Review: The Sunderland Story (Sunderland Empire)

By Matthew Travis and Henrietta Mingay

Everyone has that friend who starts a story with “Do you remember when…” and then proceeds to recount their entire biographical story of their first-year glory days – that is what The Sunderland Story felt like. Chronicling the foundation and rise of Sunderland AFC, Nicky Allt’s The Sunderland Story traces the Black Cats’ history from their First Division title in 1892 to their last FA Cup victory in 1973. Directed by Howard Gray, what ensues over the next 90 minutes + extra time is a fun and light-hearted variety show, presented as a hagiography of the club’s greats. Whilst The Sunderland Story lacked a compelling narrative, subplot, or any dramatic nuance, the crowd of the Sunderland Empire adored every last minute. Songs, chants, jokes, and historical anecdotes filled the stands in a way I’ve never seen before in the theatre – this is local theatre for a local audience, and an audience that adores the beautiful game at that.

Productions about football are no strangers to theatreland: the homage to Gareth Southgate, Dear England, is currently on its second revival at the National Theatre. Likewise, Apple TV+’s Ted Lasso has captured living rooms with charm and humour. However, The Sunderland Story fits into the niche rather differently: instead of inspiring tales about teamwork or didactic lessons on perseverance, Sunderland’s rendition is more of a factual retelling and admiration for the past. Set in a family-owned pub, accompanied by a live band, and a central projection that framed the stage with visions of past glories, the play felt like a Northern folk story. In this way, The Sunderland Story is less play, more celebration.

The characters served to guide watchers through a historical rundown of the club, stir up sentimentality and show the audience a good time

That said, what the plot lacked in substance, the performance made up for in joviality. The sombre opening of Grandpa’s funeral attempted to establish a framework for the narrative. The story was narrated by a local family of supporters. However, the family members remained more or less nameless: identities beyond their relation to each other were unimportant. The characters served to guide watchers through a historical rundown of the club, stir up sentimentality, and show the audience a good time. The young son provided a strong comedic element. He bounced around the stage, cracked in-jokes, and revved up the crowd. Although the humour was not revolutionary, it was well-tailored and warmly received. 

All slips-ups were left in the open, an unorthodox approach for professional theatre. Yet they were used for comedic advantage and enjoyed all the more by the crowd – the actors took the ball and ran with it. The inspired confidence of those on stage, who appeared to be enjoying themselves immensely, contributed to the relaxed and celebratory atmosphere. 

The immensely personal and familial tone was aided by the set. Somewhat sparse, a stack of stools created the bar, and a set of poles mimicked a football pitch barrier that provided an area for the characters to watch snippets from matches on the screen. Nevertheless, it was this overreliance on projection that made the production feel as if it were a sentimental slideshow of Sunderland’s football legends past and present. Whilst it allowed me to put faces to the many names called out during the show and was helpful as a storytelling device, I did not personally like the aesthetic.

From the old days at Roker Park to the Stadium of Light, the club has been an emblem of local pride for over a hundred years and continues to be a unifying force

With an enviable sense of community, the audience was perhaps the highlight of The Sunderland Story. In the sea of red and white stripes, their shared uniform created a shared journey with those on stage and the pitch. From the old days at Roker Park to the Stadium of Light, the club has been an emblem of local pride for over a hundred years and continues to be a unifying force. One character recalled fond memories of watching football matches with his grandpa. Many in the audience could relate to the touching moments of sentimentality: indeed, one highlight was the moment when retired players from the ’73 squad joined the actors on stage, lifting their FA Cup to rapture from the crowd. I would argue the passion for the sport itself is ingrained in the local DNA as, the play mentions, “it is in the blood”. 

They say that it is the fans who make Sunderland AFC, and indeed any football club; I say it was the fans who made The Sunderland Story. All on our feet for the flag waving and feet-stomping finale, the space transformed from theatre to football stadium. Filing out of the theatre, post-show, only positive remarks could be heard.

Whilst I am not a Sunderland fan born and raised, or I admit, a football fan of any kind, The Sunderland Story certainly made a good pitch. When it comes to the Championship playoff final next Saturday, I know who I will be supporting. Perhaps ‘The Sheffield Story’ just doesn’t quite have the same ring to it. For Sunderland supporters, their Story is a must; for fans of the “Mags” or other teams, there is little there for you.

The Sunderland Story is in performance at the Sunderland Empire Theatre from 15 – 31 May 2025. Tickets are available here.

Image Credit: David Wood