The Monstrous Evolution of Count Orlok
AJ White explores our evolving responses to horror and the body through the 1922 and 2024 versions of Nosferatu
Last winter I spent an evening in a run-down Edinburgh cinema with a drawn red velvet curtain framing the screen and chairs to match, watching Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu (2024) whilst a slow drip of ice-cold water fell onto my seat. At the films end, I promptly declared that I had loved it…and that I never wanted to see it again. Eggers’ Nosferatu is a wonder-work of gothic cinema that, in the months since its release, has gained widespread success. Lily Rose-Depp and Nicholas Hoult inhabit the familiar characters of Ellen and Thomas Hutter alongside Willem Dafoe, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, and Emma Corrin. The cast is rounded out by Bill Skarsgård, no stranger to horror cinema, having played Pennywise in It (2017), in his portrayal of Count Orlok.
It is with the success of the recent rendition in mind that I turn back to the film’s source material – F.W. Murnau’s German expressionist film: Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror (1922). I aim to consider whether, with the widespread success of its cinematic descendant, there is still a place for Nosferatu (1922) in the mind of the contemporary viewer.
Murnau’s Nosferatu is the first piece of vampire cinema, and the film to which hundreds of vampire movies, both horror and romance, owe a debt to. The film was an unauthorised adaptation of Bram Stoker’s Dracula. It changed the character names in an attempt to avoid copyright, giving us Count Orlok in place of Count Dracula, but retained many of the novel’s plot points. As such, Stoker’s wife sued for copyright violation but, as there had been an error in the copyrighting of the novel, the damage was done and the vampire figure entered the canon of cinematic monsters. As the film begins, the opening credits roll, and then printed upon the screen is;
‘Nosferatu, Does this word not sound to you like the cry of the Deathbird?’
With that open ended question, the familiar series of events has begun.
I cannot earnestly say that this film is particularly scary to a modern audience. It lacks many of the horror conventions to which we have become accustomed. At no point does the monster jump into frame while the film’s score ends a tense crescendo with crash symbols, or some similarly abrupt sound. Nor does the film contain the usual features of blood and gore that viewers of more contemporary vampire films would come to expect. In fact, there are moments when, quite unintentionally I’m sure, the film teeters into the realm of the comedic. Specifically, the multi-minute sequence when Count Orlok, upon arrival in Wisborg, sneaks around the city streets holding his coffin under his arm and yet is not noticed by a soul. There is something so ridiculous about this moment that it does away with some of the tension built up throughout Orlok’s sea journey. It is unsurprising that Eggers’ did away with this sequence entirely. And yet, despite these moments that perhaps did not stand the test of time, the film is undoubtedly haunting.
Max Schreck, the actor who portrayed Count Orlok in the 1922 film, did not shy away from playing Orlok as a demonised corpse. He is far from the alluring and often gentlemanly vampire archetype common today. Schrek’s Orlok alternates between moving unnaturally slow and fast, never quite settling on a humanlike speed. He has long, claw-like fingers and a perpetual dead look in his eye. A further element of what makes Schreck’s Orlok so frightening is his relative mystery. He remains, despite our understanding of the threat he poses, quite unknowable. Due to the film’s silent nature, he is voiceless and thus known to us in only one sensory manner. Further, he appears on screen for less than nine minutes. Much in the way Ellen is haunted by visions of Orlok, the viewer is more haunted by the anticipation than his physical presence.
While I make no claim to have not been scared by Bill Skarsgård’s portrayal of Count Orlok in the 2024 rendition of the film, he is indisputably more known to the viewer. This is due in part to Robert Eggers’ decision to expand the relationship between Count Orlok and Ellen Hutter. While in the 1922 rendition, Orlok’s interest in Ellen is sparked when he sees a picture of her fall from her husband’s pocket while he is visiting Orlok’s estate, the relationship between Ellen and Orlok is far more central to Eggars’ film. It is in this rendition that Ellen and Orlok have had a connection since a moment in her childhood, and he has haunted her ever since. Her only reprieve came in the form of her husband Thomas but it is short lived as the film chronicles Orlok’s return into her life. Further, the physical body of Orlok is far more central to this film as he is known to us by voice as well as sight. And the film, in exploring the implied sensuality of the vampiric convention, lays bare the nude monstrous body.
In his book Monster Theory, Jeffrey Jerome Cohen proposes that ‘the monster’s body is a cultural body.’ To mean that the monstrous figure is an embodiment of its cultural climate. Thus, as these two films sit more than a hundred years apart, the two bodies of Orlok represent drastically different cultural orders and anxieties. 1922’s Orlok presents a looming fear of bodily corruption, as it is much closer to the Victorian ideas present in Stoker’s Dracula. Whereas 2024’s Orlok finds himself wrapped up in a climate much more explicit in its concerns of sexuality.
To return to my earlier consideration of this film’s relevance to modern viewers; I find the original film’s importance only magnified by its modern descendant. It does not behave as a modern horror film, nor should it. It is still a triumph in its own right. While Nosferatu (2024) employs explicit, quantified fear, Schreck’s Orlok is ever looming in the shadows.
Image Credit – Grace Gibbons

