Is this our Hunger Games?

By Callum Tilley

On Saturday 3rd May, the Kentucky Derby was won by Sovereignty, a three-year-old Thoroughbred. What attracted more attention on social media, however, was the fashion. Men wore variations on British Morning Dress, and women with ornate outfits and elaborate hats. Many received praise for their creative and innovative design, with some referencing American cultural phenomena and others seemingly just being large, floral, and elaborate. Coincidentally, two days later was the first Monday in May. At the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Anna Wintour hosted the annual Met Gala. Celebrities and donors were invited, at $75,000 per ticket, to walk the famous steps in front of the world’s press. However, both events seemed to draw a sharp contrast between the extreme wealth and luxury on display, and the increasingly hostile socio-political environment in America.

Comments on social media began to compare the extravagance on display at the Derby with the restricted reality of living in America. How can we justify these displays of wealth, viewers asked, when the cost of living in America (and indeed beyond) is soaring? One user directly compared a huge pink floral hat at the Derby to Effie Trinket of The Hunger Games, inviting criticism of the Kentucky Derby as an elaborate display of wealth whilst ordinary Americans struggle to survive. The Derby is perhaps a microcosm of American society, where elite culture diverges from the ordinary experience to such an extreme that it feels like those “with” watch on voyeuristically as those ‘without’ fight for survival. Indeed, Suzanne Collins told The Independent that the very idea for the Hunger Games came to her when she was channel-flicking between a reality television contest and footage of the war in Iraq, an uncomfortable juxtaposition that gave rise to the idea of entertainment as a distraction for oppression – and one very similar to the idea of the Kentucky Derby, or more broadly extreme luxury, contrasted against an increasingly authoritarian American government.

As of January 2025, inflation in the United States was at 3 percent; in the UK, it remained at 3.4 percent in April. This has driven up the prices of basic groceries for working people, whilst celebrity culture (and indeed our social media pages) feed us luxury content that is both completely inaccessible and increasingly at odds with lived realities. Beyond events like the Derby and the Met Gala, influencers increasingly project images of “old money” and richesse; holidays, fashion, even food become influenced by this fetishisation of extreme wealth. 

As of January 2025, inflation in the United States was at 3 percent; in the UK, it remained at 3.4 percent in April. This has driven up the prices of basic groceries for working people, whilst celebrity culture feed us luxury content that is both completely inaccessible and increasingly at odds with lived realities

This cultural consumption is also at odds with an escalating political situation in America. Whilst Anna Wintour might have uninvited Trump from the Met Gala, this does little to assuage the contrast between the Gala’s extravagance and Trump’s increasingly hostile actions. The recent deployment of the National Guard in Los Angeles, described as an “authoritarian” move by critics, is both starkly different to the Met Gala’s opulence and reminiscent of the Hunger Games. People fighting – literally – with authorities representing an authoritarian government could be from both Collins and modern American politics. Indeed, whilst Collins has never said publicly that her books were inspired by America, both the genesis of her idea – reality TV versus the Iraq War – and its setting in a “dystopian” North America allude to the United States’ capacity to become a similar arena of excess at the expense of the many.

More broadly, this tension between a projection of luxury culture and a suppression of political dissent extends to a global scale. The same platforms that elevate this content also share details of starvation and deprivation in Palestine, ongoing war in Ukraine, and conflict in Sudan. The World Health Organisation has estimated that the entire 2.1 million population of the Gaza Strip is at risk of starvation; meanwhile, our Instagram feeds show influencers spending inordinate amounts of money to project extreme levels of wealth. Collins herself noted in an interview with The Guardian that “food is a power tool that runs throughout” her books, making the analogy between the Hunger Games and current risks of famine in Gaza particularly prescient. Given the scale of deprivation and conflict around the world, it sometimes feels guilty, or hypocritical, to engage with content that projects excess.  

This is not to preach that we should completely disavow consuming this content. Part of the reason why influencers receive so many views is because they offer escapism. People can escape their everyday boredoms and mindlessly tune out of the difficulties of real life. Events such as the Kentucky Derby and the Met Gala offer similar real-life escapism that people – albeit different audiences – can then consume to distract, entertain, or satiate curiosity. Indeed, perhaps a part of the reason why people engage with this content over engaging with the concerns of the world is because viewers have “outrage fatigue”. People turn away from widely-documented injustices to protect their own wellbeing, avoiding continuous mental strain at the constant consumption of the plight of those less fortunate than ourselves – something we can hardly blame ourselves for.

Nonetheless, the Hunger Games-esque irony remains. Projections of excess, be it one-time events or influencers building a brand around a luxurious lifestyle, are at odds with a spiralling cost of living, increased political turmoil, and the rise of the authoritarian Right. Whilst we engage with escapist content to do precisely that, it is also worth noting both the distraction it can form, and the sheer injustice that someone can spend inordinate amounts of money on a hat whilst people across the world starve. But perhaps, at a risk of becoming very meta, this discourse itself corresponds to the Hunger Games. It is arguable that it is more beneficial for an unjust system if we criticise and fight each other, rather than focusing on the injustice of the system itself. So yes, enjoy the “Top Ten Hats from the Kentucky Derby”, but remember how else that money could have been spent, and who benefits from our distraction.

Image via OpenClipArt, under Creative Commons License