Review: Murder on the Orient Express (UK Tour)

By Matthew Travis

★★★★★

Murder on the Orient Express is a story that brings to mind suspense, mystery, and emotional depth. However, at the Newcastle Theatre Royal stop, the UK Tour’s adaptation of Agatha Christie’s classic lacked that certain charm and flow that made her whodunnit so captivating originally. Whilst I never found the performance dull, it equally never felt like I was hurtling down the tracks. Yet some clever staging that sliced open the stunningly decadent train, as well as some compelling characterisations, made it a welcome and fun performance. With a run time of just under two hours, for a brief retelling of the novel, I would hop on board; for a more faithful account, I would consider Branagh’s 2017 film on the rail replacement bus.

Whilst the performance was stunningly eerie, it did feel noticeably like an adaptation rather than something designed for the stage

Agatha Christie’s writing is no stranger to the stage: The Mousetrap is the longest-running show in the West End nearing 30,000 performances, whilst Witness for the Prosecution has been running since 2017. Ken Ludwig took on the challenge of adapting Murder on the Orient Express – the main difference being that he cut six characters for conciseness. Sorry to the fans of Count Andrenyi or Antonio Foscarelli! The director, Lucy Bailey, is also a stage specialist having directed 2017’s Witness as well as myriads of genres from Shakespeare’s tragedies to Hitchcock crime thrillers. Whilst the performance was stunningly eerie, it did feel noticeably like an adaptation rather than something designed for the stage.

Without giving the trick away, Murder on the Orient Express follows the story of the legendary Belgian detective Hercule Poirot, played by Michael Maloney, on the eponymous Istanbul to Calais train. Unusually for the train for that time of year, it is sold out, but Poirot uses his friendship with the director of the train company (Monsieur Bouc, Bob Barrett) to embark at the last minute. Through a series of dramatic tableaus, the rest of the train is introduced: Princess Dragomiroff (Debbie Chazen) and her maid, the annoying and overly melodramatic Miss Ohlsson (Rebecca Charles); the subtly hilarious American socialite (Mrs Hubbard, Christine Kavanagh); the understated, awkward but charming conductor Michel (Jean-Baptiste Fillon); a budding relationship starting between Mary Debenham (Iniki Mariano) and the Colonel (Rishi Rian), to name a few. However, when the train becomes stuck overnight in a snowdrift in Yugoslavia, the guests awake to find the cadaver of Samuel Ratchett (Simon Cotton) stabbed eight times. With a murderer on the loose, Poirot investigates – but what he uncovers tests the deepest core of his principles.

Yet this is where the novel differs from the play: the first is designed to intrigue and question; the latter is designed to entertain

Maloney was excellent in playing this stylised Poirot whether it be in his thoughtful gesturing, rapid thinking, or his raging tantrums – of course complete with a bushy moustache, black leather gloves, and a flamboyant waistcoat. The accent work was also good. However, I felt that the constant jokes along the lines of “don’t trust the French” or “why are Frenchmen so stubborn” from the rest of the cast – only for the gag to be that Poirot is, indeed, actually Belgian – to feel a touch repetitive. Yet this is where the novel differs from the play: the first is designed to intrigue and question; the latter is designed to entertain.

My favourite part of Murder on the Orient Express was undoubtedly the staging, which, for a touring production, was incredible. The pièce de resistance was the remarkable carriage modelled on the Pullman courtesy of Mike Britton (Stage Designer). Nestled inside was all the opulence expected of the luxurious train: beds, gramophones, and upholstered chairs wrapped inside a stunning mahogany exterior. Billowing from the wings was a thick plume of smoke to signify the train in motion. The set was mounted on a revolve that rotated to highlight different sections of the carriage, helping to make the train feel bigger: as it rotated, and other sections were added on from the wings, or furniture reshuffled, the same set was used to create the impression of multiple carriages. Another fantastic feature was the cyclorama that hung across the middle of the stage. At the start of the play, this was used to project a video of the late Daisy Armstrong – her death being critical to the plot and truth behind the murder – and later, to show motion or the snowdrift. It was a clever touch.

Whilst Murder on the Orient Express was a pleasurable and engaging piece of entertainment, and well worth seeing if a fan of the genre or Agatha Christie, as a piece of drama it never really left the station. As perhaps the most testing moment in Poirot’s career at the end of the play – the moment he questions justice – this tension between empathy, social rights and wrongs, and the law never felt fully developed. Murder on the Orient Express is undoubtedly fun, and this lack of emotional depth and serious mystery is made up for in its visual charm and flowing tracts of humour. It is certainly not the definitive medium to enjoy the story, but the UK Tour’s theatrical adaptation is entertaining and thrilling in its own way.

Murder on the Orient Express is in performance at the Newcastle Theatre Royal from 14 January – 18 January. The UK Tour will continue to May 2025. Tickets are available here.

Image Credit: Manuel Harlan