begin to rival Mainstream as the PLP’s driving force.
But with turnout in the deputy leadership contest amounting to merely 16.6% – down from 58.8% in 2020 – apathy appears rife within Labour’s members, and Tribune’s tangible support is questionable. As populist rhetoric galvanises momentum across the political aisle – Ms Powell herself having celebrated New York mayor Zohran Mamdani’s successful communicative “boldness” – one has to wonder whether Tribune’s offer of greater parliamentary softness will translate to greater electoral success. In an increasingly dynamic political age, Ms Powell and Tribune will need to be innovative in their messaging if they wish to avoid serving simply as an organisational highlighter for their own government’s faults.
For Downing Street, Ms Powell’s win can be seen as a further battle over the political direction of the party. With the Prime Minister currently polling at 51% favourability, the lowest YouGov have ever recorded, he faces a four-vectored threat from both right and left, and progressively from internal and external sources alike.
Image: Lauren Hurley/No. 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons

